I like the 3rd one best, but with maybe a darker brown cabinet. On my monitor it appears a little more red. To me it draws the eye up and doesn't seem to get all mixed together. Second choice would be the first option. Any of the ones with dark cabinets and dark counters would be my last choice. If you want to make the range a focal point then maybe do something different/special with the backsplash.

the two tone kitchen is a great start....but lighten the island stain ...maple will take a lighter stain better and if the back panels are situated where visually they receive a lot of focus I'd be concerned about the usual "blotchy" issues with dark stain. Perhaps reverse the 2-tone-white paint on the island and a light stain on perimeter.[but I do like the white perimeter].My least favorite is dark staining to any part.

I like #4 but would do a different counter on the island. Lighten it up a bit. The dark/dark of several pictures looks to dungeon-like to me.

I like 1 and 3, but light counters. If you are staining yourself, I would agree with herbflavor about the dark stain even though mine are maple stained java. The factory finish uses wood conditioners to help the stain take evenly. I think a darker stain is riskier to DIY on maple, though I have never tried myself.

Can you mock some up with lighter stain? Like maybe a spice color or other medium tone that picks up a color from the floor?

Can maple be stained that dark? I like the two tone, light perimeter with the island stained.

None of the above. Especially the stained woods. The floor wants to be the star here, and the cabinet design with the wood mantle is wrestling with it for dominance in a clashing manner. If you want the mantle hood to be the star, you need the cabinets to be painted so that they eye doesn't view the fight between the wood tones and focuses on both the floor and the mantle.

But, it doesn't necessarily have to be white painted cabinets to work in the space. I'd look at maybe a grey green, or a light sugar cookie tan, or even a soft blue.

BTW, staining maple isn't for an amateur. It should have been done in a cabinet shop by a professional finisher, NEVER EVER on site. The cabinet maker shouldn't have installed unfinished cabinets. They should be finished and topcoated in a clean room offsite. He needs to come back and uninstall them and have them finished by a professional finisher who has the proper equipment to do so. You want the control against trash and debris that a finish room provides, as well as the durability of using the topcoats that can only be used in a finish room. You want a catalyzed varnish, preferably heat or UV cured. That cannot be done on site.

Hollysprings is right. This is not a dyi finishing job. Were you intending to do it yourselves or does the contractor think he is returning to do it on site? A good finish on raw maple can not be done on site. I have been in the finishing business for 25 years. I'm sorry you have this problem.

#3 looks very similar to the colors of my kitchen. I love it!!

If you do a dark stain it should not have red undertones as it appears there are not red tones in your floor. Do not like dark cabs and black counters...too much dark and it brings the room down. There needs to be some contrast. Agree with Holly...your floors are busy and should take center stage. Counters and BS should be fairly tame.

Love # 4 but with an olivey green island, somewhat the color on the wall over the range.

I like the third one the best because I like the contrast. I agree with the maple being stained and finished off site. I have stained maple and my cabinet maker did a great job on the staining. I think the glazing was a bit heavy handed though. They were all stained, glazed, and finished off site.

I am voting a little differently because I do like dark counters with medium to dark stained wood. However, none of the colors seem to be quite right with the floors. I think, with those floors, I would use a painted finish in a soft color as Hollysprings suggested. Someone had a kitchen several months ago that had 2 tone cream and green, which I loved -- I think that green would look very good with your floors

Here is a link that might be useful: green and cream cabinets

I suggest considering painting the cabinets a color other than white.

I like #3 & #4. I love your floors!

I would definitely one of the tones that matches the acacia, either a light tone or light-medium.

The acacia is very busy and a high contrast stain to me would be jarring.