I like the middle one - the one on the right is a tad boring, the one on the left, although great colors is, as you said, a little busy. The middle is "just right".

I like the middle one too, but the one on the right is also nice and probably what I would go with it it were my kitchen. I agree that the one on the left is too busy.

Middle or right ... and if the colors blend, the middle one will make the granite and cabinets stand out.

The right one is a bit boring and maybe a touch too white. I tend to be very conservative, so i am surprised that i am not just using that one!
Here's a close up of the 2 on the right

Definitely the middle one. The one on the right reads a little off in tone, and the left is too busy,

middle one, you need some contrast...
right one too boring/blah
left on too busy, it would give me a headache and to me its already dated b/c its been done SO much.....

maybe u could use the left one as an accent, either as an band/strip or random if u want to use the left one...

me, i would just use the darker one and use my accessories for some eye candy & pop.....

Middle is "just right" to my eye as well. I would get tired of the one on the left in about 10 minutes.

Thanks everyone. My husband is on his way to the tile store now to place the order for the middle one!