Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

Posted by trader889 (My Page) on
Sun, Feb 19, 12 at 2:38

I received the following quotes for my 2500 sq foot, 2 floor house. I live in Morris county, NJ and am replacing a Lennox builder's furnace and a/c. Quotes look high, but they are from reputable dealers. What do you think?

Carrier two-stage gas fired furnace model 58MEC100-20
100,000 BTU/H. AFUE 92.5%.
New PVC flue to outside.
One (1) Carrier Infinity Control included.
One (1) Aprilaire Electronic air cleaner model #5000 is included.
A chimney liner will be installed as per code.
We will install owners humidifier on furnace.
All gas piping / electrical included.

Carrier Puron ozone-safe 2-stage high-efficiency condensing unit model 24APA748
Carrier evaporator coil CNPVP4824.
48,000 BTU/H or (4 tons) S.E.E.R. 16.5.
All wiring / refrigerant piping / condensate piping is included.

No Cooling Temperature Guarantee on second floor.

Existing equipment will be removed.

Price: $11,600

Bryant 4 Ton Super N Coil � Model Number � CNPVP06124
Bryant 4 Ton Condensing Unit � Model Number � 127BNA048 � 2 Stage � 17 SEER/13.1 EER
Bryant 100,000 BTU Furnace � Model Number � 353BAV060100 � 2 Stage � 92.5% Efficiency
- Evolution Control Module
� Honeywell Media Air Cleaner
Other-
� Install customers humidifier
� One (1) � 60 Amp disconnect
� One (1) � 4" Chimney liner
� Change condenser breaker

Total Price � $9,300.00

NOTE: These prices don't include any rebates, tax credits, etc..

Is it normal not to guarantee cooling temps on the 2nd floor? I understand during the summer, heat rises and the 2nd floor is furthest away from the furnace.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

Was a proper heat calc done?

I'm in S. Jersey with 23 year old 2500 SF home. Heat loss: around 59,000 BTU; heat gain under 3.5 tons. You probably need more heating and a little less cooling.

Re: 2nd floor: yes, heat does rise, but a well designed duct system (zoning helps)CAN eliminate (if you have) a heat problem.

Is your contractor addressing your duct system?

V


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

well, the 2nd quote isn't as bad as the first. Very nice equipment. Whats the chimney liner for? High efficiency condensing furnaces don't vent thru the chimney. They vent thru the the pvc outside a side wall.


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

The Carrier quote is on the high side for the equipment quoted. You should be able to do better.

I am not sure the Carrier models you provided are a valid match. I tried the find the match on the AHRI directory but could not find it. Ask the contractor to provide the AHRI number.

The Bryant furnace model 353BAV060100 is a 60,000 BTU input. Are you sure the contractor said this is a 100K BTU unit?

It is difficult to achieve even tempatures on both floors on a 2500 square foot house without zoning. Do you currently have temperature variations? Has the contractor made any suggestions to resolve this.

Do you need an electronic air cleaner? A 4 inch media filter is less expensive and will serve you well. I would also get a quote on a 10 year labor warranty from Carrier or Bryant.

New Jersey offers the Cool Advantage rebate. A Manual J calculation must be submitted with the application. Ask the contractors if they will applying for this rebate.


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

Trader

At the very least, I would want a two stg var speed furnace 95%+ efficient.

Nothing less and I suspect an 80 KBTU model would be more than satisfactory.

And for the previous poster Mike, that furnace is a 100 KBTU model with a 5 ton rated blower motor.

IMO


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

Tiger,

You are correct on the Bryant furnace size being 100K BTU input. I assumed the model nomenclature was the same as Carrier's. I stand corrected.

Mike


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

Thanks for all the advice so far. BTW, the house is 28 years old and currently, the coldest (winter) and hottest (summer) rooms are the 2 bedrooms on the 2nd floor where my kids sleep. It so happens, these are also the furthest away from the furnace. Will adjusting the dampers help? The other bedrooms, including the master, are fine.

BTW, here is a 3rd quote, which will include a manual J.

Bryant condenser 127BNA048 2 stage 4 ton
furnace 353BAV060100 2 stage 92% eff.
coil CNPVP06124
thermostat
honey well filtration
4 inch chimney liner
high voltage
gas piping
chimney
low voltage high voltage
install homeowners humidifier

$ 9,200

option:
Evolution system
condenser 187BNA048
furnace 355cav060100 95% 3 stage, variable speed
coil CNPVP6124
thermostat evolution control
installed
$ 11,700

He is pretty close to my original post, option 2 above with his first quote. Is the Evolution system worth and extra $2500? I do plan on staying in this house for a while.


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

I forgot to add, would it make sense to put in some sort of zoning system, like the Arzel to better control the temps in the 2nd floor bedrooms?


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

I am surprised to see a $2500 differece between the Preferred and Evolution quotes. In my experinece the equivalent Carrier Performance and Infinity models are closer in price, but my information could be out of date.

The Evolution set up should qualify for an additional $500 rebate from Bryant. The rebates usually begin in March. The Evolution may also qualify for additional NJ and utility rebates. I would have expected the final rebate prices between these system would differ by $1000 - $1500.

I also don't understand how you can configure a two stage condenser with a furnace which is not variable speed. Make sure you are being quoted valid matches.

It makes sense to investigate the possiblity of zoning the second floor. I have read postive reviews about the Carrier Infinity zoning controllers. I assume Bryant has the equivalent product. Ideally you want to improve the comfort in the house after spending this amount of money.


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

Forum members should know that NJ is one of the most expensive states to live in the US and one of the worst as far as purchasing HVAC. That is why quotes look out of line and they are compared to other geographic areas.

IMO


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

I agree pricing in NJ is higher than the national average. What doesn't make sense is the Evolution system is 27% higher than the Preferred. The labor costs should be about the same. The bulk of the difference is the equipment cost.

There are many HVAC dealers in northern NJ. Talk to additional Bryant or Carrier dealers to determine if the pricing is consistent.


 o
RE: Quote comparison Bryant vs Carrier in NJ

being in north jersey and a bryant dealer,The upgrade to an evolution system is $ 1100.00

I agree the mark up from 9200 to 11,700 is heavy.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Heating & Air Conditioning Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here