Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Care for slate v granite

Posted by tomalyse (My Page) on
Mon, Jun 23, 08 at 18:31

We have recently installed slab slate counters in our kitchen (love grey/green color and non-busy look). Have seen all kinds of advice and products for granite -- any recommendations for care for slate?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

what is slate? do you have a pictures? is it expensive?


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

Tomalyse, as slate is the one material that is considered the absolute no for a kitchen, I am curious about what the installer sealed it with. and what advice for or against slate they may have given you. What was their advice for care and maintenance?

Blessings


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

actually - vermont slate is less absorbing than granite and does not need to be sealed. It is Brazil, Indian and Chinese granite that are problemmatic. My aunt has had slate countertops in place in her kitchen in Maine for more than 15 years without sealing and they still look great. What she uses as a cleaner, however, is not available in CA and the shipping charges ridiculous. Thus, I was curious about what others use. We ordered the slab slate countertops from Sheldon Slate in Maine (quarry in Vermont) so our installer only installed them - the fabrication was done in ME. SS also recommended the same care as my aunt.
Thus - slate is not "the absolute no for a kitchen", you just need to get quality slate. I do not have pictures yet. The costs including shipping cross country plus local installation ran around $8500 -- which was in the allowance our GC originally budgeted for granite -


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

Slate is an absolute no for kitchens? Since when? I've seen several kitchens here over the years with slate slab countertops, and it has a wonderful vintage look, similar to soapstone but paler.

I would also caution against categorizing granite [did you mean slate, tomalyse?] by nation of origin. Too general.

Always worth remembering that not all granite needs to be sealed.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

You'll pay thousands to have it fabricated and shipped across country but you have a problem paying for and shipping the recommended cleaner? That doesn't make sense to me.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

I just googled "slate countertops" and came up with a number of sites that said slate was a wonderful material for countertops. Not all these sites were selling slates; some just reviewing materials. So you learn something new everyday!

All the sites that were selling said that you maintain like soapstone with food grade mineral oil and clean with any neutral PH household cleaner.

Here is a link that might be useful: cleaning slate


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

we have vermont green slate ctops going on four years now.

maintenance has been pretty simple and cheap: soap and water.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

I enjoyed learning more about slate at the Sheldon Slate website. But I've never seen slate smooth enough to be used as a countertop: is the slate smooth like soapstone? They polish it to make it that way? Just wondering.

Here is a link that might be useful: Sheldon Slate website


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

Hmmm... Just posted a question on slate. Wonder why this thread didn't come up when I did a search on "slate counter"? But this is helpful. Thanks.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

busybme--smooth like soapstone, indeed! pretty much the same look w/o the need of oiling or sealing.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

Odd the vrjames-- one of 'our' stone gurus-- posted the 'absolute no' line.

The inch thick stuff in a pool table is utterly smooth and very very strong.

Someone posted here a long time ago about using his old pool table slate for his counters-- seems like a very cost effective way of getting slab stone. He never updated us, as far as I know.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

I feel the need to clarify.

All of my training has been that slate is not durable enough for kitchens.

It scratches easily, I can do it with a paperclip, It will spall easily when something heavy is dropped on it and I have handled a few complaints when it is on a firplace and has cracked.

I have been told it is no where near as easy as Soapstone to sand out the scratches.

We strongly discourage it.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

I guess it's a matter of taste. I have scratched soapstone samples w/ a fingernail, so I consider soapstone easy to scratch. Slate is much harder. Sharp pointy objects will scratch the surface, but b/c of the matte finish, they seem to disappear on their own (its hard to describe). If you tend to flail your pots around like nunchucks you might chip and edge. Going on four years now, w/ a slate farmers sink, and there has been no need to sand out any scratches.

Vermont slate is virtually stain resistant as far as I can tell. Limited colors though.

If you want your counters to look exactly the same the day they were installed 10 years from now, then slate is not an ideal material....buy granite.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

I think there are just vast, vast differences in the quality of what is sold as 'slate': just did my bathroom floor with it-- from a reputable flooring co, not a big box-- and a lot of the tiles could be easily broken in half with my bare hands [floor came out great, though].

But I have an old hutch with a slate top that's virtually bullet proof, and I think the stuff used on pool tables would be just as good.

I think it would be essential to see your slab before buying or deal with a very very reputable, satisfaction-or-refund kind of seller.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

Here's a link to a post on the kitchen designer's site regarding slate. I wish it had better pictures, because I've never seen a slate countertop.

Here is a link that might be useful: Slate info


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

we did brazilian slate countertops in our last kitchen remodel. we were there for four years with them and never had a chip or 'spall'. scratching is inevitable, but, as janedibber pointed out, the scratches aren't really all that noticeable, especially as more of them accumulate.

here are a few pictures:

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

i was very happy with the slate counters as they really gave us the vintage look we were going for. i mineral oiled them about once a year or so and that helped to smooth out the scratches. never sanded them. they were sealed during the initial install, but was told that they wouldn't need to be re-sealed unless we had them sanded/polished.

we opted not to do them in our current kitchen, because my wife was never really comfortable putting stuff down on the slate counters due to the scratching. she wanted something more bullet-proof, especially because we now have two kids. i would've done them again.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

It didn't come up because this site's search feature works differently than most. As far as I can tell, it does a "find whole words only search." A search that includes "counter" brings up posts that have exactly the word "counter" in them. This post contained "counters" and "countertop" but didn't have "counter" by itself.

Not very user friendly.


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

Thanks cloud_swift. I'd added counter because searching on just "slate" brought up hundreds of posts on backsplashes, floors, etc. So you're correct, not user-friendly...


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

Hello all!!

My husband has been templating for and installing Slate countertops for years! Yes, Slate is WONDERFUL as a countertop! When properly honed, it can be as smooth as butter. As far as maintenance, a little hot soapy water and you are all set! And, yes, I have Slate in my own kitchen. It NEVER needs sealing and is stain resistant. ( It is only 3% pourous) When small scratches occur (and they will!!) all you need is some oooo steel wool to buff it right out. Deeper scratches will require some fine sandpaper followed up by the steel wool. My husband works exclusively with Sheldon Slate in Granville, New York. He does the templating, delivery and installations and they do all of his fabricating. The range of colors and their craftmanship is phenominal! If you are looking for a durable, long lasting, old-fashioned and absolutely beautiful countertop for your kitchen, whether a new building or a remodel, I strongly suggest Slate. It's forever!!


 o
Slate countertops

Hello again -

If anyone would like to see pictures of Slate countertops done by my husband and Sheldon Slate, please e-mail me at Stephenson737@Aol.com and I will happily forward pics of his work to you!! Please put Slate tops in the subject line so that I do not automatically delete it as unfamiliar!!


 o
RE: Care for slate v granite

I had 150 year old slate sink/counter in my farm house growing up. Unfortunately the house burned last year, as we rebuild there was never a doubt...Living near Monson, Maine and the slate quarry there I purchased/installed new slate counters and a tilt front farm sink in my new house. Easy to care for soap/water...love the homey/vintage feel, much less formal than granite (though my front steps are granite slabs from the same area). I do recommend checking out Sheldon Slate's website, lots of great photos in the gallery.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here