Bump - any KD's have any comments on Grabill v. Shiloh?

Thanks Kompy, I appreciate your professional input and personal opinion for your own home. It is indeed our "forever home". We are thinking it might not even be a full 25% upcharge if we are creative in our configuration (mix full overlay with inset or something like that). You could see a difference in the finish but $ in the pocket when you are building has a definite voice too, lol!

Thanks again.

Hi Autumn 4- sorry to be responding so late ---I've been too busy enjoying our remodel and have shirked my responsibilities here. We love love love our Grabill cabs. We had been looking at Brookhaven but the day I went to sign the contract I saw a crack in the MDF in the display at the store. I honestly walked out and went immediately to the dealer with the Grabill cabs I had loved but thought were too expensive. The dealer worked with me and brought the price to within my budget and without me having to cut out much. I can post pictures tomorrow. I hope that helps.

Hi secondhalf - I just now saw this. I was on vacation when you posted - so easy to lose track so I completely understand!

Pictures would be awesome if it's not too much trouble.

You are loving the finish and so far so good? For our size kitchen the Grabill weren't too much of a hit to take upgrading from Shiloh - with a few modifications. That would be with doing some mixing - so not ALL inset but maybe inset on the drawers and full overlay on the uppers or something like that.

Had you considered Shiloh at all or you had settled on Brookhaven until you saw the display (good thing you saw it before your ordered!)?

I know this is an old thread but has secondhalf ever post her finished kitchen pics? Love her kitchen!