Return to the Home Disasters Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Posted by Cyd1900 (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 11, 02 at 9:45

I have never had this problem before. There is a greenish buildup on the bottom of my toilet bowl that will not come off. I thought it was some sort of mineral buildup (lime, hard water, etc.) I have emptied the bowl of its water and poured in a lime/rust remover liquid and let it sit. But no matter how much I scrubbed, it wouldn't come off. Any suggestions?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Could it be a copper precipitate from copper pipes? If this is a copper-based stain I'm not sure how to remove the stain. Anybody else have any good ideas?

Denise


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Bleach is the only thing I can think of besides Lime Away.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

If the ususal stuff from the supermarket , bleach and limeaway etc, fails there is a nasty one sold at serious hardware stores called santee or santeen or something to that affect. Expensive and nasty stuff. It ate the metal out of my toilet brush. You will want real gloves and eye protection.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Try to find a thing in the hardware store called a "Pummie." It's a long pumice stone (like the ones you can use on your feet) but has a plastic handle. It was the only thing that cleaned all the stains from the toilets in the home I bought last year. (The entire house was filthy and the toilets were the worst.) My handyman wanted me to replace all the toilets because they were so incredibly dirty and stained. Instead, I found the Pummie and scrubbed with it several times until the toilets were clean. Give it a try. Costs about $6.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Try ZUD you can get it at target I think or some grocery stores..take the water out and then just make a paste and scrub lightly..it is miracle stuff


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

There is a product called Barkeepers Helper. It comes in a cardboard cylinder like Comet. You can find it in the car cleaning aisle at the groceery store. It WILL work! It works like magic when nothing else does. Better than Lime-Away (which never worked for me because the stains were so bad when I bought the house.)


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Try muratic acid. Find it in the pool chemicals. Use it carefully, don't splash, ventilate the room. Wear rubber gloves, don't get it on anything!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I second the use of a pummice stone, used for removing dry/rough skin from feet. Any pharmacy should have some. I also thought I would have to buy several new toilets for the house we bought. Spent about 1/2 hour scrubbing each toilet, stains came out and they look like new.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I tried one of thgose pumice brushes, I scrubbed and it eneded up scratching the finish off, revealing tan ceramic. Looks terrible!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Try the pumice stone. They are cheap, easy to find and work great. I used them to clean old lime and hard water stains off the bathrooms here. I have a cabinet full of dozens of cleaning products I tried first that were useless.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

How about steam cleaning it?


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Had a toilet that was really bad all over. Nuffin cleaned it. I tried many different grocery store cleaners.
New once per week housekeeper told me to buy a product called 'The Works' and she would use that to clean it. Said it might take her several times.

I bought some and started using that bathrooms toilet and everytime before using it would swish the brush and scrub a bit,,,, then after flushing would squirt some more 'The Works' in.

Housekeeper returned the following week to find that one was now a spotlessly clean toilet.

I don't know why that particular toilet now gets ring around the bowl within a week. That's the only one out of three here that does that. Must be something dissimilar metals in the line feeding it.

The Works says active ingreadiant is Hydrogen Chloride 16% which with water is Hydroclorid Acid. It works very well here - about $2 for a good sized bent neck squirt bottle.

Here is a link that might be useful: http://www.theworkscleans.com/toilet.htm


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Could that quick ring line be from damage to the porcelin from cleaners? I used a pumice stone and ended up with frequent ring lines afterwards. Just wonder if the original surface is breached in any way, will it permit continuous problems down the road?

If worse comes to worse, toilet bowls ARE fairly inexpensive.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I just went at the rings in my toilet wtih the advice of this thread. I tried The Works, didn't do anything. Tried Barkeeper's Friend - that worked but took a LOT of elbow grease -- I think I scrubbed the toilet for over a half hour straight. I've still got two more toilets to do and would like to find an easier way.

I went to home depot to ask about the pumice stone but the guy looked at me like I was from outer space. Does anyone know of a store where I could buy one of these things? Thanks!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Our local Ace Hardware has them...Pumie heavy duty scouring stick. Was in the aisle with the cleaning supplies. Read the directions...it can damage the finish and must be used wet.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

One of my toilets was stained horribly (it was like that when I purchased the home). It was too disgusting to use, in truth. I tried nearly everything, even letting Coke sit in the bowl (really, Coca Cola is supposed to remove the stains) - I even did the pummice stone, I would tear into the job while my son was taking a bath. Lime Away, CLR, none of it worked.. well, the pummice might've, but it wasn't worth the effort, it was taking forever. I ended up buying a new toilet - what a difference, so I've now fully redone the BR. :)


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Pumice stones work very well not just on the toilets but also the BBQ and many other areas around the home. I was having a lot of trouble finding a pumice stone in any stores ( other than the sort sold for foot care and way to costly to consider cleaning with them ) so I started shopping online. The best price I found was at Marko Inc. Just $3.85 each and shipping/handling was 7.00 when I ordered 4. Much better price than Ace had!

Here is a link that might be useful: Marko Inc. Pumice Stone


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

2 other products you may want to try....let the water drain below the stain. Use hydrogen perocside on the stain. It may turn a bit yellow on the first application. The more applications, the more the stain should subside. Something we used to use in the Army....hot lemon juice. Pour it slowly on the stain. Then let the water build up to cover the stain and pour a generous amount of lemon juice in and let it soak.....oh yeah, here's another one...there are teeth cleaners that contain pumice...that's what the Hygenist uses during your dental cleaning and polishing....maybe that would be less punishing than the stone? I guess I'd better hide my toothbrush in case my wife reads this!!!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I got the toilet stain out of the bowl and here's how. I used the same stuff I've used on the Glasstop stove we have. I used Cerama Bryte glass-ceramic cooktop cleaner with a Scott Brite no scratch pad. I first turned off the water to the toilet and used a small cup to get as much water out of the bowl as I could. Then I poured the cleaner on the stain and started scrubbing with the pad. It took about 20 or so and it was done. At first it might not seem to work but it is. Keep scrabbing and add more cleaner if you need it. My bowl looks brand new again with no scratches.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I have tried many different things to try to get the stains out of my toilet bowls, but the ONE thing that actually worked was using Cerama-Bryte.

I removed most of the water from the bowl and used a scratchless scrubbing pad to apply the Cerama-Bryte to the stain and scrubbed like mad. This was fairly effective at removing a lot of the stain. I wanted to take a break from the scrubbing, so I decided to try dabbing on globs of Cerama-Bryte directly to the stain all around the bowl and left it sit for about 1/2 hour. When I came back and resumed scrubbing, the stain came off a lot easier.

Depending on how bad your stains are, you may need to do this 2 or 3 times and it does require elbow grease, but it does work!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I was able to clean a very soiled toilet with white vinegar. No harsh chemicals, no fumes, etc. The bowl seemed to be very corroded with years of mineral build up, and vinegar was the only thing that actually worked, along with the elbow grease using a 3M sanding screen. For the really tough spots, I picked at the deposits with a screwdriver, and for a finish, to amend any scratches I created with the screwdriver, I cleaned the bowl with BarKeeper's Friend (the best cleanser there is). I am amazed that the two toilets I thought I was going to have to replace look brand new! Hope this helps.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Super iron out will work but wear a mask, open all the windows and run a fan. This will clean it but may knock you out.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

get a green toilet


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

There was a nasty looking toilet with a resume that hit about 10 years. Let's just say that toilet needed therapy not cleaning!

In any case, I started off simple; tried Lysol toilet cleaner: nothing.
Then White vinegar for 4 hours: nothing. Just a bad stink.
Cola overnight: Nothing. Stains were accentuated instead of extenuated which made me want to exenterate the thing!

Hydrogen peroxide, Scrubbing Bubbles, elbow grease, etc...
None of these made even a slight dent!
Then I read here and went with some advice...
And let me say 'The Works' works!

I gloved up, drained out most of the bowl water with a cup and emptied the whole Works container in there. I kept it the suggested 10 minutes. At first, I could not see if the stains were coming off since the it's a thick blue color. I started scrubbing with the toilet brush and noticed what was inital dirt on the brush. I then realised it was the actual stains peeling off! I kept it on for about 20 minutes longer, scrubbed more and most of it was gone! I wanted to make sure and so flushed. I only wish I kept it longer since most but not all of it was gone. I had to finish the job light scrubbing with a pumice stone and Comet with Bleach.

But trust me, 'The Works' was what had the most affect!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Use oven cleaner. Turn on the vent and close the door until ventilated.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Ammonia is the best thing for copper stains.

It will remove them.

Ordinary household ammonia may take a long time, so stop by a gun store and get some Sweets7.62 copper solvent.

It is stronger ammonia in a semi-gel designed to remove copper from gun barrels.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I used a black plunger in the toilet only to find out that it left the bowl looking dark in cooler . Cant remove the discoloration. What should I do to remove the darkness?


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

there is one solution to this problem. it is called old fashned elbow grease. Cheap as well. All one needs is one of those cheap sponge sanding blocks and a little bit of VIM cleaner. Just push as much water as possible out of the bowl, next roll up your slevves and rub away. use the natural feel of your fingers to find the rough spots and concentrate on these areas. Max time 5 minutes. flush toilet and check for missed spots.
PS: your hands will come out spotless clean as well. This will not hurt your toilet finish. the industry has built their product well.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Try "Lysol toilet bowl cleaner" -. First throw a bucket of water into toilet bowl so water level is low. Squirt Lysol ( it has a DUCK neck) all around. Let sit for 15 minutes. Scrub with toilet brush and flush.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Get yourself a $2 Pummie pumice stone and start scrubbing the proceline. It will come off.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

etting ready to move and can not remove the brown colored stain in the bottom of my toilet bowl. Please HELP


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

After buying our current home and spending years scrubbing our Master baths toilet with a pumice stone to get the brown stains out I finally came upon a product called "The Works". It has been 2 months and I have yet to do anything other then the occasional swish with the toilet brush.

I let The Works soak for a few hours, cleaned with the brush then reapplied and let it soak again for a few more hours.

Wish I knew about this stuff years ago!!!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

The Works is the best thing I've ever seen! I've used it for years. Don't buy at large discount stores though, their stuff is watered down. I only buy at Dollar General or some other small store.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

The stain eraser can be purchased at pool supply stores $15. It seems softer than a pumice stone, more like a rubbery substance and takes off the dark ring in toilets with a little effort. The Works and Iron Out work great for rust/iron stains.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Ladies and Gentlemen, I just want to caution on ever putting all sorts of things in the toilet at once such as bleach/ammonia/other cleaning products. You can get a burn, a bad one and not just on your hands it can get in your eyes. It sort of fizzes up like a science experiment so please only use one product at a time and the advice to use extra strong gloves and eye covering was a good one when going in for a scrub like this one! Good luck and I am going to try some of these good suggestions for cleaning products! P.S. I have been able to get Bar Keepers Friend at Willams Sonoma.


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Hydrogen peroxide. Plain ordinary type purchased at drug store for about $1. Leave it in overnight. Then use any ordinary toilet cleaner and brush to clean. Repeat if necessary. (One time use will also make a BBQ grill surface like new. Like new. Works on my porcelain kitchen sink too. )


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I had this same problem when I moved into my house. The previous owner (my mother in law) loved her some pumice stone! I think this is what brought on the majority of the problem and gave the buildup and stains something to stick to. Anyhow in addition to the damage from harsh scrbbing and lots o pumice it is a low water toilet and is a nightmare!!! I found this stuff at walmart called Liquid Lightening - Toilet bowl and hard surface cleaner not drain opener. I drained most of the water from the toilet and sprayed this stuff in let it sit for a few minutes (about 20) then used a peice of old nylon screen to scrub. Took very little elbow greese and it came off in scaly chunks. It is the best cleaner ever. It is very harsh but worked wonders. I went to buy some a couple of weeks ago and they no longer carry it. I was able to find it on ebay for twenty dollars but use to pay only six for hte same bottle :( hoping walmart starts carrying it again because it is frustrating to find something that works only to lose the ability to find it!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

I've tried everything including bleach, Bar Keeper's powder, CLR, Kaboom Toilet Bowl cleaner and many others. Nothing would get the "ring" out. My husband suggested Cascade w/Dawn gel cleaner. I just laughed and said what could it hurt. I left the gel on for several hours and low and behold it took it off. I've been trying to deal with the toilet bowl rings for almost 2 years. We have well water with a water softner. Needless to say, he got a huge kiss!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Use a Pumie stone. Did this and within a few minutes of elbow grease it was clean as could be. Cheap, too


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

After reading all your great suggestions I learned that the 2 most reliable forms of removing stains from the toilet are the Pumie Stone and "The Works." We went to buy them both and the store only carried "The Works" so that's what we bought.
We emptied out some of the water, coated the bowl, and left it over night. This morning we grabbed the toilet brush and to our amazement chunks of hard water and lime scale came right off with very little effort!
Thank you so much! I have been fighting this losing battle for years and with your help I have won!!


 o
RE: Can't remove toilet bowl stain buildup

Hard water scale usually succumbs to distilled white vinegar pretty quickly.

All you have to do is pour a gallon into the bowl and let it sit overnight.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Home Disasters Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here