Return to the Health Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Knees bad again

Posted by catherinet (My Page) on
Thu, Aug 16, 07 at 21:33

Hi all,
Last July, I had knee surgery on one knee for a torn meniscus (probably from osteoarthritis), and a clean up of the arthritis. I guess because of my fibromyalgia, I had a horrible time with recovery. It took several months of physical therapy to get me going again. Because of the fibromyalgia, my muscles go crazy for no reason at all.
I have been doing great for quite awhile. I wasn't exercising because my legs felt so good. Well a couple weeks ago, my good knee started feeling a little loose, then WHAM......both legs started hurting all the time......24/7. I'm having trouble walking on them and am in pain all the time. I've started back up on the knee-strengthening exercises and am wearing a knee brace. I'm using the exercise bike and ice packs 2 times a day. I'm only taking tylenol, since I can't tolerate NSAIDS. My GI tract also has trouble with glucosamine.
I have a call in to the physical therapist. I don't want to go see the ortho doc because I know he'll say I need knee replacements.....which I refuse to have (at least at this point in my life. I'm 57).
So......I'm going to approach this from a physical therapy/herbal supplement position. But I need to do alot of research on the Internet about my options.
Have any of you approached your knee problems in a more natural way, and if so, what all did you do? Thanks so much.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Knees bad again

Catherine, why do you refuse knee replacement? Do you think the surgery won't go well for you? I don't know if you think 57 is too young or too old! LOL!

Here's another forum below just for people with hip and knee problems. Maybe you can get some information there.

Sounds like you are suffering. I'm so sorry.

Here is a link that might be useful: Hip & Knee Problem Forum


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Have the knee replacement. I don't know anyone who has been sorry. Age isn't much of a factor anymore because they are using titanium and it doesn't wear out. My daughter's dog had his knees replaced last week. It cost 3k.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

My dad had a knee replacement at 80 years old. At 57 you're still a kid! As long as your body can tolerate the surgery itself, go for it. The hardest part is the rehab to which you must commit but it sounds like you already are taking care of your knee as best as you can.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Thanks everyone,
I know this might sound silly to some of you, but when I die, I don't want alot of fake parts. Of course, I don't want to spend the next 20-30 years in pain either......but I'd like to try to help my knees more naturally to start with. Unfortunately, it seems that once you've ruined your padding (meniscuses), you can expect alot of pain.
I guess what's really scaring me is my fibromyalgia. My body has really intense, unexplainable, unreasonable reactions to things, and I would hate to be worse off after a knee replacement.
I made an appointment with my physical therapist for next week and will try to strengthen all the muscles around the knee. If worse comes to worse, and I do need replacements, I'll be ahead of the game afterwards.
I've been having a horrible fibromyalgia flare for about 3 months and I'm afraid my physical and emotional reserves for more problems are at a low point.
Jenn.....how's your dad doing? I've heard good things about knee replacements......but I still hope I won't need one.
I've had leg/foot/knee problems since I was a child. I'm thinking I was born with some defective parts.......and I'm not aging very gracefully either!
Thanks everyone.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

One problem that you might want to talk to your physical therapist about is that sometimes a person with knee problems will hold themselves awkwardly. This messes with the natural posture and then they have back pain too. Ask him/her to make sure that you are still standing and walking correctly.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

My dad is doing great now... it's been several years and his knee is still doing very well.

I understand your hesitation to have surgery, I hope you'll find a remedy that will help you feel much better soon.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Thanks agnes and jenn.
Agnes....one important thing I learned from my physical therapist with surgery last year was how important it is to not limp or hold yourself out of alignment. You're right.....that in itself can cause alot of other problems. I have to really focus on walking correctly....even though I really want to limp!
Thanks again!


 o
RE: Knees bad again

I hope your dog has improved and is walking again without pain.

My big old dog tore her ACL CCL Crucial Ligament torn tendon in her back knee. Too old for surgery.

I also read many many forums of those whose dogs had ACL CCL tendon surgery and it went badly, a nightmare.

Dogs that are under 2 years old, too young as bones and tendons are not fully mature until 2 years old. Dogs under 2 years are suppose to wear a Knee Brace and not consider knee joint tendon surgery until after 2 years old.

I have been reading about Dog Knee Braces. Who has tried a Stifle Brace?
Who did you buy it from and what was your experience?

When to use a Brace and or Surgery articles...

TiggerPoz.com

VeterinaryPracticeNews.com has an article
Questioning Canine Cruciate Surgery

http://www.veterinarypracticenews.com/vet-practice-news-columns/complementary-medicine/questioning-canine-cruciate-surgery.aspx?cm_mmc=10177433

Thanks anyone for sharing your experience with your dog wearing a Dog Stifle Knee Brace.

.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Find a naturalpath doctor and go after the cause instead of working with the symptoms. If you get the knee replaced a few years down the line the other knee is next and then a hip.
Fix the cause and the symptoms will go away.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Looks like you're the unfortunate, one of many out there who inherited some of the not so desirable genes.

Hopefully you get relieve in whatever treatment you do, I'm thinking of building up muscles by swimming, ..I know some people get relive do this, ...exercising your joints while not under pressure/weight.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

I am with d0ug on this one. I go this route for my arthritis. I have had a messed up knee (right side) for a good 20 years of my life (since my late teens). At times it was so inflamed that I had to keep it extended and had next to no range of motion. My worse flare up two years ago is what got me try the natural route. I wasn't ready to move onto the next medication and I knew my body couldn't handle it as I was already rejecting the tried and true ones. I was so amazed by what and elimination diet did for me. I wasn't diagnosed with Fibro. but am pretty sure that I had that too along with three other autoimmune conditions. I am drug free and short of getting some tightness in my joints there is no major inflammation anymore. Look up inflammatory foods and play around. One week of a hardcore elimination diet did more for me than any medication has. I would look up nightshades, gluten, dairy, soy, sugar and the joint pain connection. I wish I would have gone this route as soon as my first autoimmune condition came out. I know it sounds crazy but it has been my life saver. Oh yeah, a food journal has to be your best friend during this time - tracking everything - foods and any symptom experienced. A lot of it can be done on your own if you are willing to research online.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Theophilus Curtis Ratliff a basketball player blow out his knees early in his career and found a Naturopath who helped him regrow his knee and when on to play basketball for more year than most all other players.
You might need surgery but if you have the time go for fixing it instead of cutting because you can not undo surgery. There is a reason for pain and it is not a lack of surgery or pain killers


 o
RE: Knees bad again

I had pain in my left knee, they "cleaned" it up but it didn't help, I came out hurting as much as when I went in...they gave me a shot, it worked great...for 2 weeks, pain returned, couldn't straighten my leg...got a total left knee replacement, a year ago this month...no pain, can straighten my leg...it's still a little numb around the knee but I would do it again..I'm only sorry I didn't get the replacement right away.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

This would worry me, ..a replacement can lead to more problems down the road, ...talked to a fellow who had it done on both knees in just over a year, he said that one has to be careful and you have to totally re-learn how to take care of,...like not kneeling on it or squatting etc. gets swollen allot.

Do it only as a last resort.

Somebody else said after a replacement,..it hurt so bad that he would never do it to the other leg at any cost.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

The problem with surgery is they can't put the real knee back. If you have a problem with one knee than you probably have a problem in most of your joints. This is just the first to fail. Go and find a alternative doctor which treats the body not just one joint. Most people who get a knee replacement soon find themselves getting the other done and then the hips.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Didn't realized but this thread is already 6 years old,..would be nice to know what route Catherine took.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Do not worries nowadays knee surgery or replacement would not painful.


 o
RE: Knees bad again

Watch this before any surgery

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nHDg4Dx0jc


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Health Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here