Return to the Household Finances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

Posted by joyfulguy (My Page) on
Sat, Nov 18, 06 at 10:52

It seems that evaluation of the Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation's system has led to the concludion that far too many of the purveyors are turning up winners.

It seems that, when they brought their tickets in for checking, the machine said that the holder was a winner, but the amount was in small print, down in the corner.

It is said that a number of store employees were telling the holders of the tickets, who hadn't signed them, that they'd won a free ticket, give the holder a ticket ...

... then turn in the ticket for the substantial amount of the win as their own.

One man who claimed he'd won $200,000 was refused by the lottery corporation, and they fought in court for several years. Finally he won in court.

After having spent over $400,000. in legal fees.

Now, after this matter was brought to the fore by our national broadcaster, the Lottery Corporation are quite distressed, and saying that they are taking immediate steps to make the system more secure - the holders of tickets can have them scanned themselves in a machine at the outlet.

Governments having become addicted to their cut of the take by the Lottery Corporation, an agency not at arm's length from the government.

Who said that governments can't become addicts?

A simple way to avoid such problems?

Don't buy tickets in the first place!!

If one can justify them as "entertainment", maybe they make some sense ...

... but if one should happen to call them an "investment" - forget that!

Around here, many say that lotteries are "A voluntary tax on the stupid".

And - it ain't just governments that become addicted to them!!!

Have yourself a lovely weekend, everyone.

ole joyful

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

Wow, OJ, I thought you had won and were having a problem which case, I was thrilled for you.

Seems there are scammers everywhere, and one has to be both smart and careful.


RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

Chemical girl (mot "Material" girl, I assume),

Sorry - I'm not a winner.

I couldn't be - I don't buy tickets.

Did you read the replies over on Kitchen Table the other day when someone asked what we'd do if we came into a lot of money?

(Quite a few became quite charitable).

I remember a song made rather famous by "The Bare-Naked Ladies" singing group a few years ago, "If I had a Million Dollars", saying that they'd buy me a house ... a K car ... a green dress (but not fur - that's cruel), etc.

I thought that about a million of us should write them, asking whether, if they had $100,000, if they'd buy us 1/10th of a house.

Now, of course, that they (probably) *have* a million dollars (or close to it) ...

... maybe they've developed short memories?

Have an interesting week.

ole joyful

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

More problems afoot.

It appears that this evaluation of the Ontario Lottery system has turned up information that far more of the sellers of scratch-and-win tickets are winning than would normally be expected.

It seems that some have found a way to select winners without scratching, or an amount so minimal that it's scarcely noticeable.

Plus at least one, who's interested in math, found a way to use the serial numbers to evaluate winners. I beleive that the report said that he was good enough to alert the Lottery Corporation of the problem.

Dad used to say that wherever you might find a stash of honey - you'd find bees. Some of them rascally ones?

ole joyful

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

The latest is that the Lottery Corporation is considering refusing to allow purveyors or employees (some 14,000, I think they said) from buying the tickets - which they claimed that no other province or state does).

They said that the problem with that possible apparent solution is, as I'd thought when I first heard the idea suggested, that the worker selling the tickets has dozens of brothers, sisters, parent, aunts, uncles, cousins, friends, etc.

Don't you just shed a tear for our poor, addicted government, having to deal with such problems?

Will have to send them to an addict-recovery program, I guess.

Have yourself a great holiday (if you're a U.S. resident).

ole joyful

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

The government isn't addicted to gambling. They aren't gambling. They are assured of making a profit. No risk.

If they were to get rid of the lottery, then they would have to tax the people in some other way in order to make up for their loss of income. Personally, I'd prefer they keep the lottery around as a 'voluntary tax' where I can choose to contribute or not.

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

The problem with that kind of voluntary tax is that it taxes poor people far more highly than wealthy ones. People who have a lot of money to spare may spend a bit of extra money on the entertainment of a lottery or other gambling. But it is poor people who are so desperate that they will spend money they need to use elsewhere on the extremely low odds that they will win big. People take more risks when they are desperate, even stupid risks.

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

Lotteries (bingo, etc.) ...

... a voluntary tax on the stupid.

The governments are addicted - not to the gambling, but to the easy revenuwe that it brings in.

To the politicians - painless.

To the (largely poor folk) who participate - a con job.

As a personal financial advisor - I wanted to see my clients (and everyone, as a matter of fact) prosper.

And that includes folk who scarcely have a pot to dribble into, in many impoverished parts of the world.

But - we load the economic dice against them.

The rich get richer - and the poor get screwed.

Have a lovely weekend - and a great week ahead.

ole joyful

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

Another problem, now.

The Atlanic Lottery have been accused in a national TV program of having problems, as well ... (by our national TV broadcaster - who was the agency that brought the Ontario Lottery issues to light).

It seems that the selling agencies' people are having about 10 times the proportion of payouts that one would expect, in the normal course.

At first, the leaders said that they were satisfied with the situation.

But now they're carrying on an investigation.

By the way - did some of your see my offer made here a while ago?

If you want to give me a dollar ...

... I'll give you 35 c3nts.

Which is about the payout on Nevada tickets, the slots in the casinos, etc. (except the ones in high-traffic areas), and some lottery tickets, though with some it's a higher percentage, I hear.

Strange - haven't had any takers. I wonder why?

Have a lovely spring weekend, everyone.

ole joyful

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

The Ontario Lottery Corporation and their boss have just parted company - by mutual agreement.

o j

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

Provincial Ombudsman report Monday castigated them for long-term improper actions.

For a number of years it appears to have been evident that there were too many claims made by their purveyors ... but not enough remedial action was taken.

When one buyer's ticket was claimed by a seller, the guy sued and the OLGC fought him in court for years, finally lost.

Seems to have been millions improperly paid out.

"See no evil" seems to have been at least part of their guidelines.

The report says that they need an outside agency evaluating them.

As Dad used to say, "When you have a pot of honey - you attract a lot of bees".

Bears, too, it seems.

ole joyful

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

Sued for 1.1 *billion* ... by a guy who's been buying tickets for years ... ever since they began in '75, it seems.

Start of a class-action lawsuit.

One lawyer says that everyone who ever bought a ticket should get a free one!

Second highest paid of out Provincial Police personnel has been in charge of security, so some are saying that another investigator should be brought in.

ole joyful

RE: Problem with Ontario (Canada) Lottery payout

There was an old man, Bob Edmonds, who claimed that he'd been done out of his rightful prize win, and fought the Lottery Corporation in court for three or four years, though it now appears that they'd been aware of a number of unusual claims by a number of their purveyors for some time.

His story was told some time ago by an investigative program on our National Broadcaster's TV system.

In the original settlement of his $250,000., he was to keep quiet.

He fought for a longer time to be allowed to talk about the issue, and to have his lawyer's and court costs of $72,000. covered by the OLGC.

Eventually he won.

The OLGC agreed just before the weekend to cover his lawyer's and court fees, and to apologize.

He knew about that, and the message arrived at the beginning of the week.

His lawyer says that he knew that it was coming, but had not seen the letter ... when, after fighting cancer for several years, he died on the weekend.

One wonders - did all of the hassle about the Lottery Corporation cause a greater deterioration in his health?

Or - did he stubbornly keep going longer, refusing to be bulldozed??

We'll never know - but we do owe the old guy a vote of thanks for having pursued the issue, and to the national broadcaster, as well.

ole joyful

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Household Finances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here