Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
mrsjoe_gw

Strand Bamboo Brands

mrsjoe
14 years ago

Short story: Can someone please provide me feedback on EcoTimber, Morning Star and Cali Bamboo all in Strand Woven Carbonized? Are there any other brands I should be considering besides these and Teragren?

Long Story: I'm trying to finalize our flooring plans, and currently we are planning to install about 400 sq. ft. of strand bamboo. My husband wants to just go with Lumber Liquidators Morning Star Carbonized because he thinks it will be the easiest because of being able to just go into the store and order it. Plus, he likes the $3.99 / sq.ft. pricing. I'm nervous because of all the negatives that get posted about LL and also because of the formaldehyde smell of the Morning Star that has been mentioned. Also, Consumer Report ranked it well below EcoTimber and Teragren, but didn't really say why.

Anyway, I know Teragren is out because they seem the priciest and were ranked below cheaper products. I was hoping that someone could tell me their opinions on the Morning Star, EcoTimber and a brand called Cali Bamboo someone mentioned on this site. I'm leaning towards the Cali Bamboo because it seems the formaldehyde will not be as potent as the Morning Star, but I have no idea of the quality. The Cali Bamboo is right now $3.92 sq.ft plus shipping, versus the EcoTimber which is at least $6. So I'm also more likely going to be able to talk my husband into the Cali Bamboo.

Thanks

Comments (12)

  • vikki_wa
    14 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Mrs. Joe, any developments on this since your last post? My ex recently installed the Teregren Synergy chestnut and he says he's happy with it. Like you, my budget calls for something cheaper. I have purchased bamboo fencing from Cali Bamboo and was pleased with the company and the product. I am now considering their Fossilized java flooring for my home and I have a sample on the way now.

  • elkberry
    14 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We bought EcoTimber woven bamboo for two bedrooms, and we have yet to install it. I've worked with two different installers, and the verdict is that it's a TOTAL pain in the tush to nail down. It's just too dang dense, but using a staple bigger than 18ga voids the warranty and splits the tongue. We are considering gluing but don't really like that option.
    Does anyone know if solid T&G bamboo can be floated, gluing planks together but not to the floor??
    One plus, the EcoTimber does not seem to have an odor. I had a sample of Morning Star and it definitely had a questionable smell.

  • jeri
    14 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hi Elkberry

    You will have to call or email EcoTimber. Their web site doesnt list floating, but you need to ask to be sure.

    Why donÂt you want to glue? You have professional installers  right? Hopefully they have lots of experience with gluing. If not, you might want to look for someone who has.

  • elkberry
    14 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hi jeri
    We're concerned about the potential "forever" of glue, if we ever want to make a change. Also, the EcoTimber glue is $200/tub which does 200 feet or so. For 3 tubs worth, I guess I could buy a Powernail 50P for $500 and try that. But I've heard so-so results from the gun too.
    Another thing about gluing is that one bedroom is partially over slab. It is plastic lined and has "sleepers" under the plywood subfloor.
    Any thoughts?
    Thanks, elk

  • dakotamagnum
    13 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hi, any updates on the preferred brands? I'm also looking to install but want to stay away from Lumber LIquidators. Am leaning towards click and lock, however am somewhat open. Also have been looking at Teragren but is more money than I like so also looking at Cali and Mohawk. Anyone have other brands or ideas? Thanks!

  • Erinpdx
    13 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    How about Simple Floors? I looked at their products in person and they look great.

  • beaniebakes
    13 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Erinpdx... since you just registered could it possibly be that you are affiliated with Simple Floors?

  • avivacarol
    13 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Although I am not currently looking at strand Bamboo, I did research it and found a low voc Bamboo engineered that you float. One of those clicking types. I don't remember the brand, but it may have been "Style" or something that sounded a bit commercial. The website looked a little hokey, but I did look at a sample in a local floor store and that it was good. It was a Chinese product, but someone else on the Gardenweb had just installed in kitchen and she has dogs. She was very happy with it. I would search this site. I am NOT an affiliated sales person with this company. I just remember it was my "back-up" product. Right now I am looking at the 3-strip long planks, just cuz I am not that crazy about bamboo strand and want something with more movement. Good luck.

  • marissa16
    12 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I looked at the ecotimber since it was so highly rated by Consumers but felt it was a little dull and planks narrow. The Taragen synergy as an engineered bamboo, also highly rated but too expensive. I did see a strand solid wood made by Trilium which has a nice shine which I like and is comparable to the ecotimber price. I am more concerned about denting than scratching. Does anyone have experience with Trilium?

  • Floortech
    12 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I will say this...We sell Bamboo..but not a lot of it. We are a serious flooring store and go about our business with a no nonsense approach. The reps that come in our store are from all over. ?The common thread of knowledge on Bamboo is that there are only 3 types that should even be considered. They are Teragren, Wicanders and US. For what it is worth! We only sell one of these and we do sell others....but this is what the experts tell us continually. they say it is all about quality. Good Luck

  • ufo25_mac_com
    12 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'm having the same concern. I originally went to lumber liquidators and found a nice hand scraped strand bamboo flooring. I then went online and researched a load of companies. So far, I like Cali bamboo. My biggest concern was the formaldehyde in the products. Cali bamboo has little to no formaldehyde added in there product. I've read those same reviews about Morning star, but they were outdated. I was emailed a material safety data sheet on Morning Star brand, but no one could tell me how much formaldehyde content was in the morning star product. At the bottom of the sheet there was a disclaimer:

    "The information and data herein are believed to be accurate and have been compiled from sources deemed to be reliable. It is offered for your consideration, investigation and verification. Lumber Liquidators makes no warranty of any kind, express or implied, concerning the accuracy of completeness of the information and data herein. Lumber Liquidators will not be liable for claims relating to any party's use of or reliance on information and data contained herein regardless of whether it is claimed that the information and data are inaccurate, incomplete or otherwise misleading. It is incumbent upon the user to obtain the most up-to-date information".

    So I guess what they mean is that the info on the safety data sheet is BS.

    I'd like to know. Cali bamboo is great, but I actually prefer the hand scraped look they have from Morning Star at lumber liquidators. Does anyone know if Morning Stars 2011 line has added formaldehyde?? (That's the lovely odor you smell from the floors). I can't seem to be able to get a solid answer.

    This is what the safety data sheet states for Morning Star:

    3000 John Deere Road
    Toano, VA 23168
    Emergency phone: 1 800-HARDWOOD
    Fax: 1 757 259 7295
    IMPORTANT NOTICE: This material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) is issued by LUMBER
    LIQUIDATORS. LUMBER LIQUIDATORS flooring will issue a new MSDS when there is a
    change in product specifications and/or regulations. LUMBER LIQUIDATORS will not accept
    any responsibility for any change to its MSDS in content by other person or organization.
    IDENTIFICATION
    Product name: Prefinished Strand Bamboo Flooring
    Trade name: Morning Star Bamboo Flooring
    Other Names: Various
    Manufacturer Information: Lumber Liquidators Inc
    3000 John Deere Road
    Toano, VA 23168
    Tel: (757) 259-4280
    Fax: (757) 259-7295
    www.lumberliquidators.com
    Description:
    This product is composed of bamboo fibers bonded together with urea formaldehyde (UF) resins.
    The fibers are mixed and pressed together to give a unique shade blend and increase hardness. The
    wear layer is finished by 7 coats of polyurethane with aluminum oxide coating manufactured by
    Treffert or Klumpp
    UN number: Not applicable
    Dangerous goods class: Not applicable
    Product Use: Building Materials � Commercial or Residential
    MSDS Morning Star Strand Bamboo Flooring,
    Revision 3, April 2009 Page 2 of 7
    Hazardous ingredients/identity information:
    Name CAS
    #2
    % Agency Exposure Limits Comments
    Bamboo1 None 89-90 OSHA3
    OSHA
    ACGIH4
    ACGIH
    PEL5-TWA6 15 mg/m3
    PEL-TWA 5 mg/m3
    TLV7-TWA 3 mg/m3
    TLV-STEL8 10 mg/m3
    Total dust
    Respirable dust fraction
    Respirable dust fraction
    Inhalable particles
    Urea Formaldehyde resin
    solids
    9011-
    05-6
    10-11 OSHA
    OSHA
    ACGIH
    PEL-TWA 0.75ppm
    PEL-STEL 2 ppm
    TLV - Ceiling 0.3 ppm
    Free gaseous formaldehyde
    (contains less than 0.1%
    free formaldehyde)
    UV Finish
    Polymerized polyurethane
    None 0-1 OSHA
    ACGIH
    PEL-TWA none
    TLV-TWA none
    None
    None
    1 CAS # = Chemical Abstract System. 2 OSHA = Occupational Safety and Health Administration. 3 AGCIH = American
    Conference of Government Industrial Hygienists. 4 PEL = Permissible Exposure Limit. 5 TWA = Time Weighted Average.
    6 TLV = Threshold Limit Value. 7 STEL = Short Term Exposure Limit
    Note: Bamboo is a member of the grass family which has distinct anatomical differences from that
    of wood. Therefore, bamboo would be regulated as an organic dust in a category known as
    "Particulates Not Otherwise Regulated" (PNOR), or Nuisance Dust by OSHA. The ACGIH
    classifies dust or particulate in this category as "Particulates Not otherwise Specified".
    Physical data:
    Physical State: Solid
    Boiling Point: Not applicable
    Freezing Point: Not applicable
    Specific Gravity: 0.58 g/ml
    Vapour Density: Not applicable
    % Volatiles By Volume: 0
    Melting Point: Not applicable
    Vapour Pressure: Not applicable
    Percent Moisture 5% - 9%
    Solubility in H20 (% by wt.): Evaporation Rate (Butyl Acetate = 1): Not applicable
    pH: Not applicable
    MSDS Morning Star Strand Bamboo Flooring,
    Revision 3, April 2009 Page 3 of 7
    Appearance and odor: Bamboo fibers mixed creating a shade blend unique
    to each plank (light yellows for natural, light browns
    for carbonized or a mix of lights yellows and light
    browns shades). This product can also be stained
    with various colors. Low-fuming urea formaldehyde
    resins have a slightly aromatic odor.
    Fire and explosion data:
    Flash Point: Not applicable
    Auto ignition Temperature:
    Not available, however, it is usually accepted that the
    ignition of bamboo begins when the temperature
    reaches 204-260�C (400�500�F).
    (Depends upon duration of exposure to heat source
    and other variables).
    Explosive Limits in Air: Not applicable. See below under "Unusual fire
    and explosion hazards"
    Extinguishing Media
    Water, Carbon dioxide, Dry chemical, Sand.
    Special Fire Fighting Procedures
    None
    Unusual Fire and Explosion
    Hazards
    Sawing, sanding or machining can produce bamboo
    dust as a by-product which may present an explosion
    hazard if a dust cloud contacts an ignition source. An
    airborne concentration of air is often used as the LEL
    for bamboo dust.
    Reactivity data:
    Conditions Contributing to Instability
    Stable under normal conditions
    Conditions to avoid Excessive moisture, condensation or water vapor;
    Open flame or conditions above 400 F.
    Incompatibility
    Avoid contact with oxidizing agents. Avoid open
    flame. Product may ignite when temperature reaches
    in excess of 204�C (400�F).
    Hazardous Decomposition Products
    Thermal and/or thermal oxidative decomposition can
    produce irritating and toxic fumes and gases,
    including carbon monoxide, hydrogen cyanide,
    aldehydes, organic acids and polynuclear aromatic
    compounds.
    Hazardous Polymerization Not applicable
    MSDS Morning Star Strand Bamboo Flooring,
    Revision 3, April 2009 Page 4 of 7
    HEALTH HAZARD INFORMATION
    Carcinogenicity Listing:
    (X) NTP1: Group 2, A & B
    Formaldehyde, Wood dust
    NTP-Group 2: Reasonably anticipated to be a
    carcinogen. A) Limited evidence of carcinogenicity
    from studies in humans which indicates that causal
    relationship is credible. B) Sufficient evidence of
    carcinogenicity from studies in experimental animals
    (X) IARC2 Monographs; Formaldehyde,
    Group 2A, Wood dust, Group 1
    IARC-Group 1: Carcinogenic to humans; sufficient
    evidence of carcinogenicity. This classification is
    primarily based on studies showing an association
    between occupational exposure to wood dust and
    adenocarcinoma of the nasal cavities and paranasal
    sinuses.
    (X) OSHA3 Regulated: Formaldehyde
    IARC-Group 2A: Probably carcinogenic to humans;
    limited human evidence and sufficient evidence in
    experimental animals. Studies of cancer incidence
    among workers in a wide variety of occupations have
    failed to convincingly show carcinogenic activity of
    formaldehyde in humans. Gaseous formaldehyde has
    been shown to cause cancer in certain laboratory
    animals after long-term exposure to very high
    concentrations (14+ ppm); concentrations which are
    far above the levels of formaldehyde gas emitted
    by this product.
    1 NTP = National Toxicology Program
    2 IARC = International Agency for Research on Cancer
    3 OSHA = Occupational Safety and Health Administration
    Exposure hazard:
    Eye Contact
    Wood dust can cause mechanical irritation such
    redness and watering.
    Skin Contact
    Not applicable for this product in its purchased form,
    however various species of wood dust may evoke
    allergic contact dermatitis in sensitized individuals.
    High concentrations of gaseous formaldehyde may
    cause allergic contact dermatitis.
    Ingestion
    Not likely to occur under normal use. If ingested,
    may cause gastrointestinal tract irritation.
    MSDS Morning Star Strand Bamboo Flooring,
    Revision 3, April 2009 Page 5 of 7
    Inhalation
    Not applicable for this product in its purchased form,
    however, wood dust may cause nasal dryness,
    irritation and obstruction. Coughing and sneezing;
    sinusitis and prolonged colds have also been reported.
    Wood dust, depending on species, may cause
    respiratory sensitization and/or irritation. However,
    gaseous formaldehyde may cause respiratory
    difficulties for sensitized/allergic individuals.
    Emergency and first aid procedures:
    Eyes
    Flush eyes with large amounts of water. Remove to
    fresh air. If irritation persists, get medical attention.
    Skin
    Wash affected areas with soap and water. Get
    medical advice if rash or persistent irritation or
    dermatitis occurs.
    Inhalation
    Although not applicable for this product in its
    purchased form. However, if inhalation of bamboo
    dust, remove to fresh air. Get medical advice if
    persistent irritation, severe coughing or breathing
    difficulty occurs.
    Ingestion Not applicable under normal use.
    PRECAUTIONS FOR USE
    Accidental Release Measures
    Not applicable for product in purchased form. Dust
    generated from sawing, sanding, drilling, or routing
    of products may be vacuumed or shoveled for
    recovery or disposal. Avoid dusty conditions and
    provide good ventilation. A NIOSH-approved dust
    respirator should be worn if dust exposure limits are
    exceeded.
    Handling and Storage
    No special handling precautions are required for
    products in purchased form. Keep in cool, dry place
    away from open flame. This product will release
    small quantities of gaseous formaldehyde (â¤0.12
    mg/m3, which is below the E1 classification in
    accordance with EN 717-1:1998 test methods).
    Store in well ventilated area.
    MSDS Morning Star Strand Bamboo Flooring,
    Revision 3, April 2009 Page 6 of 7
    Personal Protective Equipment:
    Respiratory Protection
    Not applicable for product in purchased form. A
    NIOSH-approved dust respirator is recommended
    when allowable exposure limits are exceeded.
    Protective Gloves
    Not required. However, cloth, canvas, or leather
    gloves are recommended to minimize potential
    mechanical irritation slivers from handling and
    machining product.
    Eye Protection Not applicable for product in purchased form.
    Goggles or safety glasses are recommended when
    machining this product.
    Other Protective Clothing or Equipments Not applicable for product in purchased form. Outer
    garments may be desirable in extremely dusty areas.
    Work/Hygiene Practices Follow good hygienic and housekeeping practices.
    Clean up areas where wood dust settles to avoid
    excessive accumulation of this combustible material.
    Minimize blowdown or other practices that generate
    high airborne-dust concentrations.
    Local Exhaust Provide local exhaust as needed so that exposure
    limits are met.
    Special / other None
    OTHER INFORMATION
    Disposal Consideration If disposed of or discarded in its purchased form,
    incineration is preferable. Dry land disposal is
    accepted in most states. It is, however, the user�s
    responsibility to determine at the time of disposal
    whether your product meets RCRA criteria for
    hazardous waste. Follow applicable federal, state, and
    local regulations.
    Transport and Regulatory
    information
    Not regulated as hazardous material by the U.S
    Department of Transportation and the Canadian
    Transportation of Dangerous Goods (TDG).
    Not a controlled product by WHMIS