Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Posted by Jonesy44 (My Page) on
Wed, Aug 13, 14 at 12:12

Could really use some input. I have a 2800 sq foot, 2 storey house with unfinished basement in Eastern Ontario Canada. There is no natural gas available and I'm currently using forced air electric on a 20 yr old furnace that needs replacing.

Been looking at ASHP that will work for our climate/house size and been leaning towards the Carrier greenspeed. We have central air but don't normally turn on our a/c.

Had 1 quote for a greenspeed 4 ton HP with heat coil and a 25W heater, waiting on a couple more quotes. Can anyone point me to data that specifically says how low outside temp can be when the greenspeed heat pump still provides 100% heat (on average)? Getting different answers from each salesman.

Nor can I find anything that specifically says what the electricity draw is for different greenspeed HP performance levels. Our electricity costs here are insanely high but don't want to go the propane or oil route. Delivery of propane/oil was a big issue last winter. I'm trying to find a way to save some dollars and hoping that this big investment could potentially pay for itself in 4 or 5 years?

Any advice or input would be greatly appreciated.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

There has been a great deal of threads and discussion on the GreenSpeed systems recently. I suggest you use the search function at the bottom of the main page and start reading these.

Also learn to use the AHRI HP Directory website.

IMO

This post was edited by tigerdunes on Wed, Aug 13, 14 at 12:23


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Thanks Tigerdunes. Didn't know about the AHRI website but have since checked it out. I did have all of the SEER/EER/HSPF data. Have already looked at the threads posted on greenspeed but still can't get the two answers I'm hoping to learn.

1. Min outdoor average temp that greenspeed HP will still heat house at 100% without aux heater kicking in. (I did read the comments) Salemen are telling me it will heat house at really low outdoor temps closer to 1F but I read in the forums that I'm looking at 15F?

2. Electricity draw. I'm trying to figure out how to determine cost/benefit ratio of installing this HP and don't have any data to use for calculations.

Any help would be appreciated.


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

You should contact a dealer, request a load calculation, and ask for temp balance point for your home based on the size system the load calc indicates.

AHRI HP directory will give you the BTUs produced at 17 degrees.

Again dealer will need to provide the data on electricity draw for the condenser and air handler before the need for auxiliary heat strip demand to keep up.

IMO


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Ah, was thinking that I should be able to find those figures myself.

Thank you Tigerdunes, I will ask the dealer for that info and see what they come up with.


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Your question is difficult to answer. It depends about the heating load of your house and what your thermostat temperature setting.

Take a look at the product data sheet for the 4 ton size. The maximum heat output is flat at 48K BTUs until 18 degrees F. Then it starts to fall off. The balance point is probably between 8 and 18 degrees. It will be different during the day when the sun is out then it is in the middle of the night.

Post your electric rate and a calculation can be done on the operating cost of the HP versus an electric furnace.

Here is a link that might be useful: Greenspeed product data sheet


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Mike,
My heating load was estimated by the salesman to be at 67,000 BTUH and cooling load to be at 29,500 BTUH.

Electric rate varies depending on the time of day.

On-peak daytime 6hrs 13.5 cents KWh
Mid-Peak daytime 6hrs 11.2 cents KWh
Off-Peak overnight 12 hrs 7.5 cents KWh

We normally keep our indoor temp lower to save costs around the 66 to 68F level because electric costs are so high here.
(Our utility provider also charges us another $120 per month for a delivery charge on top of the cost KWh but I don't need that value added into the calculation)


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

The heating and cooling loads seem a little lopsided. Did this salesman into all your house data into Manual J calculation software or was this a gross estimate based on area? Do you know what indoor and outdoor temperatures were used?

Your electric rates are low compared what I pay in NJ. The $120 delivery charge is a little ridiculous.


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Salesman used an EMS Heat Loss/Gain Calculation form to provide the data to me.

Mike, you just clued me into something. I've just emailed the salesman to look into the winter outdoor temp he put into the heating load calculations. I think he may have made a mistake (too low temp outside) so I'm going to check that out and get back to you as soon as I have his response.


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Just received a response from the salesman re outdoor winter temp.

He used Manual J calculation data and he says he used the temps recommended by HRAI because even if it doesn't get as cold that often, I still need to have the heating ability when it does.

He specified "Indoor winter temp 70F" "Outdoor winter temp -13F" (our actual avg winter outdoor temp is usually around 4F but it can go down to the -13F and even -20F a few times a winter in a very cold spell)

For summer - indoor temp was 76 and outdoor temp was 86.


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Here are the design temperatures for the US and Canada. I am not good with Canada geography so look at page 24 and find the closest city to your location. The temperatures are supposed the be the average low, not the all time records.

I can see why your heating load is much greater than your cooling load. It gets a little nippy where you live.

The typical indoor design temperatures are 72 for winter and 75 for summer. You have to decide whether 70 and 76 are good for you. It is not going to make much difference for your cooling load, but I suspect it will have an impact on the heating load calculation.

Here is a link that might be useful: Outdoor Design Conditions


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

That was a great link. The outdoor winter temp for my area was listed as -8F. With respect to the indoor winter temp 70F is very adequate. We rarely heat above 68 anyway.

The -8F figure is not as low as the salesman put in at -13F for outdoor winter temp. I don't know if that difference will change my heating load though.

I can live with the summer temps he put in. The cooling load isn't an issue for me since the heating load is so much bigger.


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Careful careful Jonesy - you’re dealing with contractors that are NOT at the top of they’re game!

All their load calculations are being done to a standard - the American standard, which is the WRONG standard for Canada where you live.

The correct and latest version of the standard for Canada is the ‘CSA F280-12’. However any CSA F280, such as the ‘CSA F280-M90’ might suffice.

If you’re receiving government grants or rebates, provincial or federal, dependent on ‘proper’ load calculations, your application ‘might’ be ‘Denied’, depending on who does the review, if the methodology you mentioned is used, as it does NOT conform to Canadian standards.

Just some friendly advice…

Good luck with finding someone that actually does it right - most people are CLUELESS and full of excuses!

Caveat Emptor!

IMPO

SR


 o
RE: Carrier Greenspeed Heat Pump Purchase Questionss

Thank you for those insights SR. I didn't realize that the standard was that different for Canada. Out of 5 guys, so far the last salesman was the only one to even give me a heating/cooling load estimate. You are absolutely correct, the other 4 were clueless and so I am having another HVAC company come tomorrow for another quote.

Currently, there aren't any rebates or grants in Ontario for an ASHP unfortunately but it is still necessary that I know which size system to purchase for my home.

It looks like if I want an accurate heating load calculation, I'll have to take matters into my own hands. So if anyone has any ideas where I can get heat load calculating software for Canada or know someone who can do that online (trying to keep costs reasonable) I would be highly appreciative.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here