|I am looking for advice on replacing the original heat pump and air handler installed in a 25 year old townhouse in Maryland. It is an 1800 sq foot, 3-level end-unit townhouse with a walk out basement. The original Trane is a 2-ton heat pump paired with a 2.5 ton air handler. So far, I have talked to 3 different HVAC contractors. Two contractors recommended 2.5 ton replacements (Heat pump and air handlers) and the other recommended 2 ton replacements. Below are the quotes that I am currently considering.
Quote #1 (1st contractor) $6500
Quote #2 (2nd contractor)$6498
Quote #3 (2nd contractor)$6198
Quote #4 (2nd contractor)$6998 (I'm not sure I want to spend this much)
The second contractor said Carrier and Bryant were the same company and the equipment was interchangable. If the Bryant was out of stock, he would substitute Carrier.
The 3rd contractor was much higher priced; so, I didn't post any of his quotes.
Should I go with 2 ton or 2.5 ton units? What should be the cost difference between a 2 ton and 2.5 ton quote. What is the reputation of the equipment in the quotes?
|Are you in Montgomery County? I'm not sure if you were looking to get another quote, but I can certainly recommend a couple companies if you are (I'm not in the business myself). |
First question is how well did the 2 ton heat and cool the place. Oversizing is not good for the equipment or efficiency, but 1/2 ton should not make a huge difference either way. If the 2 ton always kept the home comfortable, I would not change size. Though 2.5 tons sounds more proper for 1800 sqft., many factors determine sizing (windows, insulation, home orientation, etc.). So, really no way to tell you what size unit to get. It's determined by a heat load/heat loss calculation on your home.
All equipment you've been quoted is good and will qualify for the $1500 tax credit.
|Thanks for your response. |
I'm in Prince Georges County near Greenbelt.
The upper story bedrooms on the side of the townhouse that received the afternoon sun, were warmer in the summer with the 2 ton. I don't really use those rooms alot. I'm not sure I would blame the heat pump because I never tried to reduce air flow to the cooler rooms in order to balance the temperatures better.
|Next time your a/c is on, try adjusting your dampers to see if you can better balance your temperatures. |
If that does the job, I would stay away from an 'upsized' air handler, as it will reduce your latent (humidity removal) capacity.
What temperature is your stat set at? Is it colder than you would like in order to feel comfortable? That would be another reason not to upsize.
I spent about 10 months living in AA county (stationed at Ft. Meade), but don't remember what it was like, weather-wise.
Be sure to get a heat calc.
|I'm wondering if the original system had the upsized air handler in order to get more airflow for the 3-story townhome. |
The warmer rooms isn't really an issue with the unit sizing, but rather inadequate airflow to those locations. Your installer may be able to install some in-duct dampers to help balance the temperatures.
It's hard to compare quotes with different sizes. I'd see if I could get all the dealers to agree on the same size. Perhaps some were not aware that the outdoor unit, despite the indoor unit, was a 2 ton.
|All 3 contractors I talked to said that I had a 2-ton heat pump paired with a 2.5 ton air handler. Two of the contractors recommended 2.5 ton heat pumps and air handlers. One recommended 2 ton heat pumps and air handlers. None of them did a survey. I know of one neighbor who went with a 2.5 ton replacement. I don't know if he had any issues nor do I know what most neighbors have used for replacements. One contractor said he would go with the 2.5 ton because I have an end unit. |
I have a programmable thermostat. I usually keep it set around 70 degrees (both A/C and heat) when I'm home. I believe the program drops to 62 degrees for heat and raises to 78 for air conditioning from 8 AM to 5 PM during the weekdays.
There are dampers in the basement that would allow me to reduce air flow to the lower levels. I haven't worked with balancing the air flow upstairs as I usually don't use those rooms. My heat pump stopped working; so, I cannot experiment with it now.
We have humid summers where I live in Maryland.
I'm leaning toward the 2.5 ton since 2 of the 3 contractors recommended it, my original air handler is 2.5 ton, and I have an end unit townhouse.
|Hey Zucchini, if you don't mind can you shoot me a message at firstname.lastname@example.org or post the firms you are working with for your quotes. I also have a 3 story townhome in Montgomery County (Rockville) and have been obtaining quotes. My quotes seem to be consistently higher than yours and I'm wondering if it is just an equipment difference or the difference of different HVAC firms. Thanks!|
Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum
Information about Posting
- You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
- Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
- After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
- Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
- We have a strict no-advertising policy!
- If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
- If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.
Learn more about in-text links on this page here