Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Posted by baymee (My Page) on
Fri, Mar 23, 07 at 5:39

I have decided to install a stainless flue liner in my old chimney, but have to remove the old clay liner first. I've seen a product which looks like a 4" square piece of steel, which works with a drill.

Has anybody used one of these and what was your experience?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Is the removal required because of space requirements for the new liner? I can think of no other reason to remove the clay liner.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Yes. I want to put in a minimum 6 1/2 X 6 1/2 square liner with 1" of insulation around it. The current clay liner is 6 1/2 X 6 1/2".

I hoping that somebody has done this removal.


 o
RE:: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

I meant to give the clay liner measurements as 6 1/2 X 6 1/2 inside opening; probably 8 x 8 outside measurement.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

The only time I ever removed a clay liner I did so with an iron digging bar. It was already pretty well shattered from a chimney fire, I was just finishing it off.

Is it a self-supporting liner, or is it grouted to the sides of the chimney, as well?

If self-supporting, a hammer and a digging bar will do a lot of the work for you.

If it's grouted in place... good luck.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Dynamite.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

It's self supporting, but I don't remember how much space there was around the tile, which wasn't grouted in place.

I see number1 has come out of the cold.

The tool is spun by a drill. It is a square 1/2" thick piece of hardened steel, 4 x 4" and it connects to lengths of steel rod. The company claims they work great, but I'd rather get an unbiased opinion.

I asked a chimney sweep today for his price to break out the tile and he quoted a price of $800 for the 20' chimney. The tools will cost me about $150.

The snow is melted off the roof, so I'll take a look at the chimney and order my tools.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Possibly an electric chipping hammer, if you have enough room to work with it.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Risky. Vibration will wreck mortar joints.
Don't mess with the chimney. Go out the wall.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

I would install a 6 inch square or round stainless liner inside the existing clay liner - Hammering the clay out is really going to be detrimental to the health of your chimney, I fear

Don


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

The breech of the stove is 8". If I put 1/2" insulation wrap around a 5 1/2 X 5 1/2" liner (equivelent to about 6" round), it will fit inside the existing tile.

It's a 60K BTUH unit and the chimney draft is excellent, but I'm wondering about the 2" drop in size from a breech of 8" to a flue of 6" ???

In oil fired equipment, a 6" flue is acceptable to 120K and even higher; twice the wood boiler capacity.


 o
RE:: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

I just realized I was wrong about the breech. It's 7" and if I reduced to the equivelent of 6" with the 1/2 Super Wrap for UL standard, I'd be OK. I think most stoves today are using a 6" flue.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

How straight is your chimney? How do you plan on getting the liner in?


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

It's very straight. Put in from the top, riveting each section as I go.

I took a drive to a stove store and all the current stoves in my BTU range use a 6" flue, so I guess I'll leave the liner in, unless I find out something different until Spring.

I still need the boiler for heat for another 6 - 8 weeks anyway.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

ahh, most old chinmeys I have encountered are less than perfectly plumb, the chimney in my current house makes quite a turn in the attic in order to exit at the peak of the roof. I think installing a liner would be very difficult.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

You would use the flexible liner, which is very easy to get down the chimney.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Baymee:

If you go with a smaller stainless liner inside your existing clay flue, you could always pour sand into the voids between the liner and flue.

With sand instead of cement, you won't have any problem removing the liner for future replacement if you should ever have to do so in the future.

The thermal mass of the sand will also moderate expansion and contraction of the liner, reduce condensation tendencies in the stainless, and help retain combustion products within the flue should the stainless develop any cracks or pinholes.

I agree with the others that trying to break out the flue with a vibration tool from the top would compromise the integrity of mortar joints in the block supporting the flue. Up here in Wisconsin, the guys I know that do flue replacement do it by cutting into the chimney block at all levels, replacing the flue and then putting new block into the cut out section from the base up.

Good luck!

Fairyprincess


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

I've been doing alot of research on this lately. The sand idea is a good idea.

The most modern stainless liners use a dense 1/2" wrap around them, made of mineral wool. This satisfies UL standards, even without sand or mortar.

I talked with our lab engineer this morning and he doesn't see any problem with keeping the existing clay flue and using the equivelent of a 6" flue in the chimney, even though the flue outlet on the boiler is 7".

The reasons being that a 6" flue can handle up to 180K BTUH in heat and my boiler is only 60K BTUH max and it's an interior chimney in good condition.

My real concern from the beginning was downsizing from a 7" flue outlet to a 6" stainless, insulated chimney flue. Almost every wood stove today is using a 6" flue. We also have large boilers out in the field that have downsized from the recommended 6" flue (180K BTUH) to a 5" insulated flue with no problems at all.

I determined yesterday that there is a 1/2" of air space all around my clay liner and it's not the type of chimney where you could cut out block and replace it.

I'm not ordering any materials yet and I'll keep my ears open for opinions for a few weeks.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

baymee, I can't offer much advice here as far as if that tool will work for you but I think you're worried about creosote build up in your block chimney and want to go with SS instead. What temp do you run your stove at?


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

Stack temp varies. This morning it was up to 800 while the fire was stoking and then dropped off to 250. The temp varies alot. My buddy has been using his identical boiler since the '80s and he told me last night that I should open the damper in this warmer weather and let more heat go directly up the chimney. I haven't had time to experiment with that idea yet.

All I know is that I've burned for 30 years in one chimney and also for 20 of the 30 years in the other chimney and never had creosote, and never cleaned them.

But, since this boiler is so versitile, I want to do the right setup.


 o
RE: Opinion needed on a tool to remove clay flue liner

We burn wood in a woodstove which is obviously different then a boiler but either way if you let those flue temps get up there like that several times a day you really shouldn't have much of a creosote problem. I run our stove at close to a thousand for about 10 minutes twice a day and our chimney is pretty much all outside. When we brush it down every fall its pretty clean. The key is to stay on top of it before it has a change to build up and ignite.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here