Return to the Kitchens Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
DD graduating! What about insurance???

Posted by patrice607 (My Page) on
Wed, Nov 15, 06 at 9:16

I just got off the phone with our insurance company. DD will be off our insurance the night she graduates - 12/16.
Cobra is over $600/month. I have looked online and found a few short term policies but they are expensive and don't cover much. W'e be paying about $100/month with a $1,000 deductible. Any ideas/suggestions would be welcomed.

She is looking for a teaching job but I need a contingency plan just in case.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

$100 sounds good to me. $600 sounds really high, I hope you have a good plan. I work as a retirement/health care actuary, so I see a lot of premiums that employers are charged for their employees' health care.

Now, back when I was 20 and needed temporary health care, I went to an insurance agent. I got a policy for $20 a month with a very large deductible. Since that was almost 30 years ago, I think $100 is very reasonable.

But still, go to an independent insurance agent and see what's available. There are also online resources that will find insurance for you. Since I don't know your zip code, I can't get a good comparison from one of those sites.


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

Does DD's alumni association offer group medical insurance?


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

I also did a policy with a large deductible when I was in a similar situation. It was very cheap. I think the deductible was around $2500 or so. The idea is to cover catastrophic incidences (the type that bankrupt you or kill you), not smaller things.


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

patrice, they won't give you a grace period?

I'd ask- ours did for DivaD1 with a slight upcharge. I think they gave us 6 months, but we had to ask. They certainly didn't offer.


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

The $100 policy sounds like a screaming deal. Because we are self-employed, my DH and I pay $760/mo (for both of us), and we have a $3,600 annual deductible, .

I recently read a long article in the WSJ about children remaining on adult policies long after graduation, as long as they live at home. It was probably within the last few months, maybe since August? Perhaps it would give you some other ideas.

Molly~


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

patrice607-

I'm not sure where you are, but here in NY (not exactly a cheap state) individual COBRA policies run in the $250/month range and $600 would be for 2 person coverage. Make sure your HR department is quoting you the individual rate for your DD and don't forget to factor in that *your* coverage may go down in cost, say if you are changing from family to 2-person or from 2-person to individual. Perhaps you could help with the COBRA through those savings.

Also, companies are only allowed to charge a 3% administrative premium over the actual cost of the health care coverage to COBRA participants, so ask your HR department for the actual cost of individual coverage and how much (if any) your costs will go down when she gets off your policy.

WRT individual coverage, sue36 is exactly correct, the point is to make the deductible as high as possible and pay for the small things out of pocket. Since this is a temporary situation, this may be a cheaper option, however, if your DD has a chronic or pre-existing condition or has high script costs per month, the CORBA policy might be a better deal.

Good luck-

sandyponder


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

Here in NJ, they just passed a law that health insurance providers must now offer continued coverage to dependants under the age of 30. My son, who just gradutated college in May (hooray!!) is covered by my usual insurance, and it does cost more, but it isn't as much as COBRA would be. (he's paying about $225.00/month, $30.00 co-pay yada yada). It is billed seperately from my paycheck deductions. I don't know what other states have instituted this, but here's a link to the NJ web site:

http://www.state.nj.us/dobi/dependentsunder30.htm

He doesn't have to live at my address, just within the state of NJ, can not be married or have any children to be elegible for this. It's hard for recent grads to get full-time jobs and most health insurers will drop them right after graduation. Hopefully more states (or our federal government) will take this into consideration.


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

We got the paperwork today. Over $600 was optimistic - the exact cost is $890.00 per month! The company has a very generous insurance program (We pay nothing) and they are self-insured. I'm grateful for the fantastic coverage so I don't want to rock the boat by asking for an extention. We checked into gradmed which mentions DD's school. I will check with the alumni association. The NJ law is interesting but it only covers the under 30's if they are full time students. DD wd be covered under our policy if she continues to go to school full time. I will look for the WSJ article. Thanks for all the great suggestions!


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

No, in NJ, they do not have to be a full-time student for the extended coverage. It's for kids under 30 who have graduated or for whatever reasson are no longer in school. I'm not sure how many states have this law now.


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

Kitchenwitch -

That's quite a deal! My husband's employer has a facility in NJ. I'm wondering if I talked to the right people...

I found that article in the WSJ. http://www.experthealthquote.com/news/articles/Grads, You Need Coverage _05_08_2006.pdf

Thanks for all the help.


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

Is she healthy? What about an individual plan at Kaiser, or some other local HMO. Really, at that age you need coverage for some kind of catastrophe, like an accident or serious illness. She probably only goes to the dr. once a year for a gyn check up, right? I hardly ever went to the dr. at that age. That said, it's dangerous not to have insurance, but I would bet you can find a much better deal somewhere else. I'd also go for a high deductible, much better in this situation, with higher out of pocket expenses for the few times a year she might go to the dr. but lower premium costs. If/when she gets a job, she'll have her own coverage.

Some individual plans to check into are PCHS (Private Healthcare Systems), and Kaiser.


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

Please note: the following is based on my non-professional understanding of COBRA. Please discuss with your insurance agent! Now that the caveat is complete:

For our 3 college graduates, we have taken advantage of the 60 day COBRA election period. You have 60 days after the "qualifying event" (graduation in this case) to decide whether you want to elect for COBRA. Anytime within that 60 days, you can elect for COBRA coverage and it will be applied retroactively. For example, if your daughter doesnt need medical insurance at all in the sixty days after graduation, she doesnt have to elect for COBRA. If she does need medical care -even in an emergency - as long as she elects coverage in that 60 day window she will get coverage retroactively. Payments are also retroactive though, so if she elects coverage on day 60, she will still owe payments for days 1 - 59 no matter whether she needed care during that time. The trick is for her to find a job in the first 60 days that has health benefits! If she is at day 55 with no prospects in sight, then you sign her up for COBRA and pay for the past 2 months. If she does get a job in the 60 days, youve skated through the 2 months without risk and you've saved a bundle of $. It's important for you to understand that during the 60 days you don't waive your right to coverage, you just don't elect coverage. If you actually waive the right to elect continuation coverage during the 60-day period, you can change your mind and the waiver can be revoked at any time up to the end of the 60-day period. The employer is not required, however, to provide retroactive coverage in this situation.
Hope this makes sense...


 o
RE: DD graduating! What about insurance???

We have been on COBRA several times...the thing to understand is yes, it is retroactive, HOWEVER, if she should need health insurance during that time, it is useless to go to a dr. or worse, be in an accident or incur some urgent, severe medical costs and say to the admissions department, that you will need to apply for COBRA. They will treat you like you are uninsured (even though you are COBRA eligible), and you will be treated as a self-pay patient and charged the full freight cost of your medical care instead of a reduced, discounted amount health insurers pay. Have you ever received a bill from a medical lab and it says that the price of a test is $100, but for your insurance company the discounted price is $12.00 and your co-pay is $3.50? I'm making those numbers up, but it's kind of like that - you really would be shocked at the amount charged to uninsured people versus those with insurance. With COBRA, if you do not present a valid medical card, you will be charged and treated like you have no insurance. Once you apply, pay your retroactive premiums, then you will need to go back and sort through the bills -- GOOD LUCK! Most doctors, if you can't provide proof of insurance at the time of service, will make you pay up front, the full fee. I doubt you would be able to get them to reimburse you what you overpaid several months down the road. Also, it can take up to 6 weeks to apply for COBRA and then get your medical cards.

My neighbor is a lawyer and worked on the origianl COBRA regulations. I had a discussion with her one day about these kinds of points and she was amazed, they had not considered how people are actually charged for and pay for medical services under the "limbo period." I've been through this, and it was a PIA big time. The concept of retroactive coverage, imho, is not a good one. Try to find some kind of continuous coverage for her.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Kitchens Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here