Go to a plumbing supply store.

I appreciate the suggestion. I have tried plumbing stores, fireplace stores, ebay & google. What I found was nothing unless I want to pay for a custom key & bezel, I can get one however the prices ranged from about $75-$100 for the key alone. I was hoping to find something a little more affordable. Thanks.

This is what I use and it works. Not the exact size but close enough. Its called a four way water key.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Water-Key-Four-Way-Steel-G5295132-/331346229997?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0amp;hash=item4d25c63aed

Check out Amazon. I found keys as cheap as $5-10; or a key plus a floor plate as cheap as $24. If you want to be really cheap mount a visegrip at a right angle on what's left of your key...instant right angle lever.

Here is a link that might be useful: Gas valve key

Wow I really appreciate all the replies. I think I am not being clear as to my problem. I have found a bezel and not too expensive on eBay & Amazon. The key though, needs to look and function like an "L" turned upside down, not a "T" because the valve itself is too close to the wall. An L shape means one side can be close to the wall and still turn. I looked at all 20 pages on Amazon. Lots of keys, but all are a T shape and I didn't find any 1/4". Thanks everyone again. I may end up having to have a custom key made or just changing out the whole vale itself which also means going under the house....Eek!

a picture is worth a thousand more words

ken

meanjeans-
I understood that you probably needed an L-shape, and that is why I suggested making one out of the the remains of your key and a visegrip.

This post was edited by kudzu9 on Sat, Jan 10, 15 at 3:25