Return to the Fireplaces Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Posted by ahreno (My Page) on
Mon, Nov 24, 08 at 21:14

I had the pleasure of having a chimney fire a month ago. Nothing major happened and insurance is covering everything which includes tearing down and replacing my chimney and fireplace.

http://picasaweb.google.com/ahreno/NiceHousePictures#5098326681503635522 (-- as you can see the chimney is a major part of the curb appeal of the house so it will be rebuilt on the outside to match. However I'm free to do the inside however I like.

I've pretty much decided on wood but could be convinced to pellet. Gas is probably out as the house isn't plumbed for it.

here is a picture inside: http://picasaweb.google.com/ahreno/NiceHousePictures#5098326406625728178

I'd like to get something a little bit more efficient (A LOT more efficient actually). The fireplace is the main sorce of heat for the downstairs which is 900sq ft. I'll probably put some vents in so the heat can get upstairs as well.

I am debating getting the fireplace rebuilt with the intentions of putting in an insert OR putting in a wood fire box instead.

The benefit of the firebox is it's WAY cheaper since i dont need a full chimney... just the stove piping and then a brick face (to retain the original look). The firebox is a bit more efficient than the insert (73% compared to 65%) and comes with a blower.

What are some of your thoughts on this? Is there anything wrong with doing a fire box? anything i'd regret?

Thanks so much


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

You may want to consider just walling over the place where your fireplace once existed. I have heard the new democratic congress will consider a new and hefty carbon tax on NEW and/or REPLACEMENT fireplace construction, effectively eliminating them from new home construction.
Of course, you can always pay the tax.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Or i could hurry up and get it in before congress does that!

I dont see why a fireplace would warrant a carbon tax... isn't burning wood carbon neutral since that carbon would have been released anyway when the tree decomposed?


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

anyone have any other thoughts on what is best to put in?


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Decomposition of organic material envolves the binding of carbon atoms into other living organisms and eventually into - OIL! By your reasoning, the hydrocarbons from organic material that decayed millions of years ago would already have been released. However, we know we are now releasing those hydrocarbons through the burning of oil/gasoline. Burning wood now immediately releases the bound carbon combined with oxygen (CO2) into the atmosphere. By the way, CO2 accounts for approx. 3 to 5 percent of the green house gases in the atmosphere. H2O,
water vapor, accounts for perhaps 80 to 90 percent of the green house effect. So, maybe the next administration will think about regulating the clouds! If the 250 million autos now on the road were all hydrogen fuel cell vehicles, they would all be putting out - WATER VAPOR!! - a green house GAS!! There IS no free lunch - but the dems. are determined to make it so.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Wow, my type of house. Is it still in that condition? I'll buy it! I love fixing up homes. Do fireplace on inside, imo.

I'd get a wood stove but being there was a chimney fire, I shouldn't recommend a wood stove.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

A fireplace was the latest heating technology--- in about the 10th century. Today it's grossly inefficient as a source of heat.

A fireplace insert is the way to go since heating efficiency is a consideration.

Pellet stoves tend to be sort of expensive to maintain ---and be sure you have service available locally before buying.

The insert is a no brainer especially if you can get wood for free and don't mind the considerable labor involved in cutting, splitting stacking, building and tending fires, cleaning the insert and so on.

Most people get tired of that after a year or two.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

If you do not have natural gas piped in, you can still go with propane gas. If you want energy efficient heat generation, get a direct vent system that uses propane. The efficiency is in the 70% range, unlike conventional fireplace design, less than half that.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Propane is one of the most expensive heating fuels.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Propne is costly, but clean-burning and highly efficient. It's a trade-off.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

"Propane is costly, but clean-burning and highly efficient. It's a trade-off."

Compare the costs of 1 million btu's of heat for a wood insert vs a propane insert. The 75% efficiency of the inserts (both propane and wood) is based on QuadraFire which makes both types.

Propane at $2.50 per gallon delivered:
(1,000,000 / 91,000 btu per gallon) x 2.50 / .75
= $36.63

Hardwood at $180 per cord delivered:
(1,000,000 / 20,000,000 btu per cord) x 180 / .75
= $12

In this example, propane is 2x the cost of wood for the same 1 million btu's of heat.

Take care.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Hi Aherno

Have you gotten your fireplace fixed up yet. Have you thought about a wood burning or pellet insert with blower -- either would heat that entire house. I just got a wood insert -- Pellets were not available when I ordered the insert (September). The thing I don't like about the pellets is the cost is controlled too much by someone else and they are subject to availability. Good luck -- sorry I don't have any tech talk, but I did pay $160 for a cord of wood. You can always look on craigslist for good wood cheap.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

36 elite by fireplace xtrordiner. put a wood stove in your wall. ull need a bigger chase but the unit is the best around.


 o
RE: Insert vs Firebox vs Fireplace please help!!!!!!!

Buy pellets and you're right back to where you were with oil, gas, electric, ect. Someone else telling you what its going to cost to heat your house. Wood is a pain in the ass, but at least you can "do it yourself"

The best is to have the choice, but that's money right there.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Fireplaces Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here