recent pic.

close up of porch

With the craftsman feel, I would paint the trim a dark color contrast to the house rather than white. Beautiful home.

Maybe this will help

Here is a link that might be useful: historic paint colors

Agreed. Light trim would look foolish.

Siding: BM Woodcliff Lake

Trim: BM Briarwood

Muntins: Black

Wow! Thanks for the ideas. I never considered dark trim. Here are a couple pics that inspired the house and the color scheme. But I'm definitely going to consider dark trim now! I'm searching for pics to inspire that new direction.

I'd vote for darker, earthier colours. I've attached a link to a house plan I've looked at-- I like the colors they used in the pics of the house.

Here is a link that might be useful: Craftsman-ish house

The inspiration house is pseudo-Victorian. Different ball of wax.

Earth colors are the way to go.

I vote earthy colors, the body of the house either a mossy green or dark brown, trim dark taupe. Love the exterior!

sweet-tea, that's the BM Woodcliff Lake brown siding and Briarwood trim combo I suggested: brown and taupe. With black muntins. So gorgeous.