JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others please

Posted by helou (My Page) on
Mon, Sep 22, 08 at 17:04

To start, I want to say that I am NOT one of the people who buys into this whole thing. I think the NY Times had a slow news day & popularized a non-issue. If I had granite installed already there's no way I would rip out my counters based on these flimsy reports.

Having said that, how exactly does one go about testing a slab in the granite yard before purchasing it? Since I haven't bought it yet I'd prefer, at the very least, to know whatever is available out there abut the granite I'm getting. Eyes wide open.

The radon test kits all seem to be made for granite that are already in place in your home. I think it's highly unlikely that the granite yard will let me leave my testing stuff overnight.

The stone I found that I love has a name I've never heard before, (Oscura, but I've also seen it called Silver Waves - I think all these names are made up by the granite yards) and which doesn't show up at all when I Google it. It's from India, black, but with a lot of gray swirls and movement. I'd like to test it before buying but I just have no idea where to begin.

If it turns out to be one of the hottest granites around, myabe I'd keep looking for something else. I don't know, but I want to make an informed choice.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

I'm renting a Geiger counter and going over the slab I have my eye on. If it registers a few times background, I'm okay with that. If it is off the charts, forget it, I'll find another counter material.

I don't think this is a non-issue. The Rice professor said that of the 55 granites he tested a handful were hot. A handful of 55 sounds to me like 8-10 percent. So I think it is worth testing before you buy. Also, to be blunt, your reproductive organs sit close to counter level. So I don't buy the "well, I'm not laying on it" line of thought.

Here is a link to the company from which I am renting the Geiger counter:

Here is a link that might be useful: Geiger counter rental


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

Thanks. I'll get in touch with them & see what's involved renting it. Are they a national company?


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

Maybe the granite place will give you a small chunk and you can do a radon test at home.


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

geiger counters do not present an accurate representation of the radon in your home.

from the web::
Simple hand-held Geiger Counters are not calibrated for measuring ONLY the radon-producing Radium in granite. This means they will almost always over-respond when attempting to measure the radon emissions.

2. Not all the radiation coming from the granite that makes the clicking sound comes from radon-producing Radium. In most cases the noise is produced by two other naturally occurring elements: Potassium and Thorium. In fact, up to 95% of the Geiger Counter clicks may come from the Potassium. Potassium is very common and is found in our own bodies, as well as many foods and vitamin supplements.

"


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

Good idea mmme. I actually have a small collection of samples, so maybe I'll run a test here in the house.

Thanks.


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

The guy who is renting the Geiger counter says that I must go over the entire slab, not a sample. Sometimes there are hot spots.

Jennibg, I know that Geiger counters cannot accurately measure radon in the home, but I am looking to use it as a measure of the relative radioactivity of one slab versus another. I am not able to bring a slab I am considering into my home and measure for radon over a few days. For a $35 rental fee, the Geiger counter will offer some peace of mind.


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

Well, I tested my Madura Gold slabs yesterday with the rented Geiger counter, and they were nice and quiet, never measuring more than 3x background. The radiation testing company said that anything up to 10x background was okay.
My slabs are the handsome, silent type! Just what I was looking for.

I realize Geiger counter testing is imperfect. You will get some false positives (stone testing radioactive, but in fact fine), but not any false negatives (stone testing quiet when it is in fact hot). I'm glad I tested.


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

Check your local university...we borrowed one for my mother to use free of charge. They even showed her how to work it


 o
RE: Can I test for Radon before I buy granite? - Bill & others pl

Just buy Cambria quartz at Cambriausa.com. It's radon-free and beautiful. U.S.-made also. My budget requires that I default to tile, but I'll choose Cambria quartz when I redo the next time.


 
 

 

 


Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.



iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network