Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
A question of aesthetics

Posted by fishymom (My Page) on
Sun, Apr 13, 14 at 16:54

I am wondering what I should do with my range hood. We had originally planned to run a stack all the way up to the ceiling to run the venting but it was easier to vent it through the soffit in the wall behind the hood because of the access space in the attic. It is vented to the outside and works perfectly but I am wondering if we should still run the stack up for aesthetic reasons. What do you think?

 photo 9686e33a-775c-43fa-9942-f964faf1f042.jpg


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

Really the question should be Does it bother you? It is functional. I don't think I would have noticed walking into the entire kitchen. If you had asked me to find something... Maybe. But I doubt it. If it bothers you add to it. I know I wouldn't.

Jen


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

What a pretty kitchen this is. Love it.

Your range hood looks fine to me at it's current height. If anything, I thinking running it higher could compromise the room aesthetics.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I don't have an opinion on the hood, but I have to say that I love your granite!


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

It is a lovely kitchen!!!

I don't know if running the stack to the ceiling is the answer, but it does look a little unfinished, somehow. maybe it is the white hood between dark cabinets. Could there be a way to connect the two dark areas? Then the eye keeps running down the line instead of studying the ceiling for the rest of the story.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I think it looks like it doesn't "go anywhere" and chimneys, which a traditional hood is, essentially, go up and out of the house. It looks non functional to me even though it is functional.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I say yes. It's a chimney hood with no chimney. If the top were the same level as the cabinet tops you could do a soffit or bridge to give it a terminus. As it is, running it up to the ceiling and putting the molding there makes more sense. If the molding on the top of the hood is integrated, you can echo that molding at the ceiling, and do an applique with the same feeling as on the lip of the hood in the middle of the tall stack to tie it all together.

But if you leave it the way it is, once you get into the living phase and out of the my kitchen is something I'm designing phase, you'll stop noticing it, and no one who isn't a design weenie will ever notice that it isn't what you intended.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I have to say yes, too.
Simply because it looks like a stairway to no where.

Your counters really compliment your cabinets -- and visa versa!

Just lovely.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I've looked at pictures of your lovely kitchen before & never thought "Oh, that chimney should go to the ceiling." Do a photoshop mockup first. I'm afraid it might look too tall in relation to the cabinets. I'm having trouble envisioning it up to the ceiling. Maybe once you get your backsplash in & the cabinets & chimney are connected to the countertops, it will be a non-issue.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

Thanks, I appreciate the opinions. And thank you for the compliments! Jreag, the granite is Magna Gold, an impulse buy which I absolutely love.

Jen, the hood doesn't really bother me and my husband is quite happy to leave it the way it is. And I'm not sure I really want to add more "weight" to that wall. It is the smallest wall in the kitchen and already feels weighty enough compared to the opposite wall, which is open to the ceiling above the cabinets.

In isolation, I can see how the hood looks unfinished, but in the context of the whole kitchen, I'm just not sure how a stack to the ceiling will work.

 photo K9.jpg

I have to take new photos, the green wall on the left and under the bar are now the same color as the opposite wall, but this lets you see how open the other wall is.
 photo K4.jpg

Thanks Romy, a photoshop mock-up is a great suggestion! Maybe Oldbat2be will see this and have a moment to play with it. The backsplash will go up to the base of the hood all the way across, so I am hoping that will help to tie the components together. I am hoping to get my tile ordered this week, still waiting for a couple of samples.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

Through the ceiling. And you need to cover that pantry side with stainless. It's a fire hazard and would not pass inspection as it exists.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

Photo does not show it clearly, but the side clearances have been met, but thanks for the heads up!


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

Lovely kitchen!!

Because the wall and the cabinets are tall and skinny, I'd worry that more *up* stuff would not be helpful aesthetics - wise. I almost wonder if some horizontal element above the hood and going across the upper cabinets would finish things off - kind of create a visual barrier that "explains" things?


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I like it the way it is. In this case, "less is more".


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I think once you put a backslash in it will pull it all together and it won't look so out of place. The two tone is throwing me off a little, so the hood kind of looks lonely sitting there being the only thing cream colored in that area. The backsplash will help that.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

You may not realize it, but reading your second message it's clear you've already decided for yourself. :) Sometimes you just need to defend it to know you have an answer.

Seeing the rest of your kitchen, however, I'm thinking similarly to Feisty, that some kind of horizontal element with the empty space above will work better. Even though the hood itself looks like it wants a chimney, that would break through the imaginary ceiling that the trim line on the uppers on the other side form against the void and put your kitchen out of balance. Additionally, people might see the chimney by itself through the void. It would be fine from a distance if the whole hood were in view, but the chimney in view by itself, considering it would be an nonfunctional addition, would just be odd.

This is all just chatter since you asked. I really do think you have a firm grip on what you need to do. :)

(This is goofy, and since you've just invested in a fairly formal kitchen, it's probably not your style, but it just occurred to me that what I'd do with it, myself, is paint a giant bouquet of Spring flowers on the wall above, using the hood as the vase.)


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

Plllog, I think you're right! I just cannot envision another vertical element on that wall. My husband and I were discussing ways to add a horizontal element to tie everything together. We are considering bringing the backsplash tile up to the top of the cabinets, with a frame style finishing tile versus just a bullnose. I am going to see if I can get some photoshop help to visualize it both ways, stopping backsplash at the bottom of the hood, as well as stopping at the top of the cabinets.

Funny about painting the hood! I have actually debated removing the Fleur de Lis element from the hood. The hood was part of the kitchen display that we started with and is much more traditional than I would have chosen, although my husband loves it.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

I agree with the previous poster that recommended a backsplash. I think if you choose a tile that works with all the elements (probably in a lighter tone) it will bring the whole together and finish it off. The eye won't be as inclined to wander up following the vertical lines.


 o
RE: A question of aesthetics

Fishymom,

Do, definitely, Photoshop it, but I can tell you right now that what you said about continuing the backsplash up and using a molding tile to finish it at the cabinet tops, will absolutely work. It'll tie the cabinets and the hood together, and mirror the imaginary ceiling line you have on the other side, with the top of the hood peeking through for interest. That will also make it look more like staggered cabinets than floating elements. Floating is fine, but doesn't go as well with the other legs of the kitchen.

Re the hood applique, you're right about the lines, but what it does for you (besides your husband liking it, which is a good enough reason for it), is it breaks up expectations. I know someone who always wears a black spot, but never a black outfit. It might be a pin, or a narrow belt, or button cover--but it could be an old plastic clip earring clipped to the corner of a sideseam pocket on a dress. She throws in the black spot for interest, to disrupt the expectation of unity, and it works. She always looks chic, even in the most boring clothes. :) Similarly, your flourish applique breaks up all the clean lines in just the right way, even though it's not specifically in with the style of your kitchen. :)


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here