Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Posted by herg39458 (My Page) on
Mon, Jul 21, 14 at 3:34

Hopefully a KD might see this - I met with a Lowes cabinet person today about Schuler cabinets for my kitchen remodel. I will be meeting tomorrow with a HD person and will surely discuss Innermost then. It got me wondering, is there a difference in the box construction/doors/finishes/etc. between the two, aside from framed v. frameless, or between them and Medallion? I assume Medallion has more advertised options available, but are you getting basically the same stuff across these (or other Elkay) brands?

TIA


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Not a KD, can't speak to differences. But as someone with a living room full of Innermost cabinets (hopefully mostly in the kitchen by the end of the week) I will answer anything specific you might think of about them. I'd looked at KraftMaid at Lowe's. Then went to HD mostly because a friend had worked with the KD and had good things to say and I learned about frameless/Innermost.

I am super excited about all the room in these things. It's going to be great! The delivery guys said how heavy they were compared to other things they delivered. That's a good thing to hear, in my mind. And they are beautiful! (Kendall Natural Cherry)


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Well, I met with the HD person and she said something about sending in someone to measure the space, as I have read in other posts. The problem is half of our new kitchen is being added to the house so there is nothing to measure! I can't see us slowing down the train once the room is sheetrocked to have HD come and measure, so I doubt we will go with them unless something slows the process down, and that never happens with a remodel if I am not mistaken. (note: I may be mistaken...) I have also talked to a couple of local cabinet builders, though the first one we talked to was so far beyond what we, our architect, and our contractor expected that I am not terribly hopeful. I would still be interested to know what the differences among the different brands are, though. You never know...


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

It's my understanding that HD doesn't HAVE to measure, they just like to. My take on it is that it is part of the 'building the relationship' part. Also, it covers you both if they measure (note, there were 3 or 4 wrong measurements when they measured that I caught.) If you've got blueprints, that should be even better than a measurement appt.

I wouldn't let that stop you from using HD if you want Innermost. However, Innermost is the same as Design Craft that's carried by independent designers.


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

NEVER EVER order cabinets until the drywall is up and you can do an accurate field measure. I can't tell you the number of times that something wasn't built 100% to plans. An inch here or there can be an expensive lesson for you to learn.


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Okay, I stand corrected. I'm definitely not an expert.


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

We have InnerMost from HD. We did our own measuring (and installation), but we had to sign in blood that any mis-measures were on us, not them. Actually, we measured obsessively several times, which was good because we did make a 1" error early on. That one inch was corrected in the planning phase by ordering a 15" cabinet on one side of the stove and a 14" cabinet on the other. Had that not been corrected, that whole wall of cabinets wouldn't have fit between two fixed walls. This is not a place to rush. If you have drawings of the space with measurements, you can certainly go ahead and draw up plans and ponder them. What kind of corner treatments do you want, any glass inserts, any special pull-outs? This is a great time to work all that out. The nice thing about the computer programs that HD, and I suppose others, run is that it's relatively easy to go back and tweak when you have absolutely firm measurements. Basic planning done early, final tweaks when you're sure on the numbers. You're right, it will take 6 weeks or so from there, but there's no avoiding the need for accurate measuring.

As far as one brand being better than another for finish and such, I don't really know. Our kitchen/DR cabinets (stain on maple) are almost 3 years old now and we really love them. We also got put a wall of InnerMost cabinetry in our MBR (stain on cherry) (goodby junky dressers!) a couple of years ago and I love them every morning when I get dressed. Vanities going in the bathrooms as we speak (one paint on maple, one bamboo on maple). We're fans.


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Susannes1, So glad you love your Innermost cabinets. Thank you for sharing. Any pictures?


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

hollysprings - thanks for the warning, I am definitely pretty naive on this topic.

Still wondering if the box construction, etc. is the same across the lines or if they are more like independent companies under the same parent.


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Kitchen (Brandywine on maple). This is the wall where we originally measured 1" too long. That would have been a disaster!
Overview photo kitchen3.jpg

Cabinets as china cabinets in DR (same as kitchen)
 photo photo3_zps60360794.jpg

Cabinets in MBR (Brandywine w/ebony glaze on cherry)
 photo photo-6_zpsd634eb36.jpg
Hall bath (paint on cherry, "white chocolate")
 photo cab2_zps574c6e38.jpg
MB vanity (bamboo veneer on maple). This is just placed. The drawers haven't been adjusted, or pretty much anything else.
 photo Cabsfirstin_zps45c91aa6.jpg


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Suzannes1, your cabinets are beautiful! I love the Brandywine stain! I love the light counters with the rich darker cabinets. I also love that they are frameless. Thank you for sharing.


 o
To Suzannes1 again - RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are t

P.S. Suzannes1, I clicked on the picture to see more and saw your corner cabinet without a lazy Susan like I want! I printed the picture. Thank you!


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

You mean the upper easy reach? I've been very happy with that decision. The lower corner does have a super susan, which I gotta say, is the best thing since sliced bread! (How odd, I don't personally remember the days when bread didn't come sliced ;).


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

i have medallion silverline, i also really liked schuler and spent alot of time trying to compare the two. i totally missed innermost having 1" increments in size as it sounds like suzannes1 has an odd sized cabinet i am guessing it is not the standard 3" increment sizing. in a small kitchen, that would have been awesome but too late:(
so what i got on the medallion vs schuler is that schuler has the gold level or platinum level glides for all the cabinets but the silverline has lesser glides. the schuler display did open and shut better than my silverline cabs. other than that, i could find no differences. door styles, stains, etc are mimicked. medallion has 3 levels, schuler is not specified as different levels but cost increases with door styles. cost is a little less for silverline through my kd vs the equivalent door through lowes. (lancaster/sugar creek?)
hope this helps


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

I have Schuler and I am very pleased. It is 2 1/2 years and they look brand new and function perfectly. I am particularly pleased with the insides. However, a new friend, who is an installer for a high end kitchen store, was over for dinner and he offered to show me the difference between my cabinets and the double the money cabinets he installs. I declined his kind offer.
BTW- you must let the cabinet measuring person do the measuring. You can check it 20 times, but let the cabinet company take responsibility. Measuring comes after dry wall.


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Innermost is 3" increments, but you can modify to (I think) 1/4" increments. I've got two 6"d cabinets for my island. They were going to be 5 1/4" (which would have made them 6" with doors) but we did some last minute changes on the island and 6" box worked better.

My cabinets are still in my living room, but I'm already regretting not making a couple a little taller and a little less deep. Each mod is a % increase. The first mod is the most, then subsequent ones to that cabinet aren't that much at all.

ETA: For some reason I'm now thinking of bamboo Innermost for my vanity that I've started planning... :D

This post was edited by cal_quail on Wed, Jul 23, 14 at 12:20


 o
Suzannes1- RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differe

Suzannes1, Yes that is what I want what you have. I want an easy reach upper cabinet and a Super Susan corner lower cabinet. Thank you for letting me know the names. :) I love your kitchen.


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

Beware Medallion does not honor their warranty! We purchased $18,000 of cabinets from them. Not one single cabinet out of the box is good. Open miters on every door & drawer front, cracks all over the place gaps inside the cabinets, and the stacked cabinets don't match up at all. The range hood is cracked and scratched so badly we didn't even take it out of the box all the way. They are only offering us $5,000 credit towards a new set of cabinets. #medallionfailsoncraftmanship


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

SoJersyLife, I am sorry to hear about the frusterations you experienced with your Medallion Cabinets. I am a representative from the Elkay Customer Care Team and would like to know if I am able to assist any further. Do you have any contact information so I may contact you? My email address is: Kathryn.Schroeder@elkay.com- Thank you, Kathryn Schroeder


 o
RE: Schuler/Innermost/Medallion - what are the differences?

SoJersyLife: That makes no sense-if the cabinets are damaged why aren't they being replaced under warranty? Can you post some pictures of the damage?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here