Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Posted by blueyoung (My Page) on
Thu, May 2, 13 at 15:26

I posted at the floor abroad, but I think the kitchen forum should have the most traffic. Hope it's all right to post here again.

Thank you for take a minute to check out the link
http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/flooring/msg0512241415537.html

Any suggestion or Pics would be really appreciated.
I'm so frustrated right now. Please help me make up my mind


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

You sound like you want what I wanted. The guy doing our floors said special walnut would be too dark. He suggested provincial, and I love it. It's hard to photograph the color of it, but here are a couple pictures to give you an idea. Sometimes it looks a little red in photographs, but it isn't red at all.

I'll also post your link below to make it easier for others.

Island photo P1010839.jpg

Here is a link that might be useful: blueyoung's link


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

mpagmom, thank you, your floor looks amazing. And that's what I want, not yellow not red. Is your floor white oak?
Can I ask how long have you have it installed? Any changes in the color so far?


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

We just wanted the clear poly. We choose super matte finish with q&r oak so no real grain:

 photo web_S1Q6780.jpg

 photo web_S1Q6772.jpg


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Yes, it is white oak, and the floors were finished almost a year ago. I just pulled up the edge of a rug to see if it was lighter or darker underneath and we couldn't tell a difference. I think in general they darken a bit with exposure to the sun. I have a satin polyurethane finish. Good luck with your house!


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

My floors are being refinished this week. Ours are red oak and we choose the Golden Oak stain by minwax. Here's a pic with 1 coat poly and stain. More coats are coming tomorrow.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Do any of you have spacing or filler between your boards?


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

mpagmom, judging from Minwax's swatches on their website, I though Provincial is darker than Special Walnut. Thank you for posting your pic.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

ratrem, love ur kitchen!!!!! Your floor looks great too. What a beautiful show room you have!


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

khallock, your floor looks darker than minwax's swatches. Do you think it's the light or it is kind of darker than the swatches?

Here is a link that might be useful: Minwax wood stain


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

I see what you mean about how the colors look on the website. I don't know how dark special walnut is - just that the wood floor guy said it was too dark for me. This is the picture I showed him for what I wanted, and I think I came really close.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Mpagmom, I like the Provincial Stain on the White Oak floors! Thank you for sharing.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Blueyoung - The Golden Oak is definitely darker than the swatches. I remember looking at the swatches at Lowes and I wasnt keen on Golden Oak. But then our floor guy brought over some stained boards, and I liked the color. I also like Special Walnut, but it was slightly darker than Golden Oak. My hubby didnt want to go as dark as Special Walnut. Provincial was darker than Special Walnut.

Remember I have red oak. I am not sure what white oak would look like with the same stain. Our flooring guy is also using oil-based polyurethane on top and I have heard that makes the floors darker than a water-based polyurethane would.

I have some more pictures. These are with just 1 coat of poly. My floors will be done by Sunday and I can post more pictures then with 3 coats of poly.

Close up with flash (1 coat poly)


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Sorry to be off topic, but mpagmom, what is the aqua paint color in your house?


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

We have 5" white oak floors. We had them mix a custom stain, 75% jacobean, 25% walnut. I didn't want any red or golden tones...just brown.
Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

My gosh the minwax color boards are definitely off. Two homes ago I had all my wood stained provincial and it is a lovely stain and definitely a mid tone. The home we are in now has all the woodwork and wood panel doors stained special walnut which is actually a dark walnut with a hint of henna tone to it. The jacobean is also very nice.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Msrose, off topic is what we do here. It's Sherwin Williams Comfort Gray.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

mpagmom - Would you believe I just looking at The Nester Blog and saved a picture of Comfort Gray about five minutes ago? I think it's a sign I need to find a place for this color in my house :)


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Nini804--would you be able to share any additional pictures of your floors? They are gorgeous!!! I'd like to see more!


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

mpagmom,
More off topic: Is the comfort gray also in the room adjacent to the one with the fireplace? And what's the cream paint color in the fireplace room?


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

There could not be a clearer sign, msrose.

Nosoccermom, the cream paint in the great room is SW neutral ground. The adjacent room (my foyer) is also comfort gray. I only used 3 colors in the whole house because my builder charged by the color.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

holly-kay, can you please post the pic of your special walnut floor? I'd love to see how it looks in large area


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

We installed new 3" white oak planks throughout the main part of the house. The stain is a custom mix of 75% Jacobean and 25% Coffee Black. (I was told Coffee Black was the equivalent of Minwax Special Walnut.) I showed my floor guys a couple of pictures of what I wanted, specifically Nini's gorgeous floors, and we worked from there. I wanted the floors to be dark enough to be rich and yummy, but not so dark that every strand of cat hair and crumb would scream at me. I brought a couple of drawers from some of my QS oak antiques to make sure the floor wasn't too matchy-matchy. We ended up with the same formulation as Nini's.

Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos

Edited to add that I didn't want any red or yellow undertones in my floor. Just a nice, pleasing, rich brown color. My floors are finished in Bona waterborne, which my flooring company swears by.

This post was edited by breezygirl on Sun, May 5, 13 at 17:33


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Oh no! I was all set for no stain but now seeing Nini & breezys floors makes me reconsider! Argh! Breezy--any more pics of your gorgeous floors you can share?

I don't want yellow or red--I want drown. But not dark, because I LOVE light and need to keep the space light.

I'm stuck!!!


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

I can't help you with the stain, but I'd strongly advise sticking with polyurethane for reflection and durable finish and not doing poly waterborne finish. We had a whole house done with poly waterborne, and it just doesn't hold up.

O/T: for those with glass cabinets, have you all lit them? Or, if you didn't, do you use incandescent overheads rather than recessed non diffusible LED lights? My electrical quotes for products alone are insane and I don't even like LED light much. thanks very much.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Buildinva--There are more photos of my kitchen on my old partial reveal thread linked below. If you click on any of the pics, you'll be taken to my photo bucket account with even more pics. In some of the photos you can see where the floorboards were cupping a little when we first moved back into the house. Those have almost all laid back down since that time.

FWIW, I've never had wood floors before, and I LOVE these! I still find myself admiring the color on regular occasions!

EDIT: Forgot to add the link!

Here is a link that might be useful: My partial reveal thread with many pics

This post was edited by breezygirl on Fri, May 10, 13 at 13:21


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Are you using red oak or white oak?

We just installed red oak in our entire house and used a mix of medium brown and provincial. Provincial was too light/red and the medium brown was too dark. Our floor guy put the stain on the unfinished floor and let us think about it overnight; when he came back, he mixed them and we went with the 50/50 mix and LOVE it!! Not too red, not too brown, not too dark, not too light :)

Here's a pic....just please ignore the dusty floors under the island.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

mpagmom,
this begs the question: What's your third paint color? (What do they say about imitation and flattery :)


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Red oak and white oak will take stain differently. Red has the pinky undertones that will need a bit of green in the stain to counteract that. White oak has some greenish undertones that sometimes need a bit of red to warm it up or else it's too cool.

Whatever you do, your flooring professional should do samples for your approval before you decide.


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Sorry, nosoccermom, I missed this! The third color is SW Light French Gray. My 3 daughters chose it for their two bedrooms and bath based on this picture:


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

Very pretty and very sophisticated!


 o
RE: Show me your oak floors~ Help needed!

These our are kitchen/dining room floors.....red oak, no stain and 3 coats of Glitsa polyurethane that was buffed. Floor was refinished 4 years ago and still looks great!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here