Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Posted by southernmum (My Page) on
Thu, May 9, 13 at 11:25

I just finalized my granite order: The Winter Springs slab that I posted earlier for my island, and Black Absolute for the perimeter cabinets. My salesperson told me how the Black Absolute was so magnetic that a magnet really sticks to it... Other than that, he praised it for being such a resilient granite. Didn't think much about the magnetic part at the time. However, now I'm wondering about it... Is this problematic in any way? Will it damage cell phones, credit card or YOUR HEALTH? He says it is magnetic due to the high amount of radon (? think that's how he put it..) Anyway, I really like the sleek look of it. This is probably no big deal, but thought I should look into it... If you have Black Absolute, I'd love to hear from you, too! Thanks


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

It is not radon that causes magnetism. Good grief.

Anyway, it is possible it will be magnetic. I noticed that my Tan brown (a dark tan brown) in my bathroom has magnetic spots accidentally when I set my ultrasonic toothbrush head on it (and it stuck!). But, it hasn't affected the ability of my toothbrush to charge. Magnets aren't damaging to your health. And, I don't think the counters are strong enough to wipe credit cards and definitely not cell phones or laptops.

On the issue of radon--if it has a lot of that, well then you may want to consider...but that isn't what gives it magnetic properties.

Where is Karen?


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Meaning since it does have a high amount of radon, I should reconsider? I have three kiddos... Just want to make sure it's safe!


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

I don't know who Karen is, but if she knows this kind of stuff, I hope she finds this thread! :)


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

I'm here! And I love this kind of stuff. :)

So, we've already dispensed with the idea of radon causing magnetic properties, well done. In fact, I would go so far as to doubt anything uttered by someone who says that radon makes a rock magnetic.

Also, we need to separate two things. If a magnet sticks to something the thing it sticks to isn't magnetic, it just contains iron. In that regard, yes, Absolute Black and most rocks in the granite family contain iron-rich minerals that will weakly attract a magnet. In general darker rocks have more of these minerals than lighter rocks (again, this only applies to the granite family of rocks, i.e. igneous rocks). I wouldn't worry about health, cell phones or anything else.

Does the rock give off radon? Perhaps a tiny amount, but if you have any kind of normal ventilation in your house then it's likely a non-issue.

Ready for some geologic trivia?
Igneous rocks form from a liquid magma. The magma is a slushy mix of minerals (hot slush, naturally). The iron-rich minerals will align themselves with the magnetic North pole when the rock is liquid. Once the magma cools, the minerals are locked in place. These minerals tell us where the magnetic North pole was when the rock forms, which is called paleomagnetism. This is an incredibly useful tool. For example we can look at old rocks and tell where they were when they formed. This helps us understand how Earth's tectonic plates have moved all around the globe.

Paleomagnetism also revealed that Earth's magnetic pole alternates from being at the North Pole to being at the South Pole. By looking at basalt on the ocean floor (Absolute Black is basalt, by the way), we can see that sometimes the iron-rich minerals point north and sometimes they point south. We can tell exactly when the magnetic poles have flipped. The pole flips pretty often ("often" from a geologic point of view, that is).

I think the next great sci-fi disaster movie should deal with what happens when the magnetic pole flips again. Navigation goes haywire, Boy Scouts get lost, flocks of birds and bats fly around confused, airplanes fly upside down. And who knows what other terrible things might happen. Perhaps even random charges appear on your credit card ("It wasn't me who ordered those backsplash tiles, honey, it must have been the magnetic poles flipping!").

Well, I have wandered rather OT now, haven't I? Anyway, aside from that last paragraph, the rest of this post is true. :)


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Magnetic properties come from iron and nickel in the stone.

You would have to go to a table of the nuclides and see if a radioactive iron or nickel has radon in its decay product path.

Here is a link that might be useful: Chart of Nuclides


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

southernmum, I would not worry about randon or magnetism.

I got curious so I took a magnet and there is no reaction on my White Diamond granite. But there is some with my steel gray. Interesting!


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Radon is a gas that only comes from the radioactive decay of uranium or thorium, so iron and nickel won't give you radon. Plenty of granites have some uranium in them, so there is a grain of truth to the worry about radon from granite. And by this I mean granite by the literal geologist's name, not the generalized countertop name.

Aside from radon gas, rocks can also be radioactive, meaning some of the elements in the rock are undergoing radioactive decay. That happens all the time and that's how geologists date rocks. It's still not something I would worry about but it would be fun to walk around the stone yard with a Geiger counter. What an excellent way to scare off customers!


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Great info., Karen! Since you know about this sort of thing, here goes another question: the granite I picked out for my island is a gorgeous slab of Winter Springs from Brazil. With all my research on granite this evening, I've discovered a lot of granite from Brazil does have higher radon/uranium content. Would this be a deal killer, or no big deal? (*Can you tell that I have to sign away on all my granite and quartz tomorrow?!) Many thanks!


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Very interesting, Karin! Thanks for sharing your expertise!!!


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Karin- I just wanted to say that my 7 year old son is obsessed- OBSESSED- with geology and I so often find new geology tidbits to share with him in your posts. So thanks for that! I can't wait to tell him about the trivia you posted up thread when he wakes up in the morning!

Good luck with your decisions, OP!


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

I'd be worried about buying anything from a salesman that told you that. Seems like he really does not know the product that he is selling. That's certainly a red flag about him and the company that he works for.


 o
RE: Black Absolute Granite & Being magnetic?

Hi again,

I posted a reply about Brazilian granite in the other thread SouthernMum started. I'll paste the answer here too.

Oh and Chilibeans, that is awesome! Makes me very happy to hear that. Your son will have a great time when he gets to take a geology class.

-------
Hi SouthernMum,

That's a good question. I tried to look up Winter Springs granite but didn't find it.

What color is it? Uranium is found in true granites which are light in color. So you can rule it out if it's darker.

Either way, I don't think it's a deal killer. You can find scary stories about radioactive granite online but it's not prevalent. I wish I had a definitive answer for you, but it varies with every rock so there's not much I can tell you in absolute terms.

I would definitely not say that granite from Brazil is categorically risky. Brazil is a big place with lots of different rocks. We'd really need more info about the specific rock, rather than a blanket statement.

That said, I'd be interested to see the link where it says that, because I've never heard that before. Also, post a photo of Winter Springs so we can see what it really is.

Hope that helps!
Karin


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here