Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

Posted by dreamsalive (My Page) on
Wed, Jan 14, 09 at 16:57

Do you happen to know the difference in quality between Brookhaven cabinets and Diamond cabinets (same as Thomasville, just not sold through HDepot from what I understand)? Please help me understand which is better quality & if it's really noticable. I'll be doing a painted off-white cabinet, maybe with a glaze.
Thanks!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

I can't be sure, but I think I looked at Diamond cabinets at one of the KD showrooms. It was good quality, but Brookhaven blew me away. The cabinets that came into my home are really exquisite! The finish is amazing and seemingly durable.
Just remember to go with what you like. No one is going to come into your kitchen with the door of the cabinet brand you didn't chose and try and compare them :).


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

I thought Brookhaven was better and definitely liked the finishes better. I don't remember the details other than the finish. Brookhaven is made by Woodmode and the construction is similar. The finishing and options give you more in Woodmode. I have both Woodmode and Brookhaven in my kitchen, and while I do notice things like the Woodmode deep drawers have sides that come up full height while the Brookhaven are maybe 2/3 height and the interiors are natural finished maple rather than a melamine, I don't find any difference in quality in terms of their use and function.


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

If you are doing white, there is no comparison to Brookhaven/Wood-Mode. I just posted some pics of our white Brookhaven kitchen on another thread, if you're interested. And I looked at EVERY brand, I think...even local, custom shops. Took me months--my husband thought I lost it, I think!!!

What I liked is that they had SO many options in white cabinets--most companies just have this incredibly Thermofoil-ish bright white or REALLY creamy/beige off-white. I didn't want either and couldn't find any mid-range manufacturer that gave you as many choices as Brookhaven.

Our whole kitchen priced out the same in Brookhaven as it did in Schrock--we got everything you see in my other post for 14K--lots of upgrades, but a basic door style (just remembered the name--Edgemont--cheaper than the even plainer Colony door) and no glaze. Thought the glaze might go out of style and added a significant expense.

No complaints about our Brookhaven at all.
:)
Sarah from Albany, NY


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

"Cabinet components constructed of furniture-grade particleboard "

And that's why we didn't go with them.


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

SARAH,so good to see you posting again!! I had saved the pic that you posted on the other thread to my favorites a long time ago. A couple of questions please: What color white are your cabinets and what size sink base did you get for your shaw sink? My KD told me that there were two types of Brookhaven farm house sink bases, but I never got to know what the differences were. Everything was secret!! We decided not to go with that KD, but still interested in Brookhaven.

Glad to see you back and can't wait for more pictures of your kitchen. Zoe


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

Zoe--I *think* it was Nordic White. Is that an option? I wanted it to look really white--not creamy--but not be so thermofoil white-ish like some other companies had. The choices in white and the great finish is what drew me to Brookhaven in the first place.

The sink base is a 30" base with a 30" sink in it. It fits nicely with support added in by contractor and some scribing around the sink once it was in place. It had to fit, since I only had room on that wall for the DW to the right of the sink and two lazy susans flanking either end of that run.

It wasn't really a farmhouse sink base--it was modified, I think. My KD said (now this was two years ago) that there really wasn't a base slated for farmhouse sinks as such--especially those as heavy as the Rohl Shaw's fireclay. They may have since added in some type of farmhouse-friendly cabinet to their line--I have no idea.

:)
Sarah


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

Saran and I have the same Brookhaven cabinets -- it is Nordic White. I didn't opt for the farmhousse sink (I love that Shaw's, but DH wasn't sold and I wasn't so sold that I had to sell him on it. LOL). I don't think you can go wrong with Brookhaven -- and agree that they have better options in painted finishes, don't charge you 15-20% more, and they are beautifully done.


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

Sarah from albany -- where did you get your brookhaven cabinets and i can't find the photos you posted.


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

Hey there guys, new to the site. My wife and I are redoing our kitchen, we live on Long Island. I have been to HD and Lowes along with a few kitchen places. Out budget is not allowing us to go custom with out cabinets. Between Thomasville, Kraftmade, Diamond or Fabuware and thoughts?
Thanks!!

This post was edited by Katzy2112 on Mon, Mar 11, 13 at 15:41


 o
RE: Brookhaven vs. Diamond (Thomasville) Cabinets

For those of you who mentioned you used Brookhaven or Woodmode can you please post a picture of your kitchen in this thread and tell me what door style and color you used.
I too am thinking of using Brookhaven, mostly because I think I want white cabs. I'm not capable of DIY so Home Depot and places that sell several options are out and here most designers or design build firms use custom which would be great except the paint finish options are not as heavy duty in CA. So I finally found a KD I like and the only option for paint is Woodmore of Brookhaven.

Also can you tell me why you chose Woodmove over Brookhaven or vice versa? Was it price, style, or ?

Thank you!!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here