Debit Card vs. Cash - Small Merchants

15 years ago

Greetings!

Last December, I posted here and got excellent advice about setting up appropriate spending categories in Pocket Quicken for my PDA. Not only have I gotten everything set up (and purchased a license for the program so it won't disappear), I've been developing a habit of entering checks/receipts the day that I spend for anything, from groceries to online payments/purchases. I've even learned how to split my receipts into several different categories, so I know all the different directions my money is going. While I realize this is "old hat" to some, I'm pretty proud of myself for getting this far in tracking my finances, since I've historically been too lazy to do so.

So my hubby and I have finally decided that it's time I transitioned from a paper checkbook to a debit card for the household account. I have a debit card for my personal account, but the daily limit is too low to actually make it very "usable" for things like gas/groceries (it's a credit union card - $100 per day limit), and all of the household expenses come out of the household account anyways. I'd resisted the debit card for several reasons, mainly security and a mental willingness to pay more for "stuff" when using plastic (the reason I'm paying down credit cards now). But I think I have the spending under control, and with more and more stores/restaurants refusing to take checks anymore, I either have to get a debit card, or carry quite a bit of cash with me (since I'm trying to pay the credit cards off, not use them at the moment). Right now, I don't carry cash at all, since for me, it's far easier to spend cash than writing a check (I know it's all mental - but it's there).

The only thing I worry about with the debit card is smaller merchants. I've read that if you are purchasing a smaller amount that it actually costs the merchant more if you use a debit/credit card than the purchase itself. I try to shop locally whenever possible, and I don't plan to carry my checkbook once I start using the debit card. I'm mainly thinking of my weekly/bi-weekly cricket purchases at the local pet store - $6.00 each time, or the occasional small purchase at the health food store.

So can anyone give me advice on when to use the debit card vs. when to pay cash - ie, what dollar amount (approx.) is the "cut off" point for smaller merchants having to pay more in fees? I figure I'll just take out a small amount of cash ($20.00 or so) every month to carry for those times, so local "mom & pop" stores don't get hit with that extra fee for smaller purchases.

Thanks for any advice on this!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

joyfulguy
15 years ago
Sorry to report that I don't have any advice to offer regarding your plastic question, Jamie. Would the Credit Union increase the amount that you could use the card for, daily? But that doesn't give any info on what fees they may charge small merchants.

I came on to say how great it is to see your post ... I haven't heard from you in a long time and wondered how you've been doing. It would be interesting to a number of us if you could give us an update over on the KT.

ole joyful
pacman1062
15 years ago
Hi Jamie,

Great progress. I second OJ's suggestion to call the CU. I would think they will raise that daily limit. As a matter of fact, I'd be surprised if it isn't actually higher. Sounds like an old card and maybe you just missed the notice.

As far as fees go. I know a couple people that fall into the Mom & Pop class of business. Their fees for MC/V purchases seem to run about 25 cents per transaction + 1.7% of the total sale.

So, for the small guys that adds up quick. If you charged a cup of coffee or a small drink the guy would be loosing on the deal.

On the debit side, I don't know if they all pay a fee or not, I think they do and I think it's a flat fee of 25cents per transaction.

I'd try to carry at least some cash for the small stuff.

Hope this helps,
Dan
Related Discussions
Debit Card Hacked -- Possibly Because of a Seed Order
Q
Comments (15)
I've worked bank fraud for 25 years. Your card can be hacked virtually anywhere... could be a data access on the part of the merchant, someone actually swiping your card into an encoding machine, a keystroke logger on your computer. Personally, I use paypal, but I have paypal linked to a credit card, not my bank account. I have greater dispute privileges that way. Nancy_Drew is right, though, the danger with the debit card is your checking account has the potential to be drained quickly, and the banks aren't necessarily quick about putting the money back in. Dawiff, your suspicions may very well be correct, but you should make sure you don't have any malware on your computer..
...See More
Debit card holds
Q
Comments (15)
Don't forget that the S&L debacle of the 80's was also triggered by changes instituted by our government. Income tax law changes made the ownership of real estate much more financially rewarding, which of course created a higher demand for real estate, thereby drove up the price. Developers saw a fabulous market and built more and more office buildings, shopping centers, apartment buildings, etc. At about the same time S&L's were allowed to invest in more types of loans and other investments. This was done in part because they were being creamed holding long-term low-rate home loans and paying out high interest on deposits. 15% CD's were not unheard of at that time, and 12% were common. Meanwhile the 30 year mortgages they had made a few years back were only paying 5 or 6% interest to the S&L's. These changes were both made by the government, but not as a concerted effort. In each case the laws were changed to address one issue. Then, at about the same time most S&L's had a lot of money lent on overpriced real estate, Congress decided to change real estate tax laws again - making real estate a less attractive investment. Not surprisingly, real estate values tanked at a time when many markets were way overbuilt to begin with. S&L's were left with loans that had looked solid at one point and found themselves having to foreclose loans on buildings that they couldn't sell and could sometimes could not even lease out. Yes there were crooks in the S&L business, who helped ruin some institutions, and we all read about those. But plenty of honest institutions found themselves in severe trouble as well. I worked for a life insurance holding company, managing income property loans. I made a career change just before the bottom dropped out, but I still talked with several people who had to deal with that mess. In the case of my former employer, they stopped making new loans in Texas when the markets started getting overbuilt. But they still had plenty of existing loans when the markets tanked. Being a nationwide company, only a small percentage of their loans were in severely depressed markets. But S&L's generally lent in their immediate area, or at least their home state. I don't remember if this was due to regulation or custom. At any rate, even the best-run S&L in many markets nearly collapsed. ------------------------------ Whew, I didn't mean to write so much! At any rate, my point is that the best-intentioned body of lawmakers will never understand every ramification of the laws they pass. They can easily cause as many problems as they fix. In the case of the unreasonable debit card holds, it really is a minute percentage of institutions that do this. In this case, I believe the gas station is the party at fault. In the whole debit-card system, banks have no way of verifying the amounts that merchants submit. Most merchants are honest and reasonably careful - if for no other reason than that they want repeat business.
...See More
Debit Cards vs. Checks
Q
Comments (25)
One thing to know about debit cards...you cannot put a stop payment on a transaction. You must dispute it and wait. I had a legitimate reason to stop payment on a transaction, but found I could not because it was on my debit card. I was told by the bank that it's essentially like cash when it comes to payment. Whenever we need to purchase a big ticket item, or have a repair done, we use our credit cards...gives us some protection, and in some cases, the CC covers a longer warranty. I use checks very, very infrequently. Debit or credit cards almost exclusively. And every one of our household bills is done with on-line bill pay. I set up regular recurring payments (mtg, car insurance, etc) and for variable payments, I can set the amount I want to pay. Even for places (like the garbage co) that don't have electronic payment option, my bank sends them a check, but immediately deducts the payment from my account as if it were an electronic payment. I absolutely love it. No paper, no stamps, no finding a mail box, no late fees, and a permanent record of what was paid where all on my computer screen. My mother actually turned me on to it! I quit writing checks to stores when I got the 3rd degree after writing a check. Needed ID, managers approval, yada yada. But swipe my plastic and no problemo. Honestly, it'd be easier for an identity thief to clean you out with plastic than a check, but the stores act like you're a criminal for writing a check (unless you're white haired, barely reach the counter and take 13 minutes to complete your transaction )
...See More
Car loan for recent college grad vs paying cash?
Q
Comments (25)
I'm out of the shadows again on this one. 600 is not that great considering sub prime lending can start at 650. But at her age, she is just building experience on her file. The FICO algorithm models for the likelihood of delinquency within 24 months, so the factors going into that calculation correspond with the model value. The only way to improve credit score is to have credit activity. And installment credit is considered more favorable than revolving credit. Also impacting interest rates and loan approval is the ability to pay. Permanent employment is less risky than sub work, so you get a more risky loan for a higher rate. That only changes when you have a consigner who reduces the risk. My first solo car loan came with a 10% rate in the early 90's. Living debt free is great. However few people can afford a home with cash, at least where I live. Establishing credit with 7% interest on a $5,000 auto loan makes a lot more sense when you decide to buy a home with a 30 year amortized loan at a less favorable rate based on your lower credit score. Finally, there are several industry modifiers available with FICO, auto being one. So the version of your score the dealer pulls is different than the one you receive when you go online. And many lenders will have custom models that may, or may not, act as an overlay to FICO. They model for a number of factors including delinquency, bankruptcy and retention. FICO is to credit modeling as Kleenex is to tissue. Although I know the deal is done, I thought this might add some clarification for others.....Just some additional information for consideration from experience.
...See More
chris8796
15 years ago
I wouldn't worry about it and use whatever form you prefer. The only numbers I've seen was from Starbucks in 2004. They paid 8 cents for PIN based and 10 cents for signature Debit card transactions on a $3 purchase.

The merchant should adjust the prices, if needed, to remain profitable. Your also assuming a cash transacation is "free". Handling and processing cash transactions have plenty of hidden costs. Most retail managers I know would love to only work with electronic transactions.
jamie_mt
Original Author
15 years ago
Thanks guys. I've checked with the credit union, and due to my previous bad habit of overdrafts, I'm stuck with that lower limit. That's basically just my "mad money" anyways, so it's not important. The debit card that I signed up for from our household bank account has a very high limit ($1000 per day), so no problems there.

Small merchants often have higher prices already, so I'm not going to contribute to making those prices even worse by using a form of payment that costs more when I can help it (if they raise their prices, I'm still the one that ends up paying the fee, & more people will choose to shop elsewhere). So I'll use cash for anything under $10 or so, and the debit card for everything else. That should work fine, I think. I'm not worried about the big chains, just the very small local businesses.

Thanks Ed - I'll try to stop by the KT later. Not sure if I still know anyone over there or not!
hendricus
15 years ago
Five years ago it was about 7-8 dollars. I only saw one small grocer that had a sign up for a minimum purchase of $7 if using a card. Convenience stores raised their margins from 33% to 40 % to cover the costs.
dadoes
15 years ago
The business where I work is charged about 3% to 3.1% aggregate over a monthly period on credit card transactions. Debit cards aren't accepted on the terminal, so I can't say if the fees would be the same, lower, or higher. Assuming it would be the same, I don't consider 3 cents on the dollar to be high.

Debit Card vs. Cash - Small Merchants

Comments (6)

joyfulguy

pacman1062

Related Discussions

chris8796

jamie_mt
Original Author

hendricus

dadoes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Debit Card vs. Cash - Small Merchants

Comments (6)

joyfulguy

pacman1062

Related Discussions

chris8796

jamie_mtOriginal Author

hendricus

dadoes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

jamie_mt
Original Author