Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Posted by rkb21 (My Page) on
Fri, Jun 28, 13 at 8:32

I would really love your opinion on my hardware. I really like what I've chosen, but now I'm trying to figure out if I should do all pulls or knobs on the doors and pulls on the drawers.

A close up of the knobs/pulls and how they look on my doors:
IMG_4003

IMG_4004

An idea of our space:
IMG_4020

IMG_4022

Here is a photoshopped version of all pulls:
pullsonlyxcf

Here is a photoshopped version of knobs/pulls:
knobs&pulls

So, what do would you do:
1. Knobs/pulls combo
2. All pulls
3. For the desk area, would you recommend pulls on all the bottom drawers or break it up with a combo of knobs and pulls?

If I did all pulls, then I would need a knob to put on a very small drawer that is to the right of the DW or something else that would fit there. Ideas welcome!

Thanks so much for your input!!!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Very nice RK, I don't think you can go wrong either way. I wanted to do all pulls in my kitchen. I did except for my penninsula cabinets where I decided to use knobs simply because I thought they were simply too pretty to not use a few of them!

That choice is just so individual. I have a very good friend who used all knobs in her kitchen so she didn't have so much to decide on. As much as I love the matching knobs to my pulls I wouldn't want them on every door and drawer because a pull, imo, is easier to use.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I'd vote knobs and pulls. I think the knobs won't compete with the beautiful trim on your cabinet doors.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I agree with DGM123: knobs and pulls. Usually I prefer pulls to knobs, but your cabinets have really lovely detailing on the doors that seems to work better with the knobs. The pulls seem to compete a little bit. Also, if down the road a ways you decide that the knobs just aren't working for you, you'd simply have to drill a second hole to switch to pulls. It's more difficult to go from pulls back to knobs.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I wonder if pulls placed horizontally would look good?


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Love them pulls...skip the knobs....


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I like the pulls! Guess it's what YOU like!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I like the pulls, too, and I'm surprised, because I usually prefer a knob with raised panel uppers.

Since it's such a hard call, either way will be lovely.

I would be careful of knobs on any drawers where they can catch on pockets. I tore aprons and more on the lower knobs in my old kitchen - of course, they stuck out a lot more than these knobs.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I usually like pulls; however, with your cabinets, I'd vote for knobs on the doors and pulls on the drawers.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Another knobs and pulls vote. Love the detail on your cabinets.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Thanks for everyone's input!

holly-kay: I didn't really think about the horizontal pulls. I'll have to see what that looks like.

pricklypear: I was worried about that, too. Once I drill for the pulls, I can't go back...Yikes!

I had initially thought I'd do knobs on the doors with pulls on the drawers. Then, I saw the doors and how narrow a space I had for the hardware placement. My first choice knobs wouldn't work. So, that's when I thought of doing all pulls. My second choice of knobs just barely fits in the space and I do like them with the matching pulls.

I really like the way the pulls look on our doors because they are so tall, but I'm worried that there will be too many pulls.

I don't know if the variation of knobs/pulls is better aesthetically or not.

So far, it looks like 3 votes for pulls and 3 votes for knobs/pulls combo.

Please keep the votes coming...it's too close for me to decide :)

I really appreciate everyone taking the time to chime in!!!

You guys are all great!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I think what throws me off is that the pulls seem kind of small or perhaps should be moved higher.

Here is a link that might be useful: pulls / knobs


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I agree with nosoccermom. The placement doesn't seem right, especially the pull. They also seem crowded with all the detailing on the door.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I think my KD indicated 3 inches from the bottom of the door for a knob or for the bottom hole on a pull. I think that the reason I like the pull is because larger cab doors, imo, look better with a pull. I do like the pulls you chose, they are a nice fit for your cabinets.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I like the knobs better. The pulls seem to get visually caught up in the moldings on the door. Not sure about their location though. Seems a bit low and tight with the miter/corner of the door details. Have you tried it higher?


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I think I would do all pulls, and I think I'd do them all horizontally. I'm not a fan of knobs in general (though right now I'm leaning to glass/crystal knobs for my kitchen because the up uppers will have glass doors).
Your cabinet doors, and your pull choices, are gorgeous! It must be so exciting to be so close to the finish line!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Thanks again for the input...it's really helpful!!! My husband's response was, "I don't think it matters that much so just do whatever you think would look better." That was that...so it's great to bounce ideas off of all of you!

I think I'm up to 5 for the pulls and 4 for the knob/pull combo...wow! It's a close one.

nosoccermom: Thanks for the link! I wasn't sure about the placement. I just assumed that the bottom is supposed to line up with the horizontal line of the panel. I will definitely check on the placement of the pulls!

The pulls are 4", the doors are 42" high.
I was going to use 4" everywhere and use the 5" on the wider drawers, if I used all pulls.

holly-kay: Thanks for the 3" tip...I will check that.

kksmama: You're the second person to suggest placing them horizontally...I really need to snap a picture of it that way.

It's been a crazy day. They just finished everything except the doors need to be hung, backsplash placed and hardware put in. I just finished mopping the floor...Yay for seeing the floor and counters!!!

I can at least use my kitchen...hooray :)


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I'm generally a pull person, but in your kitchen I see knobs.

Even if you do pulls everywhere else, a knob would be fine on the little drawer and door.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I think your kitchen is too traditional to do the horizontal pulls, and I don't see how it solves the problem of the pull looking squeezed into a tight space.

kksmama mentioned crystal knobs. A round crystal knob might fit better and go well in your pretty kitchen. I think beekeeperswife has/had them in both her old and new kitchen, and that's all the endorsement one needs around here. ;)


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Ohhh May-flowers, crystal knobs would be stunning!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

May-flowers: thanks for the input. I think you're right. Our kitchen is very traditional and I agree it would look out of place to do horizontal pulls. I do love the idea of crystal knobs. Though I don't know how it would look if I used them everywhere. Would you suggest crystal knobs on the doors and the pulls that I chose on the drawers? I need to check out beekeepers kitchen again :)

Thanks!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I like all pulls. I think they compliment the detail on your cabinets.

That being said, I adore crystal knobs and can imagine them looking fab in your kitchen!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Crystal knobs sound lovely, but either way, I think the knobs/pulls need to go higher.

Here is a link that might be useful: beekeeperswife crystal knobs


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Oh my I so wish that crystal knobs would have been a good compliment to my cabinets. I so wanted crystal knobs and now I know why. Maybe I can have a hutch built for the eat in side of my kitchen and use those lovely glass knobs!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

ooooh another vote for crystal knobs! I had been reading along, having a hard time deciding which look I liked better, then the crystal knobs hit the scene: instant winner!

cheers


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

It's been great getting everyone's input! I appreciate it.

It seems like there wasn't a clear winner on the all pulls vs pulls/knobs question. I guess I can't go wrong then :)

There were a lot of votes for doing glass knobs, though. I am considering the glass knob option. I'll have to get a sample to see it in my space.

Would you pair it up with the pulls I chose?

Holly-Kay: I took your advice on going 3" up and snapped a couple of pictures.

I am kind of leaning towards all pulls unless the glass knobs look awesome.

What do you guys think of the placement? Better?

image

image

The pulls on the drawers:
IMG_3919

Thanks for the input...it's been really helpful!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I love the way the pulls look! I think the placement is much better now.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I think the pulls look great with the higher placement. What a difference! I think you could even go ~ 1/4" higher for the bottom of the pull to be at the same height as the bottom of the raised panel.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

holly-kay: Thanks! I've ordered some glass knobs...maybe I'll use them on the glass doors above the desk and the little butler's pantry area.

Kellysar: Great idea to line the bottoms up with the raised panel! Thanks.

Does anyone know if the top of the pulls on the bottom doors also go 3" down?


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

The placement looks so much better!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Yes RKB, that is how mine are done. I will try to post a pc later on this evening.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

Definitely pulls! The last example you show looks great. I still like the odd knob on smaller doors and would love to see how crystal looks.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

On the door, do your fingertips bump into the molding when you try to use the pull? It almost seems to me that you need a pull with a deep arch to clear the molding. It's hard to tell in a straight-on photo.


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

may_flowers: Thanks for thinking of it. I checked as soon as I got home...there's a lot of clearance. whew!

holly-kay: thanks for the placement tip!

IMG_4076

A far away shot of knob vs pull. I still am leaning towards the pulls. I will post a picture of the crystal knobs when I get them in the mail.

IMG_4072

Thanks again to all of you!


 o
RE: Opinions needed on my hardware, please!

I really love your pulls they have a classic elegance to them. Such a lovely choice.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here