Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Posted by chitownkat (My Page) on
Tue, Aug 20, 13 at 15:16

I do not yet have to make a decision on countertops but am constantly reevaluating my choices. I have a feeling most of you folks can relate ;)

I have read the previous threads, including "Show me your countertops" which I loved. I think that thread eventually maxed out on posts, much to my chagrin.

So my inquiry is:
What is your countertop (material - brand name and pattern if possible)? post a photo if not too much trouble.

If you could change your top at no cost, what would you change to, or would you keep your present counters? Why?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

My counters (and floors) are granite and I'm going to avoid them in the future. Too unforgiving and I've broken too many dishes when my hands slip, and for me, this outweighs what other people will consider benefits of granite. I am so glad that I'll be out of this rental home soon!

We're putting butcher block into our new home. Trade-offs, you know :)


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

My kitchen is 18 months old. We have granite...Persa Avorio.....counter and BS. I am very happy with it and would not change it. Have not tired of it yet. We looked at quite a few places and I kept going back to this so knew it was the one. Sorry this picture isn't very good.

Here is a link that might be useful: Granite


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Mine are soapstone and love them.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We bought this house last summer and looked for the earliest opportunity to replace the laminate perimeter counters and the tiled island counter. The laminate was stained and the tile grout was hard to clean. We ripped those out recently and put in granite counters, like we had in our last home.

We were not very diligent in keeping our last granite counters sealed, but we never managed to stain them. Nothing man-made (I'll include quartz counters in that) can compare to their natural beauty. I can't recall ever breaking any dishes or glasses on them.

Here's our Crema Bordeaux granite:
Island Granite photo granite1_zpsb379ec80.jpg

This post was edited by gpraceman on Tue, Aug 20, 13 at 17:34


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I still like my granite, four and a half years later. i have brown Giallo and you have to rub your hands over it to see if there are crumbs. Nothing shows on this granite.
I aven't resealed it in years and it stills beads up when anything spills on it.
So, yes I wold get granite again, unless something new comes up when I am ready to do the kitchen in my Florida home.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We have Boos walnut butcher block and love it! It requires a little TLC but is well worth it to me.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I have Caesarstone. If I can do over again, I would have it in a lighter shade, but I love the material.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I have Seafoam Green granite. DH and I both loved it at the stone yard, but I did regret the choice momentarily because it was difficult to find a back splash to go with it. Now that the back splash is in, I am back to loving the granite again. It is surprising neutral, and the muted greens and browns remind me of being in the woods.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I have teak, soapstone , butcher block and reclaimed marble ! I love them all. I never do anything to any of it except the butcher block gets oiled once a year. I have painted walls for all of my backsplash and I wouldn't change that either. Even behind my gas 36 " cooktop where we stir fry and deep fat fry. All look like they did 7 years ago. Check the KAW posts to see pics. Good Luck picking counters but you don't have to have only one :) c


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I have Caesarstone. Love it because it is simple and durable, but if I were doing this again I would get an eased edge rather than a straight edge. The straight edge is prone to slight chips.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

brown.
would NOT.

(came with the house.)


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

tile with wide grout in old house.. Would not because of grout .. but will do with thinner grout, especially if it is epoxy as it is easier to clean. Would not do stainless or wood as stainless scratches horribly and wood got char marks from a hot cast iron pan.

New kitchen is soapstone unoiled and love it so far.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Anyone have slate? Every fabricator that I contact bad-mouths it. (Soapstone too)


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Mine are soapstone and love them.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Not the best shot but here's our Blue In The Night Granite countertop.
 photo IMG_1364Medium.jpg
It doesn't require sealing and make for easy cleanup.
Here's a better shot from a Google search.

It's been almost 3 years and I'd definitely do the same again.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We had soapstone and we liked it lot. We had a soapstone sink, though and broke some glasses. It is also a living finish so the sink never looked as pristine as the counters.

This time we are going to do stainless counters and integrated sink. We want something a little more cushiony than stone.

Honestly, though the house currently has white laminate that was probably not treated that well by the tenants for several years, and it doesn't look bad. In my first kitchen I did laminate and did that 45-degree beveled edge that eliminates the brown line. If I did laminate again, I would keep the brown line because the thin edge of the bevel chipped in a very obvious spot before the kitchen was even done, and it bugged me the rest of the time I lived there.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I have a mix of soapstone and curly maple countertops.

I would do great bodily harm to anyone trying to remove them.

Doc


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

One place has polished absolute black granite; it is a nightmare with waterspots and the slightest dust and debris. They came with the place and I would never order them.

Have CS Piatra Grey (mid tone grey) in the recently remodeled kitchen and it has been great thus far. Because the sheen is more satin, it is much more forgiving of any issues with a darker countertop (the pattern helps as well).

Had tile in the past (grout, even sealed, is terrible. Might consider the new full sheets), laminate (growing up; too easily damaged; would choose something else), santa cecelia granite (best for hiding any debris/spots), butcher block (stains/patina -- might consider in small batches, in walnut or cherry, not typical but end), and Corian (was always paranoid of marks/heat--just choose quartz instead).

I've been in a number of places with a lot of counters, it seems, lol....

This post was edited by gooster on Wed, Aug 21, 13 at 3:18


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

  • Posted by ctycdm 10b/Sunset 24 (My Page) on
    Wed, Aug 21, 13 at 0:09

Soapstone, Mesquite, and Maple, love all three for both their usability and looks.
... and like Doc, don't mess with my counters

This post was edited by ctycdm on Wed, Aug 21, 13 at 10:09


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We had white tile counters in 3 different houses for 20+ years. Other than the grout, they were easy to clean and could take having hot items set on them. Tile comes in a lot of different colors, etc, and if you're handy, you can install it yourself. However, I was really tired of trying to keep the grout looking nice. I probably wouldn't mind tile again if the grout lines were thin and some other color than white.

We now have seafoam green granite, and I'm very happy with it. No grout to worry about. I love the colors and designs in the stone. We live in a fairly warm climate, so it doesn't feel cold, just nice and cool. It was sealed when it was installed 2 years ago, and so far, no staining problems. It was supposed to be a 15 year sealer, but who knows how long it will really last. I think this particular material is resined after being cut at the quarry, so that probably affects how easily it would stain.

We put Kashmir white granite in a condo recently, so we'll see how that holds up. I sealed it and the backsplash after it was installed (same long-term sealer). I'm not sure I understand the big problem with granite maintenance. You wipe or roll the sealer on, wait a couple of hours, then wipe it off. Even if you sealed it once a year, it's probably about the same amount of work as you would regularly spend washing off the counters in a few days. It's much less time than I ever spent trying to clean the grout on the tile counters we used to have, and that had to be done several times a year.

I would get granite again, but I would also seriously consider other materials too, depending on the design/style of the kitchen.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Caesarstone Smoky Ash. It's pretty care-free and is a nice counterpoint to white cabinets. However, I'm a counter clean freak and I can't see anything on mine, having to go by touch to find crumbs and missed drips.

It's not that I dislike my counters, but if I were doing it again, if I could afford it I would get quartzite, because I don't think I could take marble's etching.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I currently have arctic cream granite. I love it. I'd get it again in a heart beat. It is hard and cold (the cons, I guess), but it is very pretty and just feels so...I don't know, "organic" is the best word that comes to mind. I LOVE the fact I have a beautiful sheet of rock in my kitchen.

I've also had Corian in the past. I liked that too. I know it gets a lot of hate around here, but I liked both the Corian and the integrated sink that came with it. Yes it is "plastic". But it cleaned up like a dream and it felt softer and warmer than the granite does.

I would have been perfectly fine with using Corian again in the new house, but I just wanted to try something different.

This is a pic of the granite. It looks like Cookies and Cream Ice Cream. :)

This post was edited by patriceny on Wed, Aug 21, 13 at 10:29


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I've had new counters now for about four months. I have unoiled soapstone in part of the kitchen. I like the grey, more matte look of it, but it actually more of a PIA to keep looking good than I think it would be if it were oiled. If I just casually wipe them down with a soapy dishcloth, I can get splotches. If I really want it to look good and in the more original state, I have to spray with Simple Green, wipe down, and then wipe dry with a microfiber cloth.

I also have honed carrera marble on a different set of counters (the ones that don't get as much heavy use). My experience so far is that they are really easy care, but, as I said, these counters don't get the bulk of the everyday cooking duty.

I'd install both again.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I still love looking at my Typhoon Green granite 2 years in. But for function, I'm really happy with the 24" of built-in Boos butcher block near the cooktop. So yes, I'd do exactly the same again. You may have already seen this picture; I've posted it before.

 photo P2030319.jpg


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We have quartz: Cambria Canterbury. Very happy with the look and ease of maintenance.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

chicgeek, that is one of the Cambria colors I am considering. Could you possibly post a pic?


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We put granite in a couple of months ago. I absolutely love my counters! They are called Black Coffee and are in a leathered finish.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Soapstone and Verde marble in the kitchen, awesome wouldn't change it. Granite in the kids bath, works very well and looks good. Carrara marble in the master bath, it's fine, DW loves it. There all pretty durable and trouble free.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We just finished our kitchen remodel in April and went with granite - Typhoon Bordeaux Green - and I love them. I fell in love with the veining, but more importantly it will hide imperfections down the road. I discover some part I love more every day!

(Before dishwasher went in!)


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

akcorcoran - that has got to be the most beautiful granite I have ever seen...WOW!

To answer the original question, we just had our granite installed yesterday. It was a category A granite that only cost us $29.99 per sq ft. The color is less unique than most I am seeing posted here but for the price I'm pretty happy with it. The only thing that concerns me are all the fissures. They feel smooth to the touch, but I'm hoping dough doesn't get stuck to it.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I had granite for 6 years at my old house, and installed it again at my new home.

I love the functionality, no fear of hot items on it like laminate or solid surfaces. The no maintenance is also a big plus for me. It's also very unique, one of a kind material (not everyone's cup of tea, I'm sure) but we love it and it gets a lot of compliments.

akcorcoran...I love your typhoon, we almost went with it, it's lovely! It also looks like you went with a Thermador cook top...so did we, and are very happy with it!

I don't think soapstone was the look we wanted color-wise, and even though we liked marble, we were a bit afraid of etching and staining....I'm way to anal apparently...ask my wife!

The granite shown does a great job of hiding crumbs and dust, too. With some other granites, you can see streaks, crumbs, fingerprints, etc.

EDIT...Mine is has a lot of fissures and is not glass-smooth. We have no trouble rolling out pizza dough...we just keep the surface floured well and it's fine.

This post was edited by bowyer123 on Wed, Aug 21, 13 at 18:14


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I have had tile which I would never do again because of the grout lines getting dirty and it being too hard to keep clean. I have had granite which looked beautiful but showed water marks and heat rings easily despite it being sealed every year. The sealing was also a pain to do so this time I opted for Caesarstone quartz. Haven't had it long enough to review, but so far, I like that I don't have to seal it and that it is not showing stains from water or heat the way the granite did. But I still think certain granites can really be a show piece.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Danby Marble. It chips, it etches. I would not recommend it if you want something with the utmost durability, but for me personally, in my 1927 kitchen, it is perfect. Cannot imagine any other counter for my kitchen. It just works in the room and I love the look of it.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Danby Marble. It chips, it etches. I would not recommend it if you want something with the utmost durability, but for me personally, in my 1927 kitchen, it is perfect. Cannot imagine any other counter for my kitchen. It just works in the room and I love the look of it.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We have soapstone, white macabus quartzite and raven Caesarstone. Love them all, wouldn't change any of them.

We have been talking about moving and the thought of leaving my kitchen (counters) behind makes me sad.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I am in an apartment during remodel and we have a dark faux granite pattern and I do not like that I cannot easily see the dirt for cleaning. Our home had white counters and I liked that for cleaning.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Mine are Vermont Imperial Danby marble and Walnut and I LOVE both of them!


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

And the walnut island.. finished with Satin Waterlox.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Chitowncat: Here is a photo I took this morning of the Cambria Canterbury. I purposely chose this section so you could see where it is seamed from a distance (Scrabble Mug is on seam). It is so faint that I always have to run my hand over the counter top to feel where it is. We were fortunate to be able to look at the slabs before they were fabricated to ensure that the color/continuity would be a good match.

We really liked this Cambria selection because it had an organic, stone-like look (which I preferred) and the ease of maintenance of quartz (which my husband really wanted).


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Last house, had very dark granite (Uba Tuba)....hated them. It was a 3 step process in cleaning them....to get them to look nice and shiny.

This time around, I wanted light tops! So, I went with a marble look-a-like by Silestone called Lagoon. I love it in it's simplicity, yet it's elegant....at the same time, charming....EASY to clean!


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

3littlefishies,
how is your Imperial marble holding up so far?


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Holding up great! A couple of etches but nothing major at all. Also we do most prep on the island which is walnut so that certainly helps... : )


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

chicgeek,
A million thanks for posting the picture. Our cabinets will be very similar to yours so that gives me a great image to consider.

Always nice to meet a fellow Scrabble player . . . ;)


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We have Cambria Bradshaw. Have only had them for a couple of months, but I love them. I think they are beautiful and I love the way they feel.

Before that, we had Corian. I really liked that too and loved the matching sink. But we rented out our house while we lived in Germany for two years and the tenants burned them. :(

Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

granite, "sedna" or "magma supreme" counters....

love them would definitely do granite again..
ease of cleaning and they can take abuse, no staining like laminate, which we had before...
picture poohpup's counters, that's what mine are....

best of luck in whatever you decide!!!!


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Any more thoughts, anyone? All of your opinions and photos have been extremely helpful!

I am getting closer to having to make a decision -- am thinking about a medium tone quartz on the island (3 by 7 feet) and a lighter Corian on the perimeter.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

To add to the list: we chose Vicostone/Pental Quartz in "Tobacco". We just had it installed this Monday. We chose it for the low maintenance aspect as well as the beauty. Tobacco is a cream/beige/taupe/black veined with little bordeaux garnet like dots. We wanted something neutral that had a natural look and this fit perfectly for us. Our kitchen has white cabinets with a medium brown/honey oak floors.

When the kitchen will finally done, up and running, I hope that we will be very happy with our choice. Only time will tell.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

"I love the functionality, no fear of hot items on it like laminate or solid surfaces."

bowyer123:

Respectfully, I can't let you perpetuate this myth. The Marble Institute of America recommends trivet use with all natural stone counters, same as quartz and solid surface manufacturers. That make them equal in the heat resistance department.

Yes, there are plenty of folks that will provide anecdotal evidence to the contrary. I'll be glad to take them on my next heat-damaged stone call.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Two of the fabricators I talked to (including the one I used) agree with Trebuchet. They said not to plop very hot pans down on granite. Lots of people put hot pans on their stone counters and nothing bad happens, but I'm not taking the chance. So "no need for trivet" is not a reason to get granite.

Does this apply to soapstone, too? Can you put hot pans down on stainless? Or wood? Just curious.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

We are putting granite - Tropical Brown - in the kitchen in our new house. After having laminate counters for decades (ick), granite is going to be a new experience. I'm excited!

Regarding heat resistance - I understand that while granite doesn't scorch, it is *possible* for it to crack. That could happen if you put a very hot pan on a previously undetected crack/weakened area. The extreme heat difference (very hot pan/cold counter) *could* cause the counter to crack - major damage. That sounds like it doesn't happen very often, but since it could happen - why take the risk?

BUT - in my house, we microwave a fair amount. Would a dish coming from the MW to the countertop be hot enough to risk heat damage? Seems like dishes that have been in the MW, while hot, don't get as hot as a dish right from the oven/range. Or is it better to assume that if I don't want to touch something with my bare hands because it's too hot, that it shouldn't touch the granite, either?

I've been told that Tropical Brown is practically bulletproof. Does that mean it's more heat resistant, or what?


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

I've not used a trivet since my soapstone was installed in August. Heat doesn't bother them.


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

Formica....and I'll probably do them again. I can't find anything else as forgiving and low maintenance. My friend has granite and they're hard and cold...but we have long, cold winters and I saw them at Christmas.

I really like Trailrunner's kitchen and will probably do something like that...mixing other finishes in that work in each area. I know soapstone is lovely and lots of people really like it, but it reminds me of my chemistry class, which was not my favorite.

Marble would be wonderful, especially in the baking area and I wanted a wood top on the island, but now I plan to use a kitchen table (still wood) instead.

Have fun with your kitchen :)


 o
RE: My counters are X and I would/would not get them again . . .

OP, I can add my experience now! When this thread was first around, I didn't have counters yet.

I went from 24-yr-old laminate (that held up extremely well, but was ugly), to Cambria quartz, color Somerset. I LOVE the way it looks, and the way it feels. I love my undermount sink.

The only adjustment is that it is much harder than the laminate - when I set stoneware plates or bowls on the counter, they go "clink" instead of "thud". Not a problem - just a difference (and certainly no surprise).

I would do it again - absolutely.

 photo IMG_0920_zps3c83a9ee.jpg


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here