Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Review my plan please

Posted by ash6181 (My Page) on
Sat, Apr 27, 13 at 16:27

Please take a look at my plan and let me know what you think. It's just me and my husband and we will probably not have children. I am typically the only one who works in the kitchen, although I usually do have some canine helpers who lay in the floor waiting for crumbs. I do a lot of cooking and baking, mostly from scratch. I also make jams and jellies and like to preserve seasonal food. I like to have parties and have a lot of serving dishes, china, glasses, linens, etc. to store.

Some concerns I have heard are that there is too much counter space and no where to eat other than the island. I'm not sure how to "fix" the counter space problem, if it is indeed a problem. Coming from the small amount of counter space I have now, I can't imagine having too much. I don't think we will mind eating at the island, but I welcome opinions from those with experience. I'm not sure where to add other seating, and we do also have a dining room.

I'm planning to add a prep sink. I'm thinking either the corner of the island closet to the refrigerator or the cabinet run next to the refrigerator against the pantry wall. I'd like to keep the island solid (without anything in the top like a sink), but I would consider putting the prep sink in the island if it would be better.

The kitchen is open to the living room through the opening and the right of the plan. The opening can be made smaller if needed. From the island I should be able to look through the living room and see the lake. The windows over the sink will look over our backyard and a pond.

I think I'm going to ask them to take out the niche to the left of the fridge. It's there because there is an air return below, but I think it can be moved elsewhere.

This is new construction, so almost anything is possible. I'll post a link to the entire first floor plan if anyone wants to see the kitchen in context. Thanks for your advice!

Ashley

 photo kitchen_edited-1_zpsa829f88a.jpg

Here is a link that might be useful: First floor plan


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Review my plan please

Oops, used the wrong link for the floor plan.

Here is a link that might be useful: First floor plan


 o
RE: Review my plan please

There are others who are way smarter than I am at the floor plan ideas but I will start. The distance between the sink,stove and fridge even with a prep sink is quite large.

I would consider putting the double ovens where the fridge now is and making that entire area a baking center with a prep sink on the island. I would then consider putting the fridge on the same wall as the range, at either end. If you put it at the garage end you would have to move the range down. Or you could put it anywhere from where the double ovens are now located down into the corner at the pantry.

Given where the DR, sunporch etc are, I would probably switch the DW to the other side of the sink for easier access when doing clean-up.

Have you posted the floorplan on the building forum for ideas as well.?


 o
RE: Review my plan please

Having a kitchen that size and considering the amount of home cooking/baking/canning you do; I'd definitely put in a larger cooktop. Would you upsize the appliances (s) and also add the prep sink? Those considerations may change how someone would work out a layout.


 o
RE: Review my plan please

I’m sorry, for some reason my e-mails weren’t coming through and I didn’t realize anyone had responded to my post.

ted by blfenton , thanks for your ideas. If I swapped the fridge and double ovens, I definitely wouldn’t want to put the fridge to the right of the cooktop (if you’re looking at it) because it would be very visible from the living room, and I’d like to avoid that. I’ll think about the switch, though. The dishwasher is an easy switch. I have posted on the building forum.

Remodelfla, we’re planning on a 36” induction cooktop. We’ll also have an auxiliary kitchen on our lower level so we’ll have an extra fridge, range, etc. if needed. I’m willing to upsize appliances, add a prep sink, and at least consider any other changes that anyone may have. I have an open mind.

If anyone else has ideas, I’d love to hear them!

Ashley


 o
RE: Review my plan please

just a crazy idea.. how about taking out everything in the top wall (with the sink), and put in a wall of sliding glass door to the grilling deck, which can open up the whole place to outdoor. put the sink in the island. :P


 o
RE: Review my plan please

I think it would be a waste to turn your back to the lake both during prep and eating. So having the prep sink on the island and the rounded eating area on the short side may be considered.


 o
RE: Review my plan please

That small counter between the ovens and wall seems strange. What about moving the ovens against that corner and put the refrigerator next to the ovens? That would give you a little better of a work triangle between the refrigerator, range and prep sink (less distance to travel to each).


 o
RE: Review my plan please

Noopd, that idea is not so crazy. I’ve actually considered something like that. Others have suggested at least one door in that area, so I’m going to play around with some ideas. Another thing I’ve considered is trying to add some sort of breakfast nook in that area.

Sena01, I agree. I plan to prep on the side of the island facing the lake. Given that, it probably makes the most sense to put the prep sink where you’ve indicated. As for the rounded island eating area, do you think that would interrupt the traffic flow by the sink? Thanks for drawing it up.

Gpraceman, my concern with that idea is that it would be more difficult to access the ovens if they were all the way against the wall because there wouldn’t be as much clear room in front of them. Also, if I started something on the cooktop and planned to finish it in the oven, I’d have to get around the refrigerator, and wouldn’t have a surface to set down a hot pan immediately next to the ovens. What do you think of those issues?


 o
RE: Review my plan please

@ash6181,

Any layout has to make sense for your lifestyle.

I'm not sure about your concern about clear room in front of the ovens. It looks like you have good sized walkway in front.

If you keep the refrigerator where it is, I'd consider sliding the ovens over to the corner, so you have a continuous countertop instead of what looks like an awkward and lonely bit of counter. That is, unless you had some special purpose in mind for that area.


 o
RE: Review my plan please

"As for the rounded island eating area, do you think that would interrupt the traffic flow by the sink?"

Well, that depends on how you serve your meals. That is, if you first serve some dishes, and while people are eating these, need the prep space/sink for something else, then eating area should definitely be outside your prep area.


 o
RE: Review my plan please

I know someone who has a "to die for" yard/view in the back but sadly not one thing in the house faces it. It's very strange! So I would really work on re-orienting things to focus on the lake or backyard. Also, why have a grilling deck you can't access from the kitchen? Grocery access from the garage doesn't seem very easy. Maybe you could add a pass-through from the garage straight into the pantry??


 o
RE: Review my plan please

gpraceman: I'm not sure if I had a special purpose for the space next to the ovens or not, but I had thought about what to do with it. I'm going to do some revisions and I'll see what it looks like with the ovens moved down. Thanks for you input.

sena01, most meals are served all at once- we don't usually have courses. I would prep at the island (I plan to add a prep sink), but wondered if I needed to extend the island to incorporate the rounded eating area if in would reduce the functionality of the aisle in front of the main sink..

kiko: we have tried to orient things to the backyard/lake. I've oriented the island so I can look out to the lake as I prep. The windows over the kitchen sink would look over the backyard. I know people sitting at the island don't have a view, but I'm not sure how to change that, other than the rounded island posted above or changing the main sink wall to add an eating area there. I'll probably add a door to the grilling deck, and I've been working on ideas for cutting down the garage to pantry trek. Thanks for your ideas.


 o
RE: Review my plan please

We radiused our island (thanks to GW) so that at least 2 would have the view. No stools are in the photo but now we have 4. It was a must that there be at least 2 seats with views.

kitchen9-5032_zps824de4e9 photo kitchen9-5032_zps824de4e9.jpg


 o
RE: Review my plan please

"... but wondered if I needed to extend the island to incorporate the rounded eating area if in would reduce the functionality of the aisle in front of the main sink.."

I didn't think of an extension of the island further than the present size. I assumed the rounded section would be a part of your prep area when you aren't eating.

If I understand the NKBA Guidelines correctly (sorry not a native speaker) you should be OK.

Guideline 5 says you'll need 65" clearance in front of the main sink. So you are 14" short. If you decrease the aisle b/w fringe wall and the island by 14", you'll have 37" there. I think Guideline 1b applies to that aisle so 37" would be enough. But you may have to move the oven closer to the pantry door.

You may also find this link useful.

http://ths.gardenweb.com/faq/lists/kitchbath/2011105828006802.html

Edited to add paragraph re. size of island.

Here is a link that might be useful: NKBA’s KITCHEN PLANNING GUIDELINES

This post was edited by sena01 on Wed, May 15, 13 at 20:27


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here