I have Grazia Rixi tile in Crema and I believe the switch plates color is called almond. I think they look great with the cream colored tile and would probably work for you.

look at switchhits.com for all kinds of options from fancy to plainer. You can search by color (see the categories on the left side and scroll down.) If you can't find an exact match, maybe you can find a metal one to coordinate with your hardware or faucet.

I was prepared to spend $18 per outlet cover, but then I found the Weybridge line at Home Depot. There are two colors: "travertine" and "noche". Travertine is what I chose, and is a color you may be interested in. They're only 6 bucks for a standard two gang, but a couple of the combination outlet covers (switch and two gang together, for example) are only sold online with free shipping. So, the color is a creamish bone, I guess. They have a nice stone-like texture. Good luck with your search.
:o)

Electrician was here today and installed 'light almond' switchplates. Very basic but a perfect cream white companion.

Thank you all very much for your help. I am happy to know there are more options for me.
Vitamins, I think my tile is very similar to your tile. Where did you get your outlets and covers? Are they plastic?

I found a very nice, traditional cream-colored line at Lowes I think.

Here's a kind of fuzzy pic, that for who-knows-what-reason is sideways, but you get the idea.

HTH,
Amy

Sorry Michelle don't want to steal your thread...but, I am trying to make the same decision. Great post. Vitamins can you share the details on your switchplates, please and thank you?

I have the almond rixi crackled subways and contractor recommended light almond "screw less" Levitron covers. They are perfect and LOVE that you can't see the screws!