I really like the wood barn door, but that's my style. You seem to have a more modern edge in your sofa, so you could go either way I think.

I like Tuckahoe by Hudson Valley lighting, but it has upward light. Do you need the sconces for task lighting?

How about kichler lighting 6963 structures wall sconce
http://www.lightinguniverse.com/wall-sconces/kichler-lighting-6963oz-structures-wall-sconce_g135920.html?isku=745554&linkloc=cataLogProductItemsImage

Here is a link that might be useful: Tuckahoe

No, I need the sconces for general lighting. So up or down or both lighting works.

The FR currently has cathedral ceiling.
But we may add the 2nd floor masterbedroom on top, so I didn't do any recessed lights, etc.

I have the fan for additional general lighting.
The hutch has undercabinet lighting, and lighting w/in the 3 glass upper cabinets, AND maybe upward light from the hutch top molding.

1 sconce on the left for some light near the sofa.
1 sconce on right for the mudroom area.
We can also add more lighting on TOP of the mudroom lockers (like library shelf lighting), if needed.

Dilly: oooh, those look nice.
Especially the Tuckahoe with the historical nickel bowl (instead of the glass bowl).

As for the barn door, that's the problem. I can go either way and there is no definitive direction.
1 con of glass = finger prints w/ messy kids (and DH).
1 con of barn = I can't peak at my future teenagers trying to make out or watch Rated R tv.

The door will be open ~75+% of the time.
I'll close them if the kids/their friends are too noisy when the adults are enjoying their wine in the other room, etc.