JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Flooring Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Posted by skeetie219 (My Page) on
Tue, Aug 18, 09 at 9:13

Does anyone have experience with the Sommerset solid wood contry collection- white oak? Costs? Satisfication?
We are considering hardwood for our kitchen. I was quoted a price installed $8.79 from our local carpet store. He called the rep and apparently Somerset is having a special... It does not include trim/reducers etc.. but for 5" hand scarped I think it is a good price...I was considering Lumber Liquidators but there is just to much bad press out there and they never called me back on a quote after the installer came to my house- which I thought was odd.. My other consideration is Anderson hardwood Cimarron collection in the Red Oak. If anyone has experience or feedback it would be greatly appreciated

Also any general installation costs.. it would be laid over an old linoluem floor with no furnitre to move.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

I don't have any personal experience but my flooring installer has used Somerset and recommended it to me when I was looking for oak flooring. I think their prices are generally very good. Someone on this forum recommend TrueHardwoods.com and it seems like their prices among the best I have seen at least for the exotic flooring I was looking for.

Your quote sounds good but I would have them break the price down for materials and labor per square foot. Then you really can make a true comparison. Also make sure you get a bottom line price including any floor prep work. Unless you are buying quarter round from the flooring manufacturer it is generally not expensive.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Did you make a decision?


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

I got a price for Anderson $$$$ although beautiful... I am leaning toward the Somerset I'll just need to pick up some sample to lay in the house. I think that price he quoted was pretty good- only thing it did no include was the reducers/quarter round which I would opt for.. I'm guessing another $400-500 at most. Lumber Liq was coming in around $9.5 to install and I didn't like their floor as much as Somersets.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

The quarter round should be priced per linear foot and like I said if he just buys oak quarter round and finishes it on site the cost should be pretty low. Post some photos when you find a few that you like.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Thanks for the reminder about the oak quarter round... we put all new baseboad and quarter round in our foyer after we re finished the floors.. we did all the staining ourselves since I like to do it..Do you think primed white base would look funny on this type of floor or should I stick with the all wood look - flooring and basebd and quarter round..
I noticed you are on the kitchen forum too... me too since i'm trying to start on this project.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

I think the baseboard should match the wall. As far as the quarter round I will just tell you what my interior designer friend has always told me - the quarter round should match the floor not the wall. I think when it matches the wall it makes it look like the wall is creeping onto the floor. There are probably plenty of people that do it the other way but that way has always looked like the correct way to me.

It is funny how all of these little details add up. After all the trouble and expense you hate to mess up the finished product with a tiny mistake. I am always grateful to have someone to run it by.

I don't know what I would do without these forums. I have learned so much from all of the talented and generous people out here. I have been planning for a long time and I am really hoping to get this thing going soon.

Good luck and keep me posted.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Sounds like a very good price for solid wood. That's a nail down isn't it?
I bought laminate from LL for a rental last month and it came out good. I tried before that to set up a couple of appointments with LL to come to my house to measure for wood floors. But they always change the appt. Where I live the LL estimates are free.....that is probably why they cancel!


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

it is solid wood and it would be nailed..best price I can find on line (Truehards.com and Hosking) for the Somerset product is about $5.35-ish plus delivery charges and installation. Not sure what the going rate is for nail down install but I can't imagine it would anything less than $3.50 sq ft for a straight forward install right? So all things considered if I can get a really good deal locally- I'd rather go that route and give business to my local business owners. I think am going to pursue the quote as far as getting more details and samples in the house on Friday. Like I said, the store owner was saying Somerset was having certain promotions.
Interesting about LL- they charged me $25 for the quote.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

I'm getting ready to order White Oak from the Garrison Collection II. It will be a glue down. That adds a lot to the cost of the installation. I'm buying online and having a local person install it. Wood comes to $3.61 per square foot including delivery. And I think the total install will come to $4.00 per square foot for a total of $7.61. That's the best I could do. Installers here, charge a lot.
LL usually charge $25 but for some reason, not in my area. I'm in Ventura County Ca.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

just confirmed price for install will include a nail and glue down 5" planks...thoughts on combining the 3" and 5" planks. I just like the look in picture but wanted some other's opinions.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

hey skeetie - isn't it solid? Why glue? Just checking.

I have never seen mixed plank widths in person but I agree that in the photos it looks good.

Can you tell me what color you chose and how distressed it is? I can't tell on their website.

Looks like other manufacturers are having sales. I looked at Mohawk today but I think I like the Somerset color options better.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

I have oak/buttercup in my house as a sample..it resembles a golden-ish oak floor but distressed. The distressing looks fairly authentic which we like because we have two Golden retrievers bouncing around the house. So I am hoping their scuff marks won't show as much, it will just blend in the the distress look. The store owner is suggesting glue and nail because anything over a 4" wide plank- he feel might lend itself to cup or split. I also heard this from the LL installer when he came to the house for measuring..

Back to color choices, I'm waiting on a sample piece of the oak in Royal Brown, strictly my preferences...Don't get me wrong Anderson flrs were beautiful but almost double $$. One other thing, the Somerset walnut is really nice but not on promotion- think he quoted me around $11.50 I wasn't that crazy about it for the money. I hoping the Royal Brown in oak works because at the $8.79 price installed I think is a good price. At least one thing will be done for this kitchen project.

As for Mohawk, I would never buy any products due to an issue my mother had with their carpeting. They played real hard ball with her and put a real bad taste in my mouth. And Mohawk did not stand behind their product JMO. I have Shaw/Stanton/Kane products - carpeting which we are very pleased with.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Our 5" distressed white oak that is 9/16 with 4MM wear layer is due to be delivered on Tues. Plan to start install on 8/31. It will be a glue down. I have Thomasville quarter rounds in the kitchen area that match the cabinets (cherry). Going with new baseboards (painted in the other rooms). I will buy and paint and installer will install. Will post pictures when done.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

I must have blanked out the problems I had with Mohawk when we installed 3/4'' oak upstairs. Many pieces of the wood had insect damage that was obviously in the planks before it was finished. It was really annoying given the price we paid. Getting a response took forever and ultimately we just had to live with it.

Back to Somerset I go. I was thinking about the Royal Brown as well.

I have two kids and cannot decide if I want the distressed or not. We have some 3/4'' oak flooring in our kitchen that is not distressed and still does not show all of the abuse it has taken. I guess I need to see it in person.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

msgreatdeals, I can't wait to see pics of your new floor since I know you have been looking for awhile also like me. You will love the wide plank flooring!

odiegirl3, thanks for letting us know that you too had problems with Mohawk. Skeetie219, that $8.79 sounds like a great price installed now that I see what all the material, labor and time all ends up costing.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

received our quote today including 2 reducers/4 stair bull nose pieces and 435sq. total came to $4555/includes tax/freight $65 and $50 for moving our washer and dryer. Not have them do the baseboard work, I'll leave to my cabinet guy since i'm still not sure about what color to do the base board. It will be either a stain or white but i know I will be doing at least a 5" base with shoe.
How does the price sound...?


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

The price sounds very good to me since it includes everything. I can't wait to see pics! I also did a 5.25" baseboard with shoe molding and it is looking nice but I am not done since I ran out of wood.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

odiegirl113- i called somerset directly for a sample of the royal brown. they Fedex'd it to me- got it in 1 or 2 days.

i just made the order with the deposit this afternoon. so excited one thing is done... now on to the cabinets. will post pics as soon as it is down probably in 3-4 wks.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

skeetie - I am so happy for you. So you are going with the Royal Brown? That one really got my attention on their website.

After all of my searching I decided to stick with the Brazilian Teak throughout the rest of my main floor. I am still selecting a brand but I will probably go with Brazilian Direct.

I really loved the Somerset. I could have been happy with quite a few of those floors. I can't say that about some other brands. I thought the finish looked great. The price I got on the color collection was $3.75 for the 3'' and $4.09 for the 4''. I know the distressed would be more but those are great prices.

Keep me posted on your progress. I can't wait to see the pics. Get going on those cabinets! LOL!


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Skeetie, if I did the math correct, that comes to $10.47 per sf. Sounds like a pretty good price.
My floors are going in this week. So far, better than expected. Thought my flooring in the family room was uneven but once the carpet and padding was removed, not so! That is a wood subfloor and the rest of the install will be over concrete. Finally coming to an end of this remodeling. Decided on 4" baseboards which seem large after having 2 1/2".


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

woud love to see pictures after it is installed.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

The floor was installed yesterday, they are gorgeous! I/we love them. Will post pics shortly- still in the throughs on the kitchen.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Here are pics- Royal Brown country collection


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Can you repost pics please? Can's seem to see them but am very anxious to see your floor!
Thank You!


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

http://tinypic.com/useralbum.php?ua=vSPRXj5BO%2FwsHCKER3AETw%3D%3D

try this link


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Your floors are beautiful, thank you for the link. Your cabinets are amazing, can you tell me the company you used? They are perfection in my book.


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

the cabinets are kemper- door is herrington with a 5piece drawer, maple with the toasted almond glaze


 o
RE: Somerset Country collection vs Anderson

Skeetie219- Somerset Royal Brown Country Collection 5" Wide Hardwood Floor Pictures I put in a link below so it will be easy for others to click and view the beautiful floors. Skeetie219, I LOVE your floors so much. Thanks for sharing. I also love your counters and your new kitchen cabinets.

Here is a link that might be useful: Skeetie219- Somerset Royal Brown Country Collection 5


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Flooring Forum
 
 


iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network