Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Posted by lexmomof3 (My Page) on
Sat, Nov 3, 12 at 7:25

Other than some prefer one look over the other, are there any pros and cons to one vs the other?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Polished chrome is generally less expensive than polished nickel. It seems to be more widely available so it is often easier to find accessories to match polished chrome finishes. Polished chrome is cool metal and polished nickel appears warmer. To me, fixtures in chrome tend to look more modern than what you usually see in polished nickel. I've used both in two different bathrooms and it's my polished nickel that makes me swoon.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

I used polished nickel hardware in my kitchen. For me, the chrome really stands out a little too much. I would only use chrome for the bathroom. The nickel pulls cost more, but I think they're worth it.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Are you talking about faucets or drawer pulls/knobs? Or both? Anyway, one difference is that polished nickel costs more than polished chrome. Also, aesthetically, polished nickel is a more "traditional" look - people associate the finish with traditional british fixtures (would polished chrome be in Downton Abbey?). That's not to say you can't have polished nickel in a modern setting, or polished chrome in a traditional setting - you can do whatever you like best.

If we are just talking about faucets (not knobs/pulls), I feel the opposite of Berardmr, in that I have a polished chrome faucet in my kitchen, and polished nickel faucets in my bathrooms. The reason for that is that I find polished nickel to be more high maintenance. It shows water spots, and can get a bit tarnished, which is easily removed with either a damp cloth, or with some light silver polish. But for that reason, I wouldn't have polished nickel in my kitchen where it would get more heavy-duty use. Also, my kitchen is a transitional look - i.e. neither traditional nor contemporary, and I like the sparkle of the polished chrome faucet in it.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Hey! I started a thread about chrome (which contains nickel info) that might be helpful : )

Here is a link that might be useful: Chrome/Nickel


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Thanks for the input. I am talking about in the kitchen, faucet and pulls/knobs. I like the look of nickel better but still like chrome too. I wondered about the maintenance since I've never had polished nickel. I did notice that the polished nickel is quite a bit more than the chrome. The kitchen will be transitional, I think.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

I don't know, but I am developing an attraction to the polished chrome in a faucet. It just seems so clean and sparkley...


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

For faucets and knobs/pulls, I think polished nickel is fine. We have satin nickel faucets in our kitchen and powder room and have no tarnishing issues in over 4 years...maybe it's the "type" of nickel finish and/or how it's applied.

Where I would not use nickel of any sort is for the drains, strainers, and/or disposal flange. Nickel can be damaged by harsh cleaning products such as Bar Keeper's Friend or bleach. So, use either chrome or stainless steel for these items. When we did our kitchen & powder room, I was careful to specify brushed stainless for the flange and strainers, but forgot in the powder room. I had to bleach my powder room drain and I accidentally spilled some bleach on the drain and it pitted very quickly. I wish I had remembered to get SS in the powder room as well!!


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

I too, like the sparkle of the chrome. I have chrome faucet, soap dispenser, garbage disposal button, pulls and knobs. They are easy maintenance. A wipe with a cloth is all it takes. I found the price of the nickel not to be worth it. My house is traditional, 1920, and I think the chrome fits in fine. We used it in our bathrooms too.
HTH!!


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

I was worried about maintenance so I did a polished chrome faucet. But my pulls and the trim on my light fixtures is polished nickel. They look fine together, so I think I got the best of both worlds. Plus, it saved some money.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Polished nickel is a maintenance nightmare, especially on a faucet. I have PN in my bathroom and each week all the nickel must be polished like old silverware. Brown spots, water spots, and fingerprints come out of nowhere. Before buying I was told on GW that spots could be prevented with a "quick wipe." Bluntly, that was a flat-out lie.

Some PN comes with a protective finish that may delay or reduce spotting somewhat. Just like with the lacquer on brass, it eventually fails. This is why all manufacturers will tell you that PN is a "living" finish and accept no liability for ugly brown spots.

PN is also harder to match. Some manufacturers have really been pushing the brown to make sure you know their PN products are worth the price. As a result some of the finishes are beginning to look really strange, like someone left them overnight in a coffee pot. With PN you really do need to see products in person before buying.

PN is traditional only for pre-1925 looks. After that, kitchen faucets were typically chrome until more colors came out.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Thanks for all of the replies! I like ALL things shiny so I think I'll go with polished chrome just for the easier maintenance. Maybe when my kids are grown and gone, I'll have time to keep the finish on polished nickel sparkling new. I'm going to have marble counter tops and floors when they're gone too! :)


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

I picked my Grohe faucet which is polished chrome now I was thinking of ordering Amerock's Highland ridge pulls but they only come in Polished Nickel.. I don't think I should mix these finishes.. Does anyone have any advice on mixing these? Is there a pull that you can suggest that is similar to the Amerock Highland ridge pulls? thanks


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Restoration Hardware has almost identical pulls in chrome, but they are twice the price.

Here is a link that might be useful: Restoration hardware


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Marion, Amerock creased bow is similar and it is a polished chrome. I love Candler but it isn't available in polished chrome just antique silver or satin nickel. Polished chrome musn't be a big line for amerock as most of their silvery finishes are satin.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

I forgot, Hickory Hardware American Diner is also available in chrome.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Thanks Holly-kay, I will check that out. I don't think I want to mix my faucet in chrome with polished nickel.


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Marion--I mixed polished chrome faucets with polished nickel pulls. Many of us here have. Here's the Amerock HR and the RH Aubrey (the one I chose) in polished nickel against a grayish marble. I think they look nice. And here's a wider view of my kitchen so you can see the mixed finishes together.

kitchen


 o
RE: Polished chrome vs polished nickel

Marion

Ditto what breezy said. I mixed all sorts of stuff--polished chrome faucets, polished nickel top latches and pendant, polished stainless pulls, "bright nickel" (whatever that is) appliance pulls. It all looks great together. I posted my final reveal a few days ago, if you haven't seen it.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here