this is a picture of #1 Colonial Cream

this is #2 Yellow River

I love both! What color are the cabinets? My gut says the second one. It looks more rustic.

Here is another picture of the cabinets. Please let me know which you would vote for #1 Colonial Cream or #2 Yellow River. Thank you for your help.

That is easy. I love Yellow River. It was our second choice when we did our kitchen. Sometimes I think it should have been our first choice.

#2- It suits the rest of your kitchen better than the colonial cream. Both are gorgeous though. Good luck!

here is part of the fireplace that is in the room

They just got the molding on

The floating shelves are in. The empty space is for one open shelf

#2

better "fit

No contest #2 yellow river for sure.

I know I sort of already voted but I'm a firm #2 now that I've seen your cabinets. It's going to be beautiful!

Definitely #2. Gorgeous wood.

Another vote for Yellow River - gorgeous!

Wow - not so common that everyone agrees. I prefer #2 yellow river.

Thank you everyone I placed the order for the Yellow River. I am so glad everyone likes the same one. There are so many decisions to make it is hard. Thank you again.

It's going to be gorgeous. Good choice!

#2 Yellow River!