Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Can this backsplash and granite work?

Posted by aprilh (My Page) on
Tue, Jul 15, 14 at 22:07

We are building a 'spec' home - spec in quotes because even though that is what it is technically, we put a contract on it when the lot was first purchased and customized it how we wanted. But now that it is being built, the builder can't make any changes. Which beings me to the kitchen. I have had this vision of my kitchen for a while now - dark floors, light colored cabs, neutral/warm colors. Well the granite we were going to use came in and it had some strange colors in it so I had to chose another. Somehow in the process, the backsplash did not get updated and now I feel the colors clash. Here is a close up of one of the counters. The backsplash looks warm to me and the granite more cool. Although in person, the granite does have some warm brownish tones in it, it's just hard to pick up in the pic.

 photo 179CABFE-F9BD-41A9-BC81-F9745E527D10_zpsy2dskam9.jpg

 photo A422E6D6-9FB9-4A8F-BB49-0032189B461B_zpsrqrlbjwp.jpg

Behind the range. Maybe these colors will help tie in the SS appliances and darker wood floors?

 photo 643D7ED4-79A6-4309-A3A6-18A095E33FB3_zpsydzvc6jq.jpg

And full picture of the kitchen to give you an overall feel. Sorry I couldn't get a picture of the granite with it taped up. A picture of the slab is posted right after.

 photo C4E92468-07C8-40B4-9E0E-EDF82102B78B_zpsrocdlek4.jpg

 photo 22FDF69C-D5B8-4757-9012-47642F0BBCA0_zps0mzxa7pm.jpg

I'm torn. I don't have the vision to be able to tell if this will work out when it's all done. Is there a way to make this work? If not, I am willing to change it after we close but would it be easier to change the backsplash or change the granite? I'm thinking just change the granite but would that rip up the backsplash in the process? I just don't know. Would love to have some feedback!

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

I like it. It's a terrific layout and am confident you will adore it...once that brown wrapping is off and the kitchen becomes truly yours, with all your stuff. are a lucky family!

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

To my eye it's not an optimal combination.

It will be much less expensive to change the bs than the granite, and less expensive still to simply modify the tile. I would remove a line of subway tiles, preferably the second or third line from the counter top, and replace it with the elongated grey mosaic tiles that outline your behind-the-range mural. It will incorporate some of the cool into the warm in a way that looks purposeful, and it will be relatively inexpensive.

This post was edited by EAM44 on Tue, Jul 15, 14 at 22:25

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

I don't like them together. I also don't like the little mosaic sqs in the part over the stove. Or the 'frame' around it.

I'd change the BS part. The granite is busy, I'd go with something very plain for the BS. like white tile with maybe black or dark grey pencil line tile across it (maybe just 1 line of it). maybe over the stove top a block of the tiles on the diamond angle outlined with blk or dk grey trim? you'd probably need to draw that out /photoshop it to see if you want something like that.

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

I really like your granite. I don't think the backsplash compliments it. Lovely kitchen.

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

Beautiful kitchen you do not want to screw up, so yes, sorry they clash. The border on the framed area also clashes, too busy, but should be able to remove if you could size something else to fit. But maybe you love it as is.

Which do you like better to keep? Which is easier to find something else that works? Maybe work both angles and see what combinations you come up with to choose from.

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

What pretty granite!

The white cabs and dark floor sound cool, not warm and this nice granite seems great choice while the tile seems to be what doesnt match as too warm. Tile could be better with a warmer granite but not thinking as great a match as youve already got going wit white cabs, dark floors and current granite.

I agree with desert on the framed tile - I do like diagonal / diamond pattern backsplash but never been a fan of a frame of tile with tile inside although see it frequently enough to know theres an appeal to others. To me this framing has seemed nicer when outer tiles larger, inner frame tiles smaller.

If you still want the tile / warm, think you dont want to keep this granite but shame, such pretty granite and it does match white cabs / dark floor.

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

I feel the tile is suited to a more casual, rustic kitchen. I like the idea of the framed area, but the frame itself is too eye catching. You see the frame before anything else in that area. It should be a more subtle frame. Your kitchen to me looks more classic and formal, with that lovely trim work. What about a glass or crackled subway tile? I like the granite slab with the white cabinets. Keep the grey tones going in the backsplash.

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

I agree the inset tiles of the frame are also too large. Moreover, renov8 makes a good point about the rustic tumbled stone. There is a discord there with your classic more delicate cabinetry; one that doesn't seem it will work.

I'd redo the backsplash. Do you have any inspiration photos of what you are going for?

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

Such helpful suggestions. Thank you to everyone who gave their input. I feel I need to wait until everything is finished before I make a decision. I went by yesterday and light fixtures have been installed. They are Kichler Lacey in ORB and that changes things up a bit too. We are going by tomorrow and I will try to take updated pics then but here are the pendants and chandelier in the bfst room

 photo 88830D2C-E0EC-440C-A858-F6A614FA1E20_zpsxmgzbnst.jpg

 photo 5D85D296-0DDD-4C71-AC72-8C02E33807FC_zpssyeh2jyj.jpg

Here are a few inspiration pictures I like

 photo 623F0A07-8289-44E1-A78E-6C34B78B4BE2_zpszgevflsh.png

Floors are a little shiny in this one but I like the color
 photo AF9112B3-0E53-4E4E-B389-AB150F31011A_zpssrlsojnt.jpg

 photo 1642BCA7-45CC-4BE4-A4B5-D3DE3BC4B0C1_zps70anfnwk.jpg

 photo C4ABD893-5A36-45CF-B69A-E9A055637AA4_zpsgxpcis6v.jpg

This post was edited by aprilh on Thu, Jul 17, 14 at 21:33

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

Great light fixtures. Wait til it's all in. Get all your "stuff" on your counters & see how you feel then.
Edit: love the backsplash in inspiration pic #2.

This post was edited by romy718 on Fri, Jul 18, 14 at 11:04

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

I agree with others -- the granite is the keeper. I'd change the BS (which should be cheaper to do). To me, the BS doesn't really go with your cabinets. They have a clean, sophisticated look to them. But the BS reads rustic to me.

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

Another vote for the granite. The flecks of brown are clear in the photos and they look lovely. Anything less than plain less texture will take away from the beauty of the granite.
Did you /could you consider a plain white or an off white BS?

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

Yep, I am thinking you are right about the BS now that things are coming together. Went by this morning and the granite has been unwrapped.

Try to ignore the unpainted cabinets
 photo F5A9FE45-BCD1-44E0-9F79-9191732C1C90_zpshkbfe5vy.jpg

 photo 52C2064A-F0A8-4E59-93EA-3CCA8ADA397C_zpsnukextvy.jpg

 photo 9C962A41-8AA7-4280-825A-8F3AB8BE23A2_zpsqob4yqje.jpg

 photo 17156BDA-1479-4EBB-8BDB-A6ECE960EC4D_zpsyit95qpq.jpg

So, to me, what stands out is the tumbled travertine BS. It is more casual/rustic like a lot of you have mentioned. It would be so much easier (and cheaper) to change that out plus I *really* love my granite. I also think a glaze on the cabs would tone them down a bit to make them less stark. What do you think?

So I've been looking at BS now to get ideas of what I would want to change it out to. Thoughts on which of these, if any, might work?

 photo 236A95EC-5961-4D0C-A19D-FD1DC8ADD14E_zpsbbxvmevn.png

 photo 7C9F06CF-37C1-4328-9403-D84CF4A82266_zps26mnjssb.png

 photo 91A34484-9AB9-4F99-A4A1-A79D95470601_zpsvbmm4jy0.png

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

The alternatives look nice--slightly warm but not dominating. The second one appears a little pink, which was the problem with the travertine. Is your floor white tile or is it covered? Hard to see.

When you retile, don't let them put the tile on the wall for a sidesplash. It's not a current look.

RE: Can this backsplash and granite work?

The floor will be white oak, stained dark - probably Jacobean or similar. You think the current BS is pinkish? I pick up more yellow/brown. But I'm sure the lighting is affecting it too. That is interesting about the side splash. I hadn't noticed that before. Ripping out the BS is going to tear up the drywall too; how would they fix that?

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here