Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

Posted by London56 (My Page) on
Wed, Jun 8, 11 at 23:29

After months of research and hordes of scammy salespeople, I think I've chosen the right contractor and the right unit. According to my printed load calc (thank you, Garden Websters!) I read: apprx 1600 sq ft.with total gain/loss 39,305 = 5 ton unit. Replacing broken 4 ton 15yr old Carrier 3-Phase on the westside of house (on ground, in Phoenix)with Carrier 48ESA600905A,also 3-Phase 13 SEER/11 EER, placed on roof; 2 new 30x14 return air grills in main living areas (old system is 1 small return in hallway); new gas flex and some new duct work/connections in attic. $6505. I've lived in house for 10 years and have never had a comfortable summer. Do y'all think I'm making an OK - or maybe even great choice? Hoping to install day after tomorrow, but would like a blessing! Shout out to Randy, who pointed me to GardenWeb, and all the generous spirits here!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

Tigerdunes,

I think you posted the wrong link. Nice shirt :).

London,
I know it gets hot in Phoenix, but I would with a 5-ton unit you have a potential of a meat locker! Most homes don't have a duct large enough to support a 5-ton unit. You may be disappointed.

Why does the unit need to move to the roof? Is there an advantage to do this?


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

london,
if you are saying that a load calculation shows 39,305 BTU heat gain, then a 5 ton package system is grossly oversized.

12 KBTUs equal 1 ton of cooling or heating.

I agree about the additional return. So how much return will you have?

The ES mdl is Carrier's low end gaspak package system. I would at least move up to Carrier's Performance series.

I would carefully consider sizing before contracting for a 5 ton system.

IMO


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

I agree that something isn't right
5 tons for 1600sq ft?

you would benefit from installing a smaller unit
and improving the homes thermal and air barriers.
an independent energy audit will point out the deficiencies
of your building envelope.

best of luck.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

Sheesh - I've interviewed apprx 7 companies over several months; 1/2 said 5T, about 1/2 said stick w/4T, and 1 memorable guy said a 6T commercial unit was in order.
Would it help to know that the house is 50+ old, brick, not very well insulated attic space, single pane windows with totals from the load calc. of N-1360, S-3685, E/W-15360? The guy was going to order the unit today for install tomorrow (we're dyin') - I will contact him with your concerns, and see what kind of answer I get, meanwhile, I value your opinions - thanks so much for your time!


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

I'm wondering if since it is a dry area, it needs to be 5 tons to get an adequate sensible load.

London - of course lowering the heat gain would payback and allow a smaller unit. The attic space is easy to add insulation too. Solar screens, window overhangs all can dramatically lower the gain. I think you are getting incredulous replies here because people can shoot for 1 ton for 1000 sq ft and you are talking about over 3 times that capacity/energy use. 40kbtus is the gain - doesn't really matter the directional breakdown. Your real issue sounds like you have a lot of E/W windows with minimal overhang which makes you wonder what the builder was thinking 50 years ago.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

The builder was probably thinking evaporative cooling. Cooling with swamp coolers is relatively inexpensive. The cost of water has gone up and the quality has gone down, but it is probably still a relatively cheap way to cool.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

The builder was probably thinking evaporative cooling. Cooling with swamp coolers is relatively inexpensive. The cost of water has gone up and the quality has gone down, but it is probably still a relatively cheap way to cool.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

I would step up to a 15SEER unit. The payback of increased efficiency (lower bills) should pay for itself in a few short years since you will be using it a lot in Phoenix.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

What I don't understand, if the heat gain calculation was 39,305 BTU, then why is the contractor going to install a 60,000 BTU unit? Does he think 48,000 BTU (4 ton) is cutting it too close?

Why bother doing a load calcualtion if you are going to ignore the results? Has the contractor explained the reasoning behind his decision? I know ratings have to be derated for altitude, but I didn't think this was the case for Phoenix.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

I think I'd hang a bit longer and get it right OP
otherwise you'll be living with a system that is
really oversized.

best of luck.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

Am I right that if he has 39k of sensible load, then a 4 ton would not cut it?

The way I understand it, is that units can handle about 75% of their load as sensible. In dry areas, nearly all of the load is sensible so you often have to go with bigger units.


 o
RE: Right choice of AC unit/type/ton?

OP does not really make a distinction about the load calc other than to say it is total heat gain. for the Phoenix area/climate, I would think the latent load(humidity) would be low compared to the Deep South/Southeast/Coastal.

IMO


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here