Sad Grandmother

9 years ago

I am brand new to this site and posting to this forum. I am glad I found it though because I have something that has been troubling me and would like other's opinions.

We are the very happy grandparents of twin 3 year old granddaughters. When they were first born we were so excited since they were our first. (the other grandparents already had 2 older grandchildren) But we soon realized that our DIL's parents were to be the first and foremost in their lives. I must admit that I sort of suspected this from the beginning. They were always called to babysit, the Grandmom was always at the house, etc. When we were around, and I asked to help with them, I was usually told by my DIL "No, that's okay, I can do it" or My Mom is here to help". That statement still continues today and I used to wonder if it was something I had done although we do take the girls on outings now more than before.

I started to hear from Grandmom things like, "I want to be the fun grand mom", "When they are at my house I let them do whatever they want", etc. If it is any meal time, she immediately says: "Let Grandmom help you" and she sits down and feeds them to the point that when she is not around, they ask for someone to "help them" eat. My DIL can't hand them an item without saying: Grandmom bought this for you. If you compliment the girls on an outfit, they tell you that Grandmom bought it which seems to be a lot of their clothing and accessories. (my son & DIL certainly can afford their clothes so that is not the issue). We stopped buying clothes for them early on because we had purchased outfits for a holiday of which they were going to be with us but were asked to return them because Grandmom had already bought them. If the girls are spending time with us, Grandmom calls me on the phone and wants to talk to them or me about what they are doing. When she talks to them, the conversation usually goes: Grandmom misses you soooo much. We recently had them on vacation for a few days and of course we received the phone call and she wanted FaceTime with them. We both live close by so that is not the issue either. She calls and talks to them everyday. Most holidays, birthdays, etc. are spent with my DIL's side of the family and it almost seems like a treat for us to spend time with them.

Well, I don't want to rant but I just feel like the Grandmom constantly is a presence as if she is afraid the girls will get close to us. We don't do that to her and wouldn't. One of the girls is now into throwing tantrums - today she hit me and wouldn't come near me. (her parents did correct her)

I keep my mouth closed, and pray every day that this will all change. Thanks for any thoughts you have.

Featured Answer

PRO

CJH Design

9 years ago

Stop focusing on the other grandparents and focus on the grandchildren.

No matter what or who the other grandmother is, you have to develop your own relationship with the girls. They will love you for you if you are loveable and fun no matter how much they love the other grandmother.

It's not a competition and it's useless to compare. You are making yourself miserable. The other grandmother is not getting in the way of your relationship with your grandchildren.

If she gets 10 hours a week and you get 2 every other week, make those 2 pleasant so everyone has a great time and great memories. Even if the girls enjoy being with the other grandmother, that doesn't mean they can't enjoy the time with you. People, children included, are drawn to what makes them happy and avoid what makes them unhappy. It really REALLY has NOTHING to do with her.

Relationships have nothing to do with who buys children clothing, or spoons cereal in their mouths or what inane things are said on the phone. You are wasting your time criticizing this woman for what she gushes to toddlers on the phone or how she indulges them. Let their parents deal with grandmom, if she needs dealing with, and do your own thing. Eventually she'll stop doing that, and if she doesn't, the girls will eventually find her annoying and tedious. Overbearing, needy people (if indeed she is really as you describe her) always wear out their welcome.

You certainly do not need to talk to grandmom on the phone if you don't enjoy it. I can see it would be annoying that she calls while the girls are with you, but it is only for a bit. There's only so much you can say on a phone to a 3 year old.

Who cares if she is worried the girls will get 'too close' to you. That's her problem not yours. The girls will be close to you, and that's that. Just make sure you aren't doing the same.

Think of her as McDonalds and yourselves as a 5 star restaurant. Maybe you don't go as often, but the experience is better.

It's tempting to think you are entitled to your version of 'fair', as in more or less equal time, or equal babysitting, or equal clothes buying, or whatever. But that's not how life works. And grandmom doesn't love the girls less because she has other grandchildren, and you don't love them more because they are your only grandchildren.

As for the hitting: toddler do that sometimes, if their parents are conscientious, they will teach the children how to do better. It's not the other grandmother's fault, it's just how kids are sometimes. Don't take it personally.

Focus on your own relationship with them and less on grandmom. You'll be happier and there will be less resentment and stress on the relationship with your son, DIL and her family.

The girls won't always be little; as they grown they will develop affection based on personality and experience.

Comments (7)

gmatx zone 6
9 years ago
Nana3540, I'm so sorry you are experiencing this attitude by your DIL and her mother. Wish I could tell you how to change it, but I can't. All I can say is just thoroughly enjoy their presence when they are with you and let them know you love them. As they get older always let them know you are there for them and that they can call or talk to you at any time about any thing.

It's sad when a grandmother wants to be, or thinks they have to be, only a "fun grandma" as if a child will not love them unless they are. It is also very selfish and rude of her to intrude on your time with them, IMO

(((((Hugs)))))

Mary
Nana3540
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks, Mary, that is exactly what I try to do but sometimes it gets frustrating and hurtful.

Hugs back!
Related Discussions
Grandmother Memories
Q
Comments (12)
Well I just don't know if it is my age that makes my memories so different than your "Grands that canning, cooked, etc." or it was their station in life, so I have been reticent to write (it is so different!). My mother's mother came from a lineage that delighted in family ties, and all the aunts, uncles, and cousins all talk amongst themselves saying, "Do you remember living on so-and-so street?", as though they spent all day long every day outside on that street playing together. Sounds great. She came from a huge family and there were always kids to play with, much unlike her husband. He also came from the upper crust of society, attending the local prep school here, and was a football player. An only child, his brother having succumb to disease early on. He loved chemistry class and ultimately became a chemist (I've written about him before when he died, you may remember). They only had two kids and so were able to dote on them pretty well and did so. They'll both tell you that had it good growing up. It would seem they lacked approval on the mom's part, but dad's quiet humor made it bearable. I loved to spend the night at their house and awaken to bacon and oatmeal cooking. Sis's oldest would loved to go into Gran's pantry and get out the bananas and peanut butter, feeling quite grown up as he did. We went to their house after church every Sunday and ate supper. They entertained all of our boyfriends and our friends we hung out with. The food was good and the laughter even better. Most of us remember Grandaddy the most as he had a vocabulary of grunts and would nod his head towards the door when it was time for Gran to quit talking and them to leave. My dad's mother never talked about her childhood. Couldn't tell you a thing about her. She had five children of her own and raised them by herself since her husband died of lung cancer by the time dad was in his midteens. Dad is the third oldest, so I imagine the little ones were really little. And I also think his dying keeps my dad from knowing just how to be a dad to older children, but I digress. She worked every job imaginable to keep them clothed, from school crossing guard, to swim instructor (she couldn't swim????!!!!), hospital dietician, etc. She worked so hard and slept so little, there is a story that ends with an unknown motorcycle in the garage. She would never drive a motorcycle. Never. Picture PeterPan collars trimmed in lace with cardigans. She loved to hold you in her arms and sweetly smile, saying, "just let me look at ya" and then would giggle her infectious giggle (my lil sis has it too) and hug you closer. She liked to have cookouts and picnics so that everyone could come to her house and hangout. Guess she had her big family later in life. But come we did. And had a great time. I guess my grand had time to spare and spent it keeping the family close to their hearts. That's the same as you guys. My son only has my mother and father. He knew Ed's mom pretty well, but wasn't really all that close and never knew Ed, Sr. It's sad for me to think Ed has lost both parents so young, but it's even worse to know my LF will not get to know them or enjoy them like we did.
...See More
My grandmother died ;(
Q
Comments (26)
Hi everyone, Thanks so much for your support, prayers and insipirational words. Kylie, her name was Sonmatie Ramkissoon. Strange name yes, its Indian. Her grandparents were actually from India. I think i got my love of gardening from her, she always loved that. I will miss her. thanks again everyone Siam .
...See More
Now I know what happened to my grandmother
Q
Comments (17)
...my participation here is more theoretical than specific to this situation, only because the topic of family secrets is so interesting to me. So what's to gain from sharing a family secret "like" this one here? Really, it's about the relationshp between father and daughter. A secret puts up walls due to the shame. So being able to say "I know your secret and I still love and accept you" is really really a powerfully healing thing to the person who holds the secret and potentially increases intimacy between two people. Also, the assumption that the secret holder has put it entirely in their past is often false. People hold on to shame for years and years, and often it nags daily, silently, and bleeds into areas that are not easily detected. Another way of seeing this, rather than simply "He's old, why bring it up now" is to say "He hasn't many years now, he deserves peace". OF course, we don't know in THIS situation what is best for him, so we cannot presume to say that he "should" or "shouldn't" be told. The other thing I know about humans is that we gravitate to status quo. It's familiar, it's comfortable, and the devil we know is more attractive than the devil we don't. To be fair, I choose to keep certain secrets too. I have one that I'll go to my deathbed with - however, I HAVE gone to therapy for it, and a bulk of the shame of it has been dealt with. Certainly makes life easier for me. Hopefully this dad has been able to do the same. However, if someone approached me lovingly with the information and asked me about it, I would likely be scared but relieved as well. It's just not my secret to tell, if that makes sense. Maybe dad feels some sense of loyalty to his mom.
...See More
A sad, sad day
Q
Comments (3)
Wow, I'm really sorry that you had to deal with that. It sounds like you definitely need to move on to the "tough love" part of parenting with her. And I totally agree with Dana about what to say to her comment about the jewelry. If she had asked and not stolen it, it would be a completely different story (not that you would have said yes, but it would have shown respect for you.) I also agree with how to handle the younger ones....they do need to understand that this is unacceptable....and that it is about what she did, not what they did! This reinforces why I have taken a hard line with my 20 y/o SD -- who stole from me last summer (over and over!). I will not allow her in my house alone because she has shown that she cannot be trusted. Yours has too and you need to show her that these are the consequences for her behavior (don't know about yours, but my SD never had any consequences for her behavior.....her mother either accepted the obvious lies from her daughter, lied to us about it, or made it excuses for her. Like you, we have another younger child watching all of this and this is an important lesson for them too -- we cannot and will not tolerate disrespect, lying, stealing, etc.....and there will be consequences for breaking the rules (not just house rules, but the rules you need to live by in our society in order to be successful and have some integrity!). Good luck.....! (does she have a key....you may want to change the locks.....)
...See More
sylviatexas1
9 years ago
'The other grandmother is not getting in the way of your relationship with your grandchildren.

If she gets 10 hours a week and you get 2 every other week,'

What?

10 hours a week vs 1 hour a week (or 20 every 2 weeks vs 2 every 2 weeks, you really should compare like to like) doesn't mean that one grandmother has an advantage in the grandchild sweepstakes?

& you claim OP is making *herself* miserable?

As I asked on another thread in which you blasted the OP, what on earth is your agenda against grandparents?

Nana, please don't take BananaBread's comments to heart.

She's posted on several threads, & while she's been supportive & even sensitive to children & grandchildren, every one of her posts responding to grandparents has been scathingly critical.

& this one doesn't even make sense.

I wish I had something helpful to suggest, but "never let the ...buzzards?... see you cry" is the best I can think of right now.

Keep a smile on your face, & *never* challenge your DIL on anything.

unless you see her set the house on fire or hand the baby a bottle of beer!
Nana3540
Original Author
9 years ago
Thanks, Sylvia! I just chuckled when I read the other post because it seemed to me that I was being attacked by someone who doesn't have a clue who I am rather than being offered supportive suggestions. I don't get into chat rooms but this site came up when I was searching for garden tips for my dad and since I don't share any of this problem with those around me I thought I would seek some suggestions from strangers who may have experienced the same situation.

I wasn't criticizing Gmom, just stating facts. As a matter of fact, as adults we are very friendly - even going out to dinner together with our husbands. She is a pleasant woman but when it comes to the grandkids, she is way over the top. My DIL has said that to me without any prompting from me!! I also never said I was "miserable"

I will probably end this post because I spoke to my son today who told me that at the request of HER daughters, Gmom (age 60+) visited a doctor a few months ago and was diagnosed with ADHD and is going to therapy. I feel bad for her but now can understand some of her behavior. I will pray for her and just keep on keeping on.

Thanks for your friendly advice!!
emma
9 years ago
Not every family is the same, I have 3 sisters and we all went to Mom's. Our husbands loved to be with my dad. They played horseshoes, went hunting and fishing together. The guys wanted to be with our family for holidays. We were at Mom's for Sunday dinner every Sunday. My mother worked and we never left the kids with her except in an emergency and I only remember one time that was done. She never asked the kids over, she enjoyed them when we came to dinner and for water melon feeds and bar b cues. She raised us and I am sure she enjoyed her freedom just as I did when mine left home. And no one could love babies and small children more than I do, but that doesn't mean I have don't have a life of my own. The in laws never asked the kids over and we weren't offended. They asked us over as a family because it was about the whole family.

This post was edited by EmmaR on Thu, Jul 17, 14 at 23:20
krissie55
9 years ago
Nana3540:

No one can understand your situation until they walk in your shoes. Yes, I have the exact same experience as you, oldest grandchild is 17.

It does not change, so dig your heels in for the long haul and enjoy your grandchildren even though you know their other grandma is their favorite one.

There will be a day come the grandchildren will realize you are the stable grandparent they can depend on, you are the rock and the fun grandmother will not be mature enough to be the stable rock.

I feel for you, I know firsthand how this makes you feel.

Sad Grandmother

CJH Design

Comments (7)

gmatx zone 6

Nana3540
Original Author

Related Discussions

sylviatexas1

Nana3540
Original Author

emma

krissie55

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Sad Grandmother

CJH Design

Comments (7)

gmatx zone 6

Nana3540Original Author

Related Discussions

sylviatexas1

Nana3540Original Author

emma

krissie55

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Nana3540
Original Author

Nana3540
Original Author