Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
supplemental coal furnace?

Posted by maremma (My Page) on
Thu, Aug 9, 12 at 19:12

Considering installing a coal/wood furnace in basement to supplement my 2800 sq.ft. house's baseboard hot water, oil-fired system. (natural gas not available).

At approx. $200 per ton delivered, I feel that anthracite coal would provide the most economical, efficient heat vs wood. In my experience, heating with coal requires less work than wood. Plus, I could tie the furnace directly into the hot water baseboard system.

Any input would be appreciated.

(BTW, at 68 years of age, I can't believe that outrageous oil prices are actually forcing me to revert to the coal-stoking days of my youth!)


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

Hi Marem, I see we are both the same age. I do question a couple of things. I have had a wood stove not coal but know of someone who does have one, the care for the coal in my opinion is more for the coal then the wood. Plus in either case you need to deal with weight of the coal bags or the split wood and I know that coal can get a little messy. I hear what your saying about oil prices etc .. I have started to call around and ask for COD pricing on oil and only get 150 gals delivered at a time to cushion the cost.. I have been able to save a bit doing it this way ... wishing you luck in whatever you decide.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

bigal, Thanks for the input. I've tried getting discounted oil, but the savings are negligible. I'm in the country, so the only gas available is propane.

This coal-fired furnace system under consideration has a mechanism which automatically switches to the oil furnace should it go out. I could build a coal bin in the basement, next to the coal furnace, and have the loose coal dumped via a shute into the bin. No bags or wood hauling to contend with. Of course, there's the ash cans.....

I can still recall those wintry morning days as a kid, shoveling coal into the furnace, adjusting the damper, and waiting to see the glow return. The hiss of the steam pipes revving up was a comforting sound. Only people of our generation know what I'm talking about.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

I'm a little too young to have encountered coal directly, but not far off it.

I'd love to chastise you for considering such a dirty fuel, but I suspect the reality is that coal will make a big comeback as oil gets more difficult and expensive to obtain, and I can't blame you for seeking alternatives.

Hopefully these new-generation things burn a little more cleanly.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

alan_s, Who knows if you can believe the coal industry's hype? Supposedly, anthracite coal coupled with the right stove emits less pollutants than wood or pellets. I wonder....

All I know is that we're afraid to raise the thermostat beyond 62-65 degrees with oil. This is no quality of life at our age, but we have so few options. Any suggestions?


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

Coal won't be making a comeback, its production and use are dangerous and environmentally damaging.

OP, you're one person with economic constraints, do what you have to do to be comfortable and happy. I think everyone will understand.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

maremma,

Where are you located?

I'm older than you, have a 2 year old Carrier Heat Pump with oil backup.

I live in Maryland.

Mild winters, but I've used less than 70 Gallons of oil in a year and a half. AND my electric bill is still less than it was the years before due in part to a Hybrid Electric Hot Water Heater.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

I can only suggest you look at better insulation, windows, weatherstripping etc if you haven't already, instead of/in conjunction with your supplemental heating.

Another consideration might be a heat pump - if you have air conditioning already, or even if you don't, it may be an option for you - as well as cooling your house, it's basically an airconditioner that can work in reverse - scavenge what heat it can find outside and bring it inside. It does so much more efficiently than just electric heating - you actually get more heat than you would if you were using the same amount of energy in an electric heater.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

Snidely, I think the US is just a few years and/or a government change from a paradigm shift in energy policy.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

Any nearby neighbors are NOT going to like your coal fire.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

Thanks for all the input and understanding.

In nw NJ, a heat pump may not be practical. Also, there is no duct system in my house. Trying to retrofit would be awkward and expensive. Is there something I'm missing?



 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

Ok Alan, I'll bite. A shift to what?


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

Brickeyee,

Should I go the coal route, my neighbors would never know since burning anthracite coal produces hardly any smoke. Besides, living rural has its perks: my closest neighbor is 1/4 mile away.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

"burning anthracite coal produces hardly any smoke"

It still produces a very characteristic smell.


 o
RE: supplemental coal furnace?

brickeyee,

Why do I feel compelled to answer your armchair analysis of coal-burning?

Having extensive experience in the art of burning anthracite coal, I can verify that the smell of burning coal is no more offensive than the smell of burning wood. In fact, it is perhaps LESS noticeable.

Please research your facts before pontificating.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here