Return to the Garages/Workshops Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Detatched Garage Advice

Posted by jgoodish (My Page) on
Thu, May 22, 08 at 13:42

My home has a bricked exterior and a 2-car integral garage (side-entry), which is beyond filled. I have considered placing a 16x24 shed in the back yard, but I talked with a couple of contractors who suggested that a detached garage at the end of my driveway (next to the house) would add more long-term value to the property. If I go this route, the garage will need to be bricked to match the house.

I've received two bids for a 24x24 (exterior dimension) building with concrete floor, brick exterior, 8 foot side walls, and a 6/12 gable roof (using trusses to eliminate the beam and post), and two 9x7 garage doors to match the ones on the house. Bids are coming in at $55-$60 per square foot, complete, which also includes a 9x24 concrete apron in front of the garage, but no electric (I'd do the electric myself).

Does this type of structure sound reasonable?

Thanks,
JKG


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Detatched Garage Advice

It sounds rather industrial to me. Do you need to garage more automobiles or, like me, more other stuff?
I would reconsider the shed, giving it a concrete floor, loft storage and double doors for large-item access.


 o
RE: Detatched Garage Advice

The thought process was that the detached garage would add more long-term value to the property than a shed in the back yard. While I don't need it for cars, a future buyer might.

The other problem is that my entire lot slopes to one corner, so any concrete slab is going to have to sit on a foundation. The sites on my lot able to accommodate a shed are more sloped than the garage site at the end of my driveway, requiring many courses of block and a lot of fill. To top it off, there is no good access for delivery vehicles to the area behind my house. The bottom line is that a comparable 16x24 shed, without the brick exterior, was almost as much as the detached garage due to the extra materials and labor.

I am still considering building a small retaining wall in the back, filling it in, putting 4" of crushed stone down as a base, and having a shed (with wood floor) built on top. Not nearly as nice--nor versatile--but probably under $10k.


JKG


 o
RE: Detatched Garage Advice

What about taking the money and putting towards rental of a storage facility/unit?

I think you're right that building a garage will add more value (or subtract less--not sure how many people need 4 garage spaces) than would a shed. The sf price seems quite reasonable, although that all depends on your locale.


 o
RE: Detatched Garage Advice

I have considered a rental storage unit, but most of the things that we're storing need to be readily accessible at the house (lawn equipment, etc.)

I don't need 4 garage space either, and have considered turning the second space in the proposed building into a finished workshop or office. That would perhaps be more attractive to a buyer, but also raise the cost of the project somewhat.

I would estimate that roughly 50% of the homes in my neighborhood have a 3 car garage, either integral or attached. There is one home which has a 2 car detached garage behind the house. When we built our house, we opted for the integral garage in part because it presents a "cleaner" image of the house from the road. Obviously, a detached garage at the end of our driveway would negatively impact that image, though it should be no worse than having an attached garage with the doors facing the road.

JKG


 o
RE: Detatched Garage Advice

For what it's worth, we built a detached workshop/garage even though we knew we didn't need the extra garage bay. We even installed an oversized door to insure it would accommodate (someone else's) larger vehicles or boats. It seemed like the prudent thing to do both for resale value and any unforeseen needs (e.g. storage, hobbies, etc) in the future. Instead of parking a car or boat in it, we decided to add HV/AC and stain the concrete floors, and then buy a pool table. Weve always wanted a pool table but never had enough room for one in the house. Properly insulated, garage bays can be very versatile. If building codes allow, someone could even convert it into a guest house down the road. But then the lots are large and outbuildings are pretty common where I live.


 o
RE: Detatched Garage Advice

Those bids sound in the ballpark. I've heard that garages are typically $50/sq ft, and brick will increase that price. Last fall we looked into building a ~30x40 bricked garage with upstairs unfinished storage (could be converted to living space) and got estimates around $75K. That squelched that idea until my DH teaches himself masonry. :-)

Who needs a 4-car garage? We certainly do, since I'm married to a mechanic and wanna-be farmer who owns a tractor and a growing collection of tow-behind implements. Of course, our lot is 7 acres, which almost guarantees that yard care equipment needs go beyond a walk-behind mower.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Garages/Workshops Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here