Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

Posted by rc808 (My Page) on
Fri, Jan 1, 10 at 13:40

Cost experts, here's the kitchen in question:

I really just don't like it. Bad layout, too small. And there's plenty of room to expand it.

If you look where the door is, there's a ton of dead space there that could be used. Further down is a solid wall that borders the dining room. You could eliminate that door and have some nice french doors leading outside where the dining room is.

So, here's what I think I could do:

- Where the 30" fridge and stove are right now gets ripped out. Maybe reuse the cabinets above the range or fridge for the relocated range. Make a space there for a 36" fridge and put counter-depth cabinets around and on top of it for "pantry"-type storage. No countertops needed, obviously, as it's all cabinets
- Rip out the island, it's ugly and takes up a lot of room. Would probably have to do some refinishing on the floor under it, or install new floor if there's nothing there.
- Where the door is now is where the range now goes. On the right of the relocated range are more cabinets. An exterior hood vent is also established (easier to do since the door is being ripped out there). Use the granite from the retired island for the countertops at the end. So no new granite is needed for the project. Yes, there is a big enough slab of granite on the island that can't be seen in this photo.
- Since it'll be potentially impossible to match new cabinet faces with old, even if we do figure out the manufacturer and they still make those cabinets (house was built in 2005): Reface ALL cabinets. Probably same finish as current, unless the 'boxes' can be stained darker. Shaker style full overlay with contemporary handles.
- Totally optional would be a new, better placed island if budget permits.

So, other than the cost of appliances, can anyone take a rough guess as to how much this would cost?

I see the following challenges:

- Removing exterior door and framing, insulating, and drywalling empty space
- Creating new french doors in existing wall.
- New cabinets where fridge/stove currently exist, new cabinets where range will be relocated.
- Removing island, considering flooring.
- Taking granite from island and recutting for extra counterspace
- New cabinet faces and hardware.

Can anyone take a ROUGH ballpark as to where this might land in budget WITHOUT appliances? It'd be good to know deciding whether or not to buy and go through with this, and also in negotiating with the seller.

Keep in mind I am a member of Direct Buy, so I can get many cabinet products at cost, as well as flooring if needed.

I was figuring $20k worst case scenario. Am I low or high?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

another pic.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

It's going to depend a lot on where you are. Where is the house?


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

Where in the country are you located? And would you be doing the work yourself, acting as your own GC but hiring individual trades to come in, or going with a full GC for everything? Also, is there any "hidden" work that needs to be done (electrical upgrades, plumbing/gas line movement, load-bearing wall changes)? I'm in Virginia and have rapidly realized that there isn't much you can do for $20K unless you keep your existing cabinets (or do most or all of the work yourself). An Andersen french door can be $2000 or more. I think you may be at $25 - $35K with new cabinets, and if you hire out the work.


 o
forgot to add

Forgot to add that the $25K-$35K is without appliances


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

Our previous house's kitchen had a layout similar to this kitchen. There are lots of ways of improving it and many are shown in the FKB.

I would reconsider your totally tearing out of the island and using that space to make the kitchen more functional by either using it for the cooktop or a prep sink and prep space.

If you do tear out the island, then you need to include totally redoing the floor to your budget.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

House is in CT.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

Rethinking the island now. I should take another look. So you all think 25-35? Don't I save a lot by reusing most of the cabinets and counters?

If I could keep the same island footprint, but rework it, that might work. I just really don't like the island as-is.


 o
Layout

Here's a crude not-to-scale layout. blue represents existing cabinetry and green new cabinetry.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

Are you going to do the work yourself or hire it out? Big difference in price, there.

Refacing cabinets does not save much off of full replacement, but I actually think it's pretty likely that you could match the ones you've got.

What is the exterior of the house? Brick work will be more expensive to alter for the new and old door than, say, siding.

If there's any wiring or plumbing in the wall you plan to take out for the new door, that could run into some money. You will also need to move the electrical or gas line for the stove (I can't tell which from the photos).

My husband and I could DIY this project for about $5K, probably, but if you're hiring a contractor, I'd guess around $20-30K.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

Not sure, I may DIY it. I have a contractor friend through work that does stuff at a very reasonable price for me and does excellent work. He himself only charges 45 an hour for his own time. Pretty good.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

Also, exterior is vinyl siding.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

"...Bad layout, too small. And there's plenty of room to expand it...."

If you plan to redo the layout, and I don't blame you, I'm not sure you can reuse the countertop. Cabinets, maybe, if you can match the door style for new ones.

Are the cabinets in good shape, structurally? Are they functional? Are the base cabinets the "basic" cabinets...fixed half-depth shelf? Or, were they at least upgraded to have adjustable full-depth shelves? If the latter, you can probably make them more functional using after-market inserts/pullouts/etc. like those from Rev-A-Shelf, Hafele, or other manufacturer. If the former, well, it's up to you if you want to try to retro-fit those after-market inserts/pullouts/etc.

If the cabinets are not structurally sound or look like they won't last at least another 10 years, then I would reconsider reusing them (that is, if you intend to stay in the house that long).

They look OK, but looks can be deceiving.


Have you considered Ikea cabinets? Those that have them here really like them. They're inexpensive and may be less than it will cost to reface + add new of your current ones. They have good quality hardware (Blum), have many of the "bells & whistles" that more expensive cabinets have, and are rated highly by Consumer Reports.

While Ikea has mostly "modern" styles, it does have more "traditional" looking doors. Plus, if you want different doors, you can order doors from places like Scherr's that are made specifically to fit Ikea cabinets. For now, you could go with the Ikea boxes & doors and later, when money becomes available, replace the doors with something you like better. Meanwhile, you will have structurally sound cabinets that should last a long time.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

I will check out Ikea. I like the shaker style best for cabinets. Dark maple is my favorite finish, with black countertops.


 o
cost

I should mention too that I have access to Direct Buy and can get all cabinets at cost.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

I would be wary of Direct Buy. There have been several threads about Direct Buy and issues with them. I'm not a member, but if you want more info, you might start a thread asking about it.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

You should ask around and get a feel for how much a typical kitchen costs in the area that you live. Then add that value to the price of the house. If you can find another house for the total price with the kitchen you like, that will be the cheapest and the easiest route for you and your family.

When and if you buy this house, live in the house for a while and see what the kitchen really needs. Looks can be quite deceiving.

BTW, there are ways to do the remodel "right" and there are way to just get the remodel done. There is a house in the neighborhood with vinyl siding. They redid the kitchen and where they filled in the door, they did NOT even try to match the vinyl siding.... They just stuck another piece of vinyl siding.

Unfortunately, vinyl siding may be much more difficult to match than wood siding that can be painted. I would ask around and see if you can find the manufacturer of the vinyl siding and the color and see how the "fill in" would look. To me this would be the deal breaker.... If I moved to a new house AND I just remodeled my kitchen, I would hate to live in a house with a piece of unmatched vinyl siding stuck on one wall.


 o
RE: Found a house I like, but not the kitchen. Cost to expand?

There are paints for vinyl siding. Of course once you paint the siding, it is no longer maintenance-free.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here