Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Is a 25% project management fee high?

Posted by austinaggie (My Page) on
Sat, Sep 21, 13 at 13:34

We've started to collect bids for a kitchen, dining and master suite remodel and I want to get opinions on whether the 25% project management fee I see on the first bid is reasonable because I don't have anything to compare it to at this point. It covers "time and vehicle, equipment and communication expenses of the PM plus overhead expenses." Thanks in advance for sharing your thoughts.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

It depends on the size / scope / cost of the project.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

Is this in addition to the contractors fees for labor?
Is this for a designer?


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

The total quote is $170k (including the mgmt fee), which is higher than we were expecting. It's a total gut of existing kitchen, dining room and master suite areas, with the space being reconfigured. It is not a large house and it's about 1000 sq feet of area that's in scope. We have separately engaged an architect and that fee is not included in the $170k. The bid is itemized by type of expense and it appears that all labor (other than the project manager himself) is already included in the other line items. This firm typically does design and build, but since we are using an outside architect I do not expect to use the design side as much as their normal client. Also, all materials costs including new windows, roofing, tile, flooring, countertops, appliances, etc. are included in the base on which the 25% is applied. This is a rough estimate at this point and we know they are being conservative in some areas, but I'm trying to understand if the basic formula of including all of these expenses x 25% is reasonable. Thanks!


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

It's pretty typical of a design/build firm to have 24-40% fees. They are always on the higher side. You pay for the privilege of one stop shopping. If you want less fees, you've got to shop with the smaller firms, and be willing to do some of the footwork yourself on some things.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

Well, $40,000 - $50,000 because it may not come in on budget ... how long is the project going to take?

Do you know what kind of equipment they are referring to?


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

Hollysprings - Thanks for the sanity check on the markup %. I guess if we pay that type of markup, I should expect that they'll be very active on the design aspect. Otherwise, I agree it would be better to go with a firm that doesn't provide or charge for those services.

Snookums2 - I know, I'm afraid of scope creep and this bid is already over the top of what we had budgeted, which means we have to make decisions now on how to make cuts to allow us some breathing room. They estimated 4-5 months. We cannot live here during the project, so have to consider additional living expenses as well... I do not know what equipment they are referring to, but will add it to the list of questions. I also want to understand from them whether I am allowed to source my own appliances, tile, etc. if I am not using their services to help pick them out - I have a hard time believing their trade discount is greater than the 25% markup I'd pay on top, but maybe that's an incorrect assumption.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

Are they giving you their trade discount? Is the 25% fee based on their discounted price, or full price? If you haven't done so already, take a look at the two "Huge general contractor overrun" threads that ran here recently ... they may be helpful to you when you are finalizing your contracts. Everything should be crystal clear to you and spelled out in the contract.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

I just got quoted 33K for labor and partial materials on our kitchen renovation (no cabinets and counter tops). There was a $2500 supervision and cleaning fee. I am also paying around 4K for the services of an interior designer.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

That is a typical fee for big guys where I live, Seattle, WA. The fee is charged on EVERYTHING!

When you do this type of project, it is really important to talk to prior customers that have done 'similar' scope of projects at a 'similar' quality of materials and workmanship. That is something I have learned over the years having spent much on my projects.

As an example, someone that is spending 50K on custom cabinets should not be talking to a homeowner that spent 10K on RTA cabinets. The expectations and the level of craftsmanship will differ significantly.

Good luck.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

If the contractor is a value, it is impossible for his fees to be too high, no matter the percentage.

Let's say he's the highest of all you bidders, but you've spoken to his last four customers and they all rave about him. What's that worth to you?

You want to give a new guy a chance? How lucky do you feel?


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

Thanks everyone. I have a long list of questions for the contractor and will ensure all is clearly spelled out in the contract, whether we go with him or another firm. I appreciate the feedback.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

it may be regional, but 25% is extremely high in our area! ... !2 to 15% is the norm here in So Cal.... it could be the current market, but that has been the norm for many years around here


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

I'm in the LA area and we built a large guest house last year. The GC fees were 20%. Our market went down a bit, but has shot right back up. As far as construction during the recession, the GCs did not cut their prices, but had more availability to get the job done when you needed them.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

I can't speak to the 25% management fee but we are nearing the end of a big project that included moving walls, moving & repacing cast iron pipes & other plumbing in our walls & ceiling, removing a wet bar, gutting the kitchen, laundry room & powder room, closing a wall to the dining room & removing & replacing all our floors on the first floor. We had a "scope of work" contract that included everything. Anything they were not sure about, they discreetly opened the wall and looked at. Our cost has been exactly what was quoted (except for the upgrades that we requested). I don't know what the management fee was but we got multiple bids and this one was not only competitive but it was very specific. Our contract included cabinets, countertops, appliances, electric, plumbing, drywall, flooring...everything and best of all, no surprises.


 o
RE: Is a 25% project management fee high?

Our contractor outside a big city in the Southeast charged a flat 15% over costs. He didn't do estimates. Very much to the point, he only did high quality work, was very well established in our county and got the best prices for materials, got premium service from the vendors who appreciated his business, brought top-quality crews, kept to schedule, and had a very good reputation with the county building department.

We got lucky because we were new to the area and he didn't advertise. He didn't have to.

In your position, I'd be wondering
1. Obviously, what's standard in that area.
2. What this particular 25% buys.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here