Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Marble counter substitutes..

Posted by Gidge816 (My Page) on
Wed, Feb 19, 14 at 19:23

My boyfriend and I are first time homeowners and have bought a fixer-upper that needs a totally new kitchen. I have chosen a light grey cabinet and plan on a whitish black splash and I think marble goes beautifully with both. I hear so many marble horror stories and I cook A LOT and to be honest the marks and stains would bother me and I would probably become a slave to keeping the countertop pristine (which I hear is impossible) What is a great substitute? So far I've seen Silestone lagoon and like it but can anyone recommend another close second to marble? Can someone with marble or a marble substitute share their experience? Pictures would be greatly appreciated since I haven't found much..


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

We have been looking for something similar as well. Check out this link. It has the best summary on all the options out there. *Well, there are probably more options, but I found this pretty comprehensive! Once I saw this, I then did tons of searches for those colors on Houzz and here on GW and also seeing them in person at a stone yard on a large slab really helps.

Here is a link that might be useful: White marble alternatives..


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

You owe it to yourself to check out Corian and other solid surface materials. They outperform natural stone easily.


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

Thanks for posting that link. I'm about ready to give up on marble stone look a like. The link showed me to seriously consider manmade. Thanks again


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

I just saw a new KBIS 2014 report on the newly available huge slab sized white marble looking material that is actually like a porcelain tile. This new size is aprox 10 x 5 feet (3200mm x 1500mm) and close to a standard 2cm thickness. This is the same company that I think several GW's reported using (for bathroom tiles) instead of natural marble with glowing reports. They made several sizes including large format tiles (aprox 18x24, 9x12, 4x6) and this looks equal to a full slab size that has the properties of porcelain but the look of marble. Have not seen it in person but worth checking out. It is called Classtone by Neolith and I have a link below of the KBIS introduction.

Unless you have alteady done so, you might also check out some white granites or natural stone quartzites (not to be confused with the man made quartz). Be sure to look up the GW posts about Rocks, Quartzites and other Rocks in the Kitchen, Parts 1 - 4, for great info in general and how to test individual slabs you are interested in for durability for etching, hardness, stain ability, etc. One thing that has come across in those threads is that all natural stones are NOT the same and just the names and categories can't always be accurate. So you have to test to be sure.

Or maybe some of the solid surface synthetics will work for you. Always good to have choices! Hope this helps. Let us know of your progress.

Here is a link that might be useful: Porcelain slab sized marble look alike


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

Did you see this recent post? It has pictures of these new porcelain slab look alike white marble with pictures ...

Here is a link that might be useful: Other GW post about this


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

I was so excited reading about this because I thought I could use it as the backsplash behind the range, but at those prices I couldn't afford to buy a whole slab.


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

It wasn't inexpensive, but the quartzite options can be very pretty and light. I went with Taj Mahal which wasn't as white as my husband wanted originally but living with it has been so very easy. And I am a messy cook, though even now I avoided setting down a messy bottle of olive oil where rings will sit for extended periods. Instead I just place it on a saucer. I'm very curious about the porcelain slabs. Will they be super durable?


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

I have to say.... I've always thought if I couldn't tolerate marble I wouldn't find something similar to it b/c honestly there is no "substitute". There's something about marble that nothing else can capture. That said, I would try to focus on embracing a different stone instead. I'm a marble person...... nothing else will do...... however, I've been in people's homes that have granite and have been able to think it's very very pretty..... not for me, but very pretty.

Actually, Pietra Cardoso is a fantastic countertop.... when you see it, it actually has an essence of marble (it's quarried very close to where carrara marble is quarried, so they could be cousins :) ), however, it's a dark color and looks more like a slate or soapstone (but you'd know the difference when you saw it). I believe it's a schist (I could be wrong) so you'd still want to be careful with acids.


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

Try a manmade quarts counter like ceasarstone or a quartzite, which is a natural stone, in a light color such as white macaubus or calcutta.


 o
RE: Marble counter substitutes..

We just finished up a new build and used honed Carrara marble. I knew I wanted marble and searched high and low for a substitute. The only acceptable substitute I could find was a quartzite called Sea Pearl and it was almost double the price. Also looked at White Macabas which was significantly more. We have been in our new house for over 2 months...still tying up some loose ends like our kitchen backsplash, etc... but after living with the marble I have to say I love it and am SO GLAD I went with what I wanted. It is so beautiful. We are red wine drinkers, coffee drinkers, cook spaghetti. Not to mention I have three messy sons. :-) We purchased a 15-year stain warranty for $200 (Dry Treat) which treated our kitchen counters, powder room (polished Carrara) and master bath (polished Cappucino marble). If it stains after 15 years it will be time for a remodel anyway. So far it has not stained or etched.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here