Our counters are very similar. We went with Martha Stewart Mushroom. Love that color!

I have Cloud White cabinets (love the color). I think your quartz will look nice with them. Personally I would avoid a blue undertone anywhere, but esp. with the creaminess of Cloud White. What will your floors be? I have dark gray quartz counters so I have good contrast and variety in the tones. I think a darker warm gray would be nice for your island.

Good luck. Be sure to tell us what you end up choosing. Pics would be even better.

I looked into Martha Stewart's mushroom and I really like it too! The darker tone of it looks really nice

After hours and hours of research on the internet I thought Fieldstone might be a safe bet, but seeing the sample I painted in person, its not for me. It looks so beautiful in Sally's kitchen, but just doesn't quite work for what I was looking for.

My floors are a rustic brown wood with no real obvious color undertones. They are somewhere in-between medium and dark. I'm going to start looking into some darker options!

Thanks so much guys :)

I struggled with this too, i did the white dove, and then a section in stone harbor gray Bm. It;s alittle darker than the revere pewter, but not too dark.

I love dark grey so I'd almost be thinking like BM Deep Creek? A lighter one might be BM Sandy Creek Grey but maybe too greigish depending on your space? Willow Creek maybe? Maybe I'm just really into creeks.

I am buying new construction too and am in the process of picking colors. We are going with BM simply white cabinets with white carrara marble countertops and I am painting my island BM kendall charcoal. It's so pretty!! Do a search for kendall charcoal islands on houzz.com. I have an open floor plan as well and am going to paint my walls a light gray. I had looked at revere pewter but found it to be a little too beige for me. I bought a sample of ozark shadows and smoke embers to try out over the weekend! Hopefully j can decide soon so I can stop driving myself crazy :)
Good Luck to ya!

michelle16: Like your kitchen. Any other pictures?

Oh michelle16, your kitchen is really lovely! I love the gray color you selected with the white.

Thanks guys, if you google the title almost finished...lots of pics there is a thread from this forum with lots of pictures. Backsplash should be coming soon!