Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Posted by CallMeJane (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 4, 13 at 13:44

Hi all,

My kitchen cabs are set for installation in a couple of weeks. (yeay!!) I am going with gray stained perimeter cabs and walnut stained cabs for two islands. I was initially all set on White Macaubus as my stone, thinking I can use the backsplash to warm things up.

My dilemma: Corteccia makes my heart sing. I recently discovered it. I have seen it on plenty of website, but some market it as a marble, and others a quartzite. I NEED a quartzite in my kitchen.
I asked a fabricator that I am potentially using and he says its a quartzite. The stoneyard itself labels is a quartzite. Does anyone know for sure if Corteccia is a marble or a quartzite?

Secondly, given the description of my kitchen above, would you go with the white macaubus/luce de luna or the corteccia.
Im attaching a picture of the corteccia.

Thanks guys!!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

I suggest performing the 'scratch test', as explained by our charming and knowledgeable gardenweb geologist, karin_mt. Follow the link below...

Here is a link that might be useful: test to distinguish quartzite from marble


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

When you say you need a quartzite, I'm assuming that you're looking for durability?

If that's the case, I believe that quartzites, being natural stone, have varying levels of durability. I would recommend taking home samples of your two front runners and doing lots of tests: etch tests with lemon juice and tomatoes; stain tests with red wine, soy sauce, oils, etc.; scratch tests with a key. Bang a pot on them. Do all the things you hope no one will ever do to your counters and see how the samples hold up.

Caveat: I'm no stone expert. But this is what I did with my stone samples.

BTW: the Corteccia is gorgeous! I've also seen some beautiful Luce de Luna on GW, too. I think for people to comment on one stone versus the other it would help to have pictures of sample cabinet doors (perimeter and island) in front of each slab.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

I love the Corteccia! It will blend in perfectly with your walnut stained cabinets and the painted gray cabinets. It will bring a warmth to the entire room. Have you thought about a full height backsplash? I think that would be smashing in the Corteccia. Post some photos when you get your cabinets in so we can see what the shades will look like, but based on what you said, I think the Corteccia will be the best. All three are great choices.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

I love the Corteccia! It will blend in perfectly with your walnut stained cabinets and the painted gray cabinets. It will bring a warmth to the entire room. Have you thought about a full height backsplash? I think that would be smashing in the Corteccia. Post some photos when you get your cabinets in so we can see what the shades will look like, but based on what you said, I think the Corteccia will be the best. All three are great choices.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

I, too, love Corteccia and am contemplating this slab... the place I saw mine says it's marble. I've seen it twice and both times he said, "it will etch, it will stain." I'm trying to decide if I can live with that because this is at the top of my list.

Online, I've seen Corteccia labeled as both marble and quartzite so I'm afraid I have to believe the seller when he says it's marble.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

By the way, my sister in law has White Macaubus on her island and it is gorgeous. I'd go with that if she didn't already have it. It's been bulletproof for her. You should seriously consider it if you want easy care.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

CallMeJane, could you post a picture of your cabinet colors? They sound like they would look wonderful w/the Corteccia.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Thanks for the responses and for the link to karin_mt's very insightful talk. I guess I doubt myself when I hear stories like 'beekeeperswife'. I cook with spices that stain like tumeric, so I dont want to chance it. But when you decide on a Honda, and find out you can get a BMW in the same price (corteccia is $10 more per sq ft, but a different fab is doing the job within the allowance the guy doing the white macaubus), you have to entertain the idea. I guess the scratch test will be the teller.

CK-did you do the scratch test? Or why bother when they are saying it will stain and etch, right...sigh.

Anyhow, below is a picture of the porchswing stain (courtesy of live_wire_oak when I was trying to find the gray stain look). Ill find one for the brown stain.

Thanks again for the responses. You guys are great!


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Edited for better picture below.

This post was edited by CallMeJane on Wed, Sep 4, 13 at 17:36


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Hey Jane (if I can call you Jane...)

Stoneyards aren't very good at knowing one rock from another, so I strongly encourage you to give it a go and do the test yourself. It's very easy and it prevents you from relying on information that is potentially incorrect. Empower yourself by getting your own answers!

The slab with the strong linear pattern is very cool. That would make me swoon for sure!

Do you have samples on hand you can try the tests with?


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Duh! I have sample doors. The porchswing looks very light though. IRL, its closer to the other pic I posted.
Thanks again!


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

I have White Macaubas with walnut cabinets and love the combination. The Corteccia slab is gorgeous if you prefer warmer coloring. I think either stone will work with the walnut, but I'm not sure about that particular shade of gray. You need to visit the slabs with your door samples, if you have not already done so.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Karin_mt- thanks for chiming in as THE stone expert ;o)

I have to drive 1.5-2 hrs to go to the stone yard. Actually, the closet fab had me set on WM. I just spoke with my builder that said that Im not tied down to the KDs fabricator. So now I can look with more diligence.

Yes, because the gray is a cold look, I thought the corteccia would warm it up a bit. But again, if I find out that the stone indeed is a marble, I may go back to WM, and warm it up with the backsplash.

Kaysd-do you have any pictures of your kitchen?

ck_squared-what color are your cabs?

Thanks for all the responses.


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Not sure why it posted so many times...

This post was edited by CallMeJane on Wed, Sep 4, 13 at 18:29


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Over zealous with the submit button... :o)

This post was edited by CallMeJane on Wed, Sep 4, 13 at 18:30


 o
RE: Calling all stone experts and otherwise...

Hi Jane,
My cabinets are walnut with a mocha lite stain; almost natural looking I hope (they are all in boxes upstairs in the family room!). My GC is pricing out 3 slabs for me including the Corteccia. I have the 2 others as back ups in case I get cold feet with the marble. I did try to do a scratch test with a small piece of Cambria (my perimeter counters) and nothing happened. I forgot to bring a bottle with me both times I went to see the slab.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here