Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Posted by MarinaGal (My Page) on
Fri, Mar 28, 14 at 10:47

We remodeled our kitchen about 15 months ago and installed Caesarstone countertops (Blizzard and Pebble). I love the look and have had no issues whatsoever with staining. Overall, we are very happy with them. However, I have already had two tiny chips - one when a bottle hit the counter at the wrong angle and one near the rim of the sink. Again, very tiny chips, but I had granite counters for 11 years with no chips at all.

So..... we working on a kitchen remodel of our summer house and I was planning to use quartz again, but am a little concerned. Our summer house is used by lots of different guests, sometimes when we are not there, and I worry about damage.

My question is: what kind of quartz do you have, how long have you had it, and has it chipped? Thanks in advance for your input!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Silestone quarts, going on 4 years. The edges chip very easily. We have heavy All Clad pots and pans and they have left several chips on the edges around the sink. I was annoyed at first, I don't care anymore. Kind of annoying though considering the price and how they claim it is chip resistant.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

What kind of edge do you both have? My Cambria is only 7 months old, no chips yet. Mine has a rounded edge.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

We have had Caesarstone in the kitchen for 3 years. Some small chips around the sink. I bought a product on Amazon to repair the chips, which did not do it perfectly, but filled and masked them well enough.

I would make the same choice again, as I am happy with the look for my kitchen and lack of staining. And not a fan of the look of granite.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

About a week after we had Caesarstone installed, I found a chip above the DW. It could have been chipped during fabrication and pulled loose by a sponge, because that's where I found the chip. Or we could have bumped it while loading/unloading.

We had an install issue and replaced the Caesarstone with Pentalquartz. I was a little afraid to go with Caeserstone again as it had some weird white blotches, and I could view my PQ slabs locally. My second countertop arrived with a repaired chip from fabrication. It is a little shinier than the rest of the counter, otherwise I wouldn't have noticed. In the 18 months that we've had Pentalquartz, there's a tiny chip inside the sink, noticeable only by feel. I have bumped the edge with a pan a few times but it didn't chip, though it makes me nervous.

It's just two of us and we're careful. We have an eased edge, but a rounded edge is really the best choice, especially in a busy kitchen.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

I've had Caesarstone (Smoky Ash) for a little over 2 years. Eased edge. No chips anywhere, no damage of any kind to report. My sink has a positive reveal. I live alone and don't do lots of entertaining.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

I've had Silestone Blue Sahara for 10 years with no chips or problems. It is just the standard eased edge.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Only 5 months in, but no chips in our Silestone counters so far. And I've banged the edges several times, especially around the dishwasher. We have about the sharpest edge you can get, ~1/8 - 1/4" radius, so I guess we're living dangerously, but we've been lucky so far


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Almost a year with Silestone Lagoon. I have an ogee edge and an eased edge around the sink. No chips yet with pretty heavy use and a 12 yr old boy.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

About 10 months since the install, eased edge, and no chips. I have an apron front sink for cleanup, so perhaps this reduces the risk (I notice a lot of the issues reported are near the sink). I'm more scared about cracking my fireclay sink (these new Demeyere pans I've been convinced to buy via GW are uber heavy!)


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Only a couple of months in, so I probably shouldn't even respond, but we have Ceasarstone (Organic White) with eased edges everywhere (kitchen and two bathrooms), no chips at all.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Cambria Darlington, eased edge, 3 years, nothin' (!)


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Cambria Buckingham, 1.75 years, eased edge, not a single chip!


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Like sjhockeyfan, we are only a couple of months into our remodeled kitchen ("Winfield Kitchen" on Houzz) and we love our Silestone on the island and our Daltile OneQuartz on the perimeter counters. I have held my breath after knocking some heavy items (stoneware baking sheet, cast iron pan) into the area around the sink, but so far they have held up.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Here's a tip for avoiding chips above the dishwasher. Place a cutting board on the counter pulled almost up to the edge and leave it there. You won't chip the counter and it provides a good landing area for hot things anyway. That's what I have done after getting three small chips on the edge of my marble countertops.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

We've had our Hanstone counters for almost a month, which I know isn't very long, but I've had a couple of blunders already - dropping a screwdriver (business end pointing downward!) from a few feet above the counter, and banging the corners in the stove area with the stove while sliding it back after sealing the backsplash - and not even a tiny chip or scratch thus far.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

We have Silestone on the perimeter in Cygnus. Love the look. About a week after installation a glass fell out of the cabinet onto the counter. The glass didn't break, it hit the counter at an angle on the bottom rim of the glass. But there is a very tiny, or should I say very, very, tiny chip in the countertop that is white. You have to be right over it to see it. But it did give me pause to know that it will chip and be white underneath. I'm very careful now, but I still love the countertops. We have granite on the island.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

We have cesarstone chocolate truffle which is made with recycled glass and we have a half bull nose edge. 4 years in and there is the tiniest bit if a chip that I feel when I clean the counter surface...I think it's due to the fact that the glass isn't as tough as the quartz as close inspection shows it's the glass that's chipped. Otherwise no problems at all.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Thanks, everyone - very interesting to hear your experiences. We have an eased edge on our Caesarstone kitchen countertops. I have Cambria in the master bath and I have banged it a couple of times with a glass, and no damage. My understanding is that all quartz is essentially made the same way, but I noticed that none of the Cambria owners above reported chips.... I wonder if there could be a difference?

A round edge is a good suggestion. I am not a fan of granite, especially for the look I am going for in this kitchen, and if I decide against quartz I would consider Corian (I love Corian!) but my architect/builder literally grimaced when I said that. :) I need to show him how beautiful Corian can be.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

When you're a fabricator, the first thing you look at is how to cut costs to become more competitive. Rounding edges at sinks is usually the first thing to go. The eased edge looks nice and is cheap to do.

Unfortunately, the more expensive 1/2" radius edge is much more practical. Fabricators do their customers no service when they don't try to up-sell.

Of course price-shopping consumers are getting just what they deserve too.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Trebruchet - that is interesting. I picked the eased edge because I preferred the look, not based on price. However, the fabricator didn't say anything to me about practicality. So they most definitely did not try to upsell, and I would have appreciated the information!


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

I also prefer the look of the eased edge over rounded. Rounded edge would not look right in my kitchen & bathrooms.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

In our last home we had Silestone Kala Hari for 12 years. There were a couple very small chips around the sink, and a couple places on the flat part where particulates had popped out. None of them were visible, but I could feel them when I ran my fingernail over them. Was not an issue for me at all.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

I've had Silestone Tebas Black in my current kitchen for 9 years, no chips to date. I have the standard eased edge.

That being said, I'm still struggling with what countertops to go with for the new house.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

trebuchet-
can this 1/2 radius edge be done just at the sink? would it look odd if the rest of the counters are eased?

clarification:
1) when people say "chips at the sink" do they mean the countertop edge in front of the sink, or the countertop edge *inside* the sink?

2) when I asked my question about about 1/2 radius edge at the sink, I meant inside the sink, not at the countertop edge in front of the sink.

This post was edited by illinigirl on Fri, Mar 28, 14 at 20:17


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

We've had Cambria for 11 years. No issues at all.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Interesting read. Glad I stuck with my plan for a drop-in sink in our coming quartz counters.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

"can this 1/2 radius edge be done just at the sink? would it look odd if the rest of the counters are eased?"

Yes, it can be done at just the sink. No, It doesn't look odd at all and looks a hell of a lot better than a chipped edge.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

we have had Cambria Quartz kitchen countertops for two years. We love them, no chips and I would use Cambria again for sure!


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

"No, It doesn't look odd at all and looks a hell of a lot better than a chipped edge."
How true!

So, to summarize: What's the best edges in terms of preventing chips, both for undermount sink and general edge? For everything, rounded over eased? Or definitely rounded for the sink because that's where chips are most likely?

I prefer the look of eased but not if it's chipped.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

Silestone Mahogany - about 6 years now - not a chip in sight. Love it - and I do not baby it at all


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

to add to the rounded edge at the sink discussion: how does the reveal choice change the likelihood of chipping? Does a positive sink reveal lower the chipping likelihood?


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

We got an eased edge in the bathroom, but a slightly more rounded edge in the kitchen, just for the chipping issue. Our fabricator told us Caesarstone was somewhat harder and less prone to chipping than the other brands, all other things being equal. Something to do with warm-curing vs cold-curing... I don't know, we made our selections based on the colors we needed.


 o
RE: quartz countertop owners - a little survey

"So, to summarize: What's the best edges in terms of preventing chips, both for undermount sink and general edge? For everything, rounded over eased? Or definitely rounded for the sink because that's where chips are most likely?"

The bigger the roundover, the less likely to chip.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here