Do they still have Jackalope? They used to have great hand forged hardware and tile. I also bought tile on ebay a while back and they were the same as seen in SW tile shops, but half the price. Looked exactly as expected.

But there are plenty of resources for them in other places. Have you exhausted Santa Fe? Artesanos was one of my favorites. There were other tile places on back streets there too. Perhaps wander by some pueblo style homes being built and ask for resources. Many of the stores are hidden in out of the way places and do not advertise.

Lynn may chime in and give you some great places in NM too. She has a wealth of resources.

All this, because I'm in CO (not Denver) and can't think of anyplace around with what you are after. The ones we have here are priced out of line, one would think they had gold in them. And they are the same as the majority of Mexican tile.

There should be a Sun Valley Bronze distributor in Denver now, when we were looking they didn't have samples yet but that was months ago. Their hardware is very nice, simple, well made and can have a bit of a rustic feel. Enjoy M tex. They provided our stone. For handmade tile, see Ed and Kate at Modern Bungalow

Thanks for the suggestions in Santa Fe. I've been up there a couple of times to look but did not think of Jackalope or Artesanos.
I have about 12 hours in Denver and needed some ideas to kill time! I am such a researcher and love to shop for my house.