I am in the process of going through this myself. I actually just bought regular unfinished oak reducers and some minwax stain that matched the Novalis. I have the golden oak novalis and ended up mixing minwax gunstock and colonial maple to get the right color. It's not perfect, but pretty darn close!!

Thanks again citymomof3.
The guy at Lowes said they only have gray rubber stair nose with ridges and I said "No thanks, thats not what I'm looking for." Thats the type that is used for commercial applications, not residential unless it's for a basement that isn't used for a living space.
I never thought I would dislike a sunken living room until now and it's too late for that so I will be searching for ideas in every home improvement store I can find.