Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Posted by lmalm53 (My Page) on
Mon, Jun 9, 08 at 9:28

Ok, I have narrowed down my backsplash tile choices to a Mexican Travertine or a Porcelain tile with a natural stone "look". Would appreciate input from everyone regarding which tile you think would be a better match for my granite and cabinets.

I am leaning toward the Travertine but it is much more expensive and I suppose a little more maintenance involved with the sealing every year. I have never had natural stone tile before so any advice or tips on the pros and cons of Stone vs Porcelain would be appreciated also. :)

Oh... and the sample tiles are 4x4s but I will be using 6x6 tiles.

Desert Cream Imperial Mexican Travertine - FloridaTile
DESERT CREAM IMPERIAL TRAVERTINE TILE

Ankara Porcelain Tile in True Beige and Noce - FloridaTile
ANKARA PORCELAIN TILE - TRUE BEIGE

This is my granite next to a cabinet door.
Photobucket

I appreciate your input and suggestions!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

To my eye... and on my monitor, the color of the travertine competes with your granite. The porcelain seems to blend better. I also prefer the edges of the porcelain... adds some visual interest.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

I like the travertine color with the granite better than the porcelain. Also the edges of the porcelain tile are weird and don't look natural to me. The granite is beautiful with your cabinet color!


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

I like the porcelain tile better. You have a busy granite with a lot of movement (I love it, it's beautiful.) When you have granite with such a WOW factor, the other elements in the room need to be understated.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

I love your granite. I think the warmth of the travertine really complements it.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

On my monitor, the travertine seems peachy next to your stunning granite. Personally, I would like to see a creamier tone. On the other hand, I like the simpler lines of the travertine.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

I think the porcelain color is better (at least on my screen), but agree, the wavy edges are kinda strange. Do they make a clean edge?


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Honestly they both work (omm=On My Monitor) but I think I prefer the porcelain as it seems a little less intense. Iagree the wavy lines are unusual, but I kind of like them.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

I think the porcelain is very pretty and does not compete with your granite.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Heh - on my monitor the porcelain is too cool/gray looking for the granite.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Wow! Thanks for the comments. It seems like we are pretty evenly divided between the Travertine and Porcelain. I know how hard it is to get an accurate color to show in a photo, plus everyone's monitors won't show colors the same way. Each of the Travertine tiles are slightly different in color depth and pattern but they really don't seem all that busy to me when seen in person with the rest of the elements in place.

I am amazed at how different the stone and granite both look when in natural light vs indoor incandescent vs flash lighting. I still think I like the feel and texture of the Travertine better than the Porcelain, plus the color just seems to be a better match. Here are pics of the Travertine taken outdoors in natural light and the Porcelain and Travertine indoors together under kitchen lights without using the camera flash.

Travertine in Outdoor Lighting
TRAVERTINE OUTDOORS IN NATURAL LIGHT

Porcelain and Travertine in Kitchen Lighting Together (note the Porcelain has a little more sheen than the Travertine)
ANKARA AND TRAVERTINE INDOOR LIGHTING

Does that help any? I like them both but still like the natural stone a little better than the porcelain. More Comments?

Thanks for the nice comments about my granite! I do like it alot and hope once I see it on all the countertops and island it won't seem too busy. Any comments on the difference in maintenance or wearability of Travertine vs Porcelain?

My installer says the Travertine will be easier to cut and work with on the install, but I'm wondering if there are other differences besides price I should be aware of?


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

In your original photos, I thought the porcelain looked too cool/gray (as pbrisjar said). Didn't like it at all.

In your outdoor photo, I still LOVE the travertine.

In your last photo, I kinda like the porcelain, too. But still prefer the travertine.


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

OK, what's the granite? Could it be Ivory Coast?

Anyway, we used Ivory Coast granite matched with Florida Tile (I am pretty sure) Mexican Noce' travertine subway tiles. It gives the backsplash a very Tuscan/rustic look, very soft in tones and compliments the Ivory Coast extremely well. No doubt the porcelain is easier upkeep but the stone is sooo natural looking and takes nothing from the granite.

I vote for the travertine!


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Sounds like you really like the travertine. Go with what you love, you will always be happy!!!


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

I'm glad Breezy commented like she did. I like the rustic look of the travertine better, although I brought home some very similar porcelain to try with my Tropical Brown granite. My friend with the tile store always goes for natural stone and she picked a tumbled travertine to work in my kitchen. The rustic look of the stone is really nice for me.

Red


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Still like the travertine - even more so in the outside shot. I just don't care for the edges of the porcelain. However, the color is ok but not as warm and natural looking as the travertine. How about waiting on the backsplash until the counters are in and you see the granite in all its glory. It might be easier to select a backsplash at that point. Again, the granite is beautiful!!!!


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Travertine! I don't like the edges of the porcelain. It will be too busy with your movement of your granite. It will look beautiful! Want to see pictures when it is done!


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Thanks again to everyone for the interesting responses! The name of the granite is El Dorado. I believe it is from Brazil but when I try to google the name the only thing I can find is something called Juparana El Dorado that looks nothing like my granite. Guess I need to ask the granite shop for more info on it. I do know that it looks a whole lot like Geriba Beach only without all the swirls of gray.

I agree that normally it would make much more sense to wait til the granite is installed before choosing the backsplash. In my case I have a very narrow window of time to get as much done on my remodel as possible. I hired my good friend and neighbor of 18 years to do as much of the remodel as he can. He is a certified electrician, carpenter and all around handyman who has been rehabbing houses in Florida. He is back in my neighborhood for only the month of June. We started the demo of my kitchen June 2. So far we have accomplished alot for the first week. My neighbor will be doing electrical work this week and next, new circuits, canlights, undercabinet lighting, moving switchplates, hang new light fixtures etc. Hopefully we will have granite ready to install the week of the 23rd and then my neighbor will hookup all my sinks, faucets and cooktop. If I have the tile ordered and ready to go, he will install it before he heads back to Florida end of the month so thats the reason for the rush. I will be doing the finish up work (removing old wallpaper, painting, window treatments, etc) whatever I am able to do myself and will have more time for additional decorating decisions then.

Regarding the tile, I think some of the responses hit the nail on the head for me. I am looking for a more rustic "Tuscan" feel to the kitchen, rich and warm and traditional. I think the Travertine fits that vision in my mind better than the porcelain. Now to decide on the pattern of tile placement and whether or not I should add an occasional "accent" tile in a few places. I definitely do not want the backsplash to be distracting, but rather a nice complimentary blend to the granite and cabinets.

Thanks to all for the wonderful responses! I don't know how I could ever do this remodel without having all the help found here on the forums!


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

Oh yes...the travertine does look nicer now that I see it in the outdoor light. What is the name of the granite color (it's gorgeous)?


 o
Name of my Granite

The granite is called El Dorado :)


 o
RE: Travertine vs Porcelain - Help Me Choose? - Pics

I know I'm late replying to this but I will anyway :)
Travertine!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here