BM Manchester Tan is a nice color and I also like Behr Swiss Coffee. We have colonial cream and LOVE IT! It does have a lot of mica in it(at least our slab did) and as such it doesn't have as high a shine as the other granites I have seen. It might have to do with the light color too. But what I like it contains only tans, greys and dark brown accent color. It is a really nice neutral.

We just finished our kitchen and have Colonial Cream. I did SW Dover White for the cabs and a grey stain for the island cabinets. My white is a warm white but still very white - not off-white at all. Do a search here for white paint and you will come up with several threads discussing what various people did several with pictures (not that pictures are that helpful for white though. It is just too hard to capture the true color so that is why you have to test for yourself.)

Some people here have done:
BM Cotton Balls
BM Simply White
BM Mayonnaise
(I thought I had a list written down but I can't find it)
I tried BM Marscapone but I think it has weird yellow or pink undertone. I can't remember which.

Someone did BM Nimbus a while back - it is a very light grey. It looked great.

What type of cabinets do you have with your Colonial cream? Can you post a pic, if you don't mind?

My mom renovated her kitchen and used Colonial Cream with medium dark stained wood cabs.

I don't want wood stained cabs because we already have alot of wood in our place.

I've looked at Manchester Tan and like it. Do you think it may be too dark for cabinets?

Thanks NewSouthernbelle. I'll look at those colors.
It's so hard to pick the right color!

I don't want a color that has pink or yellow undertones. I also don't want a very bright white.

geomeg - I've posted several pictures in my kitchen 'reveal' thread where you can see my Dover White cabinets with Colonial Cream. The link is below:

Here is a link that might be useful: My Kitchen