You might want to give your location and realize that someone is going to suggest something else.

I personally can't see why you would need 3 stages. Option 1 will save a few dollars over the years but perhaps not enough to justify the price. It would depend where you live and how much electricity costs in the future. I doubt a 3rd stage actually saves any gas.

GeoMason

It would be helpful to know your location.

Generally speaking, the more stages equal improved comfort and operational savings. It should be noted on furnaces that the manufacturers are moving toward full modulating mdls vs staged models for the high end. I do think the full modulating mdls are desirable for areas/climate with harsh winters. Carrier was supposed to introduce their full modulating mdl this summer and Trane/AmStd already have their full modulating model with the XC95m.

What size is your home?

The Evolution/Infinity systems with the Evolution thermostat are probably the best integrated system in the residential marketplace.

You can get an Evolution system with a 4 ton rated blower in an 80K size. not true with Trane/AmStd as you have to move up to a 100K mdl in the XV95 model. My point here is sizing can matter especially with operational costs. If you decide on the Trane, you want the correct thermostat specified.

I am a numbers person. If you post the evap coil mdl for each quoted system, I will try to give you the AHRI match with the performance/eff numbers for the AC.

IMO

what died on system? heating is off this time of year. is it a control portion that died. fan blower? a/c compressor? coil leak?

I live in SE PA outside of Philly. The house is approximately 3,400 sq feet. I get very little air circulation in the house with open windows and no trees for shade. So the house bakes in the summer. The system I am replacing is the original system, and is 100k BTU's. The compressor seized up. I was told by 2 different HVAC's guys if I replace the compressor I need to replace the AC unit, and need to match the existing furnace, so I am buying old inefficient technology. They both recommended to buy new and get the 10 year warranty. I will also get a $600 PECO rebate and (I think) $500 tax credit.

The Bryant dealer suggested he has some room in his quote, I am thinking he might come down a little. I plan on living in the house for a long time. I am thinking if can come down, I might go with him.

I am not sure what you are talking about with the evap coil mdl number. Should that be on the quote? Enclosed are the model numbers - Furnace M#355CAV060100, Air Conditioning M# 187BNA048

The installer is raving about how well integrated the Byrant system is, and with the control thermostat I can monitor the complete system. Is it worth it for a guy who sets the temp and never touches it? My wife and kids are in and out all day long.

I also forgot to mention the price may be a little higher than normal, they are doing some duct work and moving the outside pad a little further away.

I appreciate the help and advice.

GM

GM

Current furnace is 100 KBTU at what efficiency?

Any problems heating home?

Any hot/cold spots in home?

Post back.

IMO

Efficiency was 95%. I was happy with the old system. We noticed a small difference between upstairs and downstairs. One bedroom on the far end of the house does not quite cool or heat as well, but other bedrooms were fine.

thanks for your opinions.