Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

Posted by Kiwigem (My Page) on
Tue, Jul 29, 14 at 15:29

Hi everyone! We are building a rustic/ scandinavian modern mashup and I thought choosing my kitchen cabinets would be so simple but it's not! Just to give you an idea of the overall vibe: the walls will be BM White Dove, wide white oak floors (probably euro character grade), black doors (except for the barn sliders), black windows with drywall returns, Montauk blue slate flooring anywhere that isn't wood (entry, mudroom, pantry).

Our kitchen has one long working wall with refrigerator, sink, and stove. In front of that is a 10'6" island with a small prep sink to one side, otherwise just a big expanse with 5 stools on the other side.In front of that, the dining table (vintage danish modern) and 12' black patio sliders looking outside to the someday patio.

So, I've chosen my countertops based on function: Black soapstone on the working wall and white macaubas quartzite on the island. Now to choose the cabinets?!

The won't be any uppers. Most of the working wall is eaten up by 9' window over the sink and the range hood which will be white dove with 2X6 matte soft-white subway tile behind.

I originally thought I would do white cabinets with the soapstone and wood with the quartzite, but the more I think about it, it seems too Southern Living for what we are doing (Not that there is ANYTHING wrong with a Southern Living vibe!)

So now I'm thinking danish style wood cabinets (maybe a natural walnut tone) with the soapstone and ebonized oak or some other black for the island with the quartzite.

Any thoughts? I'm fighting decision fatigue! And when I get to that point I talk too much and I see my GC's face take on that heroic patience expression. Awful.


Follow-Up Postings:

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

**drool** I envy the design but not the decisions lol I think the walnut would be goooorgeous!

You might also start researching what door profile you want - that's actually harder to pick than colors because different profiles means using different materials. i.e. if you want shaker style, you can have solid wood rails but the center panel is veneered MDF. If you want slab fronts, your best bet is all veneered MDF. I ALMOST bought solid wood slab cabinet doors but was strongly advised against it here on the forums and ended up switching to MDF.

If you still want the white cabinets, you can do slab fronts and it will look very modern. Really the only time it starts to look Southern Livingish is when you introduce rails and arches and other decorative stuff on the doors. You could also integrate some woodgrain in with the white kitchen. Google up a couple images of "modern white kitchen soapstone" and you'll see what I mean.

Here is a link that might be useful: Modern White Kitchen Soapstone

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

Oh, what's wrong with solid slab doors? I'm not going to have many doors, mostly drawers, but I imagine the rationale still applies.

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

I guess warping is a big issue. Also if you look at the way solid slab doors are constructed, they're actually smaller strips of solid wood glued together and then structurally enforced with battens on the back (meaning you lose at least an inch of storage space inside the cabinet). MDF is much more structurally stable, and because its veneered, you get a much more cohesive look because you can specify bookmatched veneer, continuous grain across cabinets and drawers, etc. With solid slabs, you get what you get, and to me they look a little too busy.

Most of the kitchens you see with slab doors nowadays are MDF. I've been advised against plywood doors, too, because its just not made the same way it used to be. They can warp quite a bit (esp if you live in an area with big temperature and humidity swings throughout the year).

Here's a link for what solid slabs would look like. This is what changed my mind....

Here is a link that might be useful: solid slab doors

This post was edited by Swentastic on Tue, Jul 29, 14 at 17:40

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

I would probably skip the two-tone for the cabinets and go with a natural walnut veneer.

Something like this but with VERTICAL grain:

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

Sounds fantastic.
Go check out remodelista?
They have lots of ideas for the rustic/modern Scandinavian mashup look...

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

Norwegian kitchens. Definitely a lot of white.

I actually posted link by mistake a couple of day ago about "Norwegian kitchens and houses"

Click on house picture and more pictures will pop up.

Here is a link that might be useful: Norwegian kitchens


And a separate question. I am planning on doing a similar treatment on my windows, (black sash and no interior casing), but was curious on how you plan to handle the Sills?

I was thinking of a completely flush sill (no projecting stool), but I can't quite decide on details.

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

Wow, sounds so much like my initial direction. Many of same materials like quartzite and soapstone, sliding barn door, etc. Some have been able to pull it off, I just couldn't make the quartzite and black soapstone work together. I think in my case, the quartzite looked too modern for my traditional kitchen. Besides, as I explored more, the softer gray/black soapstone wasn't for us. I'll love following this, though to watch it take shape.

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

Wow- thanks for all the feedback, guys!
palimpset- that veneer is lovely- are you doing something like that?. We have five kids and a big dog, so we definitely need something on the sills! What we end up doing may be budget driven; eIther a white solid surface or a piece of wood painted to match the walls, most likely. We don't have the budget to kerf the doors, so we are going to have jamb extensions and let the drywall die into the jambs. That said, we may have the tiniest bit of a projection on the sill to tie it in with the door treatment better. We also will have some square baseboards painted the color of the walls, so I think a tiny lip on the sill might work. I honestly don't think I'll decide for certain until I see things coming together a little bit.
What are you thinking for yours?

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

Mags, what did you end up doing? Is there a thread?

RE: I know the counters.. what cabs to go with?

I was thinking of jamb extensions and plaster dying into it or a very narrow very flat casing for the doors. I've seen some kerfed jambs and they don't impress me as very durable: they seemed to have chipping and such of the plaster and paint on drywall corner beads. (Of course maybe I've seen some really well done ones and Not noticed them because they were perfect)

I am planning on doing recessed baseboard on the first floor at least.

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here