Sanding/Refinishing 100 year old Douglas Fir

11 years ago

Hey guys! hoping I can get some help (quickly, because I don't have much time to work on these floors :) ) We have 3/4" 100 year old douglas fir plank floors in our living room. They are dirty and gray for the most part, but parts seem to have a brown paint on them. I was working at getting the paint off with an orbital sander and 60 grit sandpaper, but it does not seem to be working very well and it's exposing a lot of new wood on the higher parts of the wood.

Questions:

1) Is it safe to use a belt sander on these floors or will that ruin the wood?

2) What grit of sandpapers should I be using so that I don't lose the patina? I don't want the floors to look smooth and new, but weathered and old while still being attractive.

3) How much should I sand down to keep the patina? I am not exactly sure what I am looking for. Do I sand til the gray is all gone or do I just sand the gray bit smooth with a fine grain sandpaper?

Help me! :) Thank you!

Comments (6)

gregmills_gw
11 years ago
Sanding the grey off or paint is touchy. Its real easy to sand "too far" and get to bare wood.

I would use 100 grit. You may go thru a lot of paper but you wont be digging deep into the wood. You can drop down to 60 grit but then your going to dig into the wood.

You may just want to think about sanding it all down. The wood as taken on its own aged looked. And a coat of polyurethane will look different on your floor compared to a new fir floor.

As far as a belt sander you can use but too much pressure and you will dig deep into the fir. Its requires finese.
nitetiger4
Original Author
11 years ago
Thanks gregmills.

I'm now wondering if this paint probably has lead in it... Perhaps I shouldn't be sanding it at all.

With 100 grit paper, it is pulling parts of the feathered wood pieces up and splintering it pretty badly. :-\
Related Professionals
Avondale Flooring Contractors · Cutlerville Flooring Contractors · Greenville Flooring Contractors · Johns Creek Flooring Contractors · Little Falls Flooring Contractors · Myrtle Beach Flooring Contractors · Owings Mills Flooring Contractors · Pittsburg Flooring Contractors · Plymouth Flooring Contractors · Thibodaux Flooring Contractors · Conway General Contractors · Oneida General Contractors · Pico Rivera General Contractors · Schertz General Contractors · Woodmere General Contractors
nitetiger4
Original Author
11 years ago
Thanks gregmills.

I'm now wondering if this paint probably has lead in it... Perhaps I shouldn't be sanding it at all.

With 100 grit paper, it is pulling parts of the feathered wood pieces up and splintering it pretty badly. :-\
gregmills_gw
11 years ago
STOP SANDING! If there is ever any doubt that theres lead get it tested. Most big box stores sells instant tests for lead. It will show the pressence of lead. Its not a comprehensive test.

If there is lead you need it removed by a professional. Not doing so can cause serious health risks.

With the flaking you are getting i suggest you hire a pro to take a better look at the floor.

While 100 yr old fir can be sanded it does need to be examined. Some times old wood if not taken care of properly over the years is just a lost cause.

Not saying your floor is shot. I have no way of knowing without visually examining it. But at this stage most highly recommended pros will at the very least come out and give you a bid.
nitetiger4
Original Author
11 years ago
I think that's what we'll do then, hopefully we can do something with it. Since the wood is so thick, I imagine that it can be sanded down to use able wood somewhere, but we should probably have someone else come do it.
brickeyee
11 years ago
"Since the wood is so thick, I imagine that it can be sanded down to use able wood somewhere,"

Any flat cut portions can have 'shelling' (the "feathered wood pieces" you are seeing) and splintering.

Sanding will not improve the issue since the growth ring structure is not going to vary as you sand.