Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Posted by redroze (My Page) on
Thu, Jan 23, 14 at 14:08

Has anyone ever removed a perfectly good granite countertop and replaced it with another one? Mine is Bianco Antico, and though it's perfectly beautiful I always have had the nagging feeling that I should have gone with my gut. And my gut said to go with marble, and my brain said that granite would be more reasonable. Recently I saw a kitchen with the most fabulous idea - veined marble on the island (we use ours mainly for prep) and a matching plain white Caesarstone on the perimeters. Beauty and function all in one!

My kitchen is only 5 years old...so if we were to remove the counters we'd obviously move them elsewhere. I think we could use them for our future (way way future) basement reno as we'll add a mini kitchen down there. However, what kind of damage would I be doing to my cabinets? Am I just crazy and I should I just stop being a spoiled brat and live with my decision?

Here is a link that might be useful: My kitchen


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Depends how the counter is mounted to the cabinets.

Best case scenario, the counter is glued to plywood, and the plywood is affixed to the cabinets with screws from below, in which case you can unscrew the plywood from below and the counters & plywood will come right up. Mine are installed like this.

However, if the counter is glued directly to the cabs, or if the plywood is screwed into the cabs from above, then it's far more difficult to disassemble.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

That is the danger of Gardenweb!! You have a gorgeous kitchen as is!

I am in a similar situation as I want marble and or quartz (I like Raven, organic white and London Gray), but we are moving in 18 months or less. So I am trying to find a granite that will mimic the look hence appealing to a potential buyer. Yours does come close! But that gut problem does get in the way doesn't it?


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

I am a fabricator.

you definitely could,salvage at least some of your existing tops. biggest risk is cracking of a sink or cooktop rail which can occur despite anything anyone ncan do.

re: removal; if 3CM typically they are only "glued" in place along the perimeter of the cabinets and can be cut free relatively easily. 2CM with a laminate edge typically has a plywood subtop which can make removal much harder.

in either case removing installled granite without damaging anything is a lot of work.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

I know this doesn't help anyone with anything, but I'm so excited because my Ceasarstone Organic White counters are going in starting, 3-2-1 NOW!! (kitchen and two bathrooms). Finally.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Wow your kitchen is absolutely gorgeous. I can see why you're dreaming of the marble island - they seem to be everywhere nowadays and do look good. Never the less, your kitchen looks great and I wouldn't bother changing anything unless the granite started having major issues (cracking or something). You could have formica and your kitchen would still look good... hehehe.. I say enjoy the granite because it looks good and is durable.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Woohoo sjhockeyfan! That's exciting.

Thanks for all the help all. Looks like my dreams will have to deal with reality. I don't think it's worth it. Maybe an island counter change would be less risky as it only has a prep sink...but marble definitely wouldn't match it.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

redroze, I think your kitchen is beautiful as is. Maybe its because I have your granite and think is really adds something to a kitchen. White cabinets with white marble would just seem boring to me but everyone is different.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Your kitchen really is beautiful, even with a stone that isn't "perfect" (to your eye). I was going to say you could just change the island surface, but then I realized you already have different cabinets on the perimeter and the island so I think that would be too many different finishes, and having the countertops all the same ties it all together. I think it's not worth the expense or the trouble.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Your kitchen is beautiful but I also believe if you can afford it, follow your heart:)


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

redroze I have a marble island and white Caesarstone perimeter counters. While I love the combination, I have to weigh in with a cautious "no" for your kitchen. Since you have all white cabinets on your perimeter, I think a white counter there will look very stark. I know sjhockeyfan voted against this (and I understand her reasoning), but what about only replacing the island counter with marble, and leaving the perimeter counters as they are right now? You could buy some butcher block paper and cover the island top with it to get an idea.

I think your kitchen is gorgeous as it is, but I understand the lure of marble.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

I think your kitchen is just perfect as is!


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

I hear all of you and agree the granite is beautiful. That's why I feel like a spoiled brat!

Annakathryn what marble colour do you think would work? I adore your kitchen.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

redroze, My husband just pulled up all our granite countertops as he was sick of them (almost 120 years old).
I am going to put Bianco Antico on my island and Zodiac quartz on my perimeter. Hoping to maybe use our old granite for a vanity top or a gas fireplace possibly.
You can remove it, just depends on how it is attached and have to be careful. I think your kitchen is beautiful.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

redroze your kitchen seems to be taupe-y, on the gray side as opposed to the gold side, so a marble with more gray veins rather than caramel/cream seems the way to go. Some of the calacatto oro slabs might work if they tend towards gray.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Sammy - I have a friend who has Bianco Antico on the island and grey quartz on the perimeters. So can vouch for the fact that it will look really nice!

Annakathryn, yes you're right that it's very gray and not warm/gold. Calacatta oro...you're totally speaking my language. I actually used Calacatta Gold (which I'm assuming is Oro in Italian?) in our bathrooms. Hmm I have a small slab...let me see what it looks like against the BA.

Here is a link that might be useful: My master bath


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Hmm...what do you think? Keep the BA on the perimeter (which reads overall more dark/grey/taupe than the white due to the amount of dark in it) and Calacatta Oro on the island? Does it work?


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

I think your granite is beautiful and your kitchen is gorgeous as is. And you don't have to worry about etching as you would with marble. Changing your island to that marble won't make your kitchen look any better and it might be worse because I'm not sure if the patterns in your granite go that well with that marble.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Apply generous gobs of hot melt adhesive on the small edge of a 2x4 then adhere it to the sink and/or cooktop cut-out rails. Extending past each cutout a foot or so, the 2x4s provides granite the strength in tension it doesn't have but needs to be moved without cracking.

Smack the top edge of the 2x4 to remove it, scrape the glue off the stone, and cleanup with a little solvent after it's reinstalled.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Redroze, why not simply wait and use the marble in your basement kitchen?


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

We just bought a new house that had a kitchen with a terrible layout and cabinets/granite countertops that were not our style. We were able to remove the granite countertops without damaging the cabinets. We removed the whole kitchen and were able to sell them on craigslist. I'm not sure if all kitchens would remove as easily as ours, but other than the amount of time it took, it was not difficult. Good luck with your decision!


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Yes, you're being a bit ridiculous - the kitchen looks great as is - but if you've got the money to redo it the way you want (including cabinet repair/replacement), then go for it.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Thanks for the opinions all...food for thought. I'll have to discuss with my husband. Making a marble kitchen in the basement would be a nice alternative too...kinda indulgent but I guess there will be a lot less counter down there so more affordable too.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Can be done, we put granite in our kitchen on the exsisting cabinets, that I thought would do it for me, and then 5 years later donated the counters and cabinets to put in a whole new kitchen. Nothing was damaged, Green Demolitions did a great job removing everything and at least it could be reused. So if your using it in the basement eventually, your still getting use out of it. do the marble in the kitchen, rather than the basement, because it sounds like that is what you always wanted..


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Totally agree Michelle and it's good to hear others have had success with it!!! I'm excited....something to look forward to.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

FYI - redroze, I went to look at your kitchen again and the link goes to nothing.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Debrak2008...sorry about that. I'm in the process of moving my website to another domain. Here's the new link.

Here is a link that might be useful: My new blog


 o
Sorry - Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Woops let me try that again

Here is a link that might be useful: My blog


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Reading through the thread, I realize the photo of the kitchen (of AnnKathryn I believe) is the kitchen I saw on Houzz and copied the pendant lights from!! Thanks AnnKathryn! I love my pendant lights!!


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

redroze have you decided to go ahead and make the change?

lcskaisir the photo I posted above from Houzz isn't my kitchen. Were those the pendants you bought? Very pretty. Mine were Bruck Rainbow II which I love.

Here is a link that might be useful: Bruck pendants


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Lol, that's what I get for skimming through quickly! I read that redroze loved your kitchen annkathryn and then I saw a photo of a kitchen posted by you so I assumed that was yours! I bought those pendants about a year ago after seeing them in that Houzz photo, funny to see that exact photo posted on here. Sorry for misunderstanding! Now I really want to see your kitchen!


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

lcskaisgir my kitchen is much less grand than the one I posted in the photo above, but I'm still happy with it after a year of using it. Link to the reveal thread is below.

Here is a link that might be useful: Finished kitchen: Ikea, walnut, marble and glossy white


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

I'm sorry redroze for hijacking your thread. This is my last off-subject comment, I promise!

Annkathryn, your kitchen is beautiful! I especially love the island counter, walnut counter, and niche cabinet. And I also really love your stair rail and the clever storage under your stairs!


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

thanks lcskaisgir :)

Sorry for the hijack, redroze.


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

No apologies needed!! Ironically I read through the lessons learned on my blog and realized that I was being wistful over something I didn't choose. I love my kitchen the way it is and if a change in counter was ever a reasonable possibility down the line, I'll do it. For moe il enjoy it as it is!


 o
RE: Changing granite to marble/caesarstone

Oh and I disagree annkathryn, your kitchen is drool worthy. That marble waterfall is to die for. It's kitchens like yours that (almost) make me want to yank out my granite.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here